Pesticides: proposals to halve them in Europe postponed

Pesticides: proposals to halve them in Europe postponed

Food · ·

The presentation of the legislative package has been postponed to a date yet to be determined. And the European lobby observatory accuses industries of exploiting the war to exert political pressure. The presentation of the legislative package has been postponed to a date yet to be determined. And the European lobby observatory accuses industries of exploiting the war to exert political pressure.

It was scheduled for 23 March, but the European Commission has decided to postpone – to a date yet to be determined – the presentation of the "nature protection" legislative package, which contains the new proposals for achieving the goal set out in the Green Deal – in particular in the Farm to Fork and Biodiversity strategies – of reducing pesticide use in the European Union by 50 per cent by 2030.

pesticidi
The Farm to Fork strategy aims to halve pesticide use in Europe by 2030 © iStock

As reported by Euractiv.com, the Commissioner for food safety Stella Kyriakides, when questioned on the matter during the EU agriculture ministers' meeting on 21 March, reportedly stated: "It could be argued that the generalised geopolitical uncertainty does not allow this proposal on the sustainable use of pesticides the political space it needs for further appropriate discussions and reflection."

Pesticides, the accusation against lobbies: "They're using the war to undermine green objectives"

The consequences of the Russia-Ukraine conflict are therefore placing a new brake on the European Union's agroecological transition, following the decision to extend agricultural production to ecological focus areas (EFAs). Several member states agree on suspending stability objectives in favour of food security, while a new report by Corporate Europe Observatory accuses agro-industrial lobbies of exploiting the war to undermine EU green policies.

"It is shameful that the war in Ukraine and the food crisis are being exploited to serve the usual lobbies, rather than acting as a driving force to make our food production independent of fossil fuels, pesticides and fertilisers, by limiting meat consumption and eliminating intensive farming and the consequent massive imports of animal feed," Eleonora Evi of Europa Verde also stated.

The Pesticide Action Week and the need for resilient food systems

Pan Europe noted how the postponement came paradoxically during the Pesticide Action Week, an awareness initiative on the risks to human and environmental health arising from pesticide use, and underlines how the current crisis linked to the prices of animal feed, petrol and synthetic fertilisers highlights how vulnerable the intensive farming model is, confirming the need to make our food systems resilient.

The European Commission's contradictions

On the very same day on which the pesticides issue was supposed to be addressed, the European Commission published a communication on "Safeguarding food security and reinforcing the resilience of food systems", in which it set out its response to rising food prices and difficulties in sourcing raw materials, resulting from the war in Ukraine.

A response based, as stated therein, on three keywords: "security", "stability" and "sustainability", in the belief that "the transition to sustainable agriculture, as envisaged by the Green Deal and Farm to Fork, is the only path to food security."

These are sentiments shared by organisations such as Slow Food, which has nonetheless renewed its appeal to the EU not to yield to lobbies, and has highlighted the inconsistencies between intentions and actions and the contradictions of the European Commission, citing, for example, the sowing derogation granted on EFA land, which does not clearly exclude the use of pesticides.