Moldova has chosen Europe, but it is divided: what will happen now?

Moldova has chosen Europe, but it is divided: what will happen now?

Rights · ·

The “yes” vote wins the referendum to join Europe by a handful of votes. Incumbent Moldovan president Maia Sandu heads to a run-off.

A country split in two. That is the picture emerging from the referendum on accession to the European Union held on 20 October 2024 in Moldova, coinciding with the presidential elections. After an initial lead for the "no" vote, the result was overturned overnight as votes cast from abroad were counted. In the end, the "yes" won by a handful of votes: 50.39 per cent in favour of joining the EU against 49.61 per cent.

The presidential election is heading to a run-off, where incumbent president Maia Sandu failed to secure re-election in the first round, despite remaining in the lead with 42.45 per cent of the vote, against 25.98 per cent for her main challenger Alexandr Stoianoglo.

Amid accusations of "unprecedented interference" levelled at the Kremlin, and counter-accusations of "an unfree electoral campaign" from Moscow, the contest between Russia and the West is this time being played out on Moldovan soil.

The people of Moldova have spoken: our EU future will now be anchored in the constitution. We fought fairly in an unfair fight—and we won.

But the fight isn’t over. We will keep pushing for peace, prosperity, and the freedom to build our own future.

What changes after the referendum

In practical terms, the outcome of the referendum does not accelerate the former Soviet republic's accession process to the European Union. It was, in fact, a consultation not required by Brussels, called by Chișinău with the aim of amending the Constitution to allow accession to the European Union. In short, a vote called to define the country's geopolitical direction, in a nation where a large segment of the population remains pro-Russian to this day, concentrated above all in the separatist regions of Transnistria and Gagauzia. In these two regions, the "no" to Europe was overwhelming: in Gagauzia, 94.84 per cent of voters voted against, while in Transnistria the figure was 68.98 per cent.

The road to the "European family" — as incumbent president Maia Sandu described it — is therefore still a long one. Chișinău had submitted its application to Brussels in March 2022 and formal negotiations began in June 2024, running in parallel with those with Ukraine. The date for becoming a full member was set by Sandu at 2030. But much will depend on the outcome of the run-off between the pro-European incumbent and the socialist Alexandr Stoianoglo, Moldova's former prosecutor general, who, while defending himself as being in favour of EU integration and of dialogue with the US and Russia, described the referendum at a press conference as "a propaganda referendum conducted in the interests of certain individuals".

Which eastern countries are moving closer to the EU

Moldova is not the only country from the former Soviet bloc, or from Eastern Europe more broadly, to have taken its first steps towards EU integration. Ukraine, Georgia, Turkey and the Western Balkans (including Serbia, a historic ally of Russia) have all been granted candidate country status. The accession process is of course a lengthy one, and in Moldova's case it is closely tied to the completion of reforms, the fight against corruption and "de-oligarchisation", as well as the resolution of certain internal issues such as the hostilities with Transnistria.

The EU has, however, already allocated several funds to support this country's economic growth and accelerate its integration process. The most recent of these is the aid package of 1.8 billion euros adopted just a few days before the vote, on 10 October 2024: described as "the largest financial support package for Moldova's independence", it aims to "stimulate the Moldovan economy and bring the country closer to EU accession by accelerating reforms". Aid that has deeply irritated Moscow.

@MariaG_N @DaveKeating 🗳️🇲🇩 A knife-edge majority of 50.39% of #Moldovans voted “yes” in the country's pivotal referendum on joining the #EuropeanUnion, electoral authorities said on Monday.

🇪🇺 Pro-EU President Maia Sandu said Sunday’s vote had been marred by “unprecedented” foreign interference 👇

Russian reactions

The outcome of the referendum in Moldova was one of the most widely discussed stories on Russian federal channels. Commentators close to the Kremlin spoke of irregularities in the vote, of rampant Russophobia and of an imbalance in the number of polling stations set up for Moldovan citizens residing in Russia. Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova described it as unacceptable that only ten thousand ballot papers had been distributed in Russia, given that approximately 500,000 Moldovan citizens reside on the territory of the Russian Federation, and that only two polling stations were opened (in Moscow and Saint Petersburg). By way of comparison, in Italy, where the Moldovan community is smaller (around 300,000 people), 60 polling stations were set up across the country.

Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov spoke of an "unfree electoral campaign" on account of the restrictions imposed on the opposition: the Moldovan authorities had banned the party, the media companies and the various Telegram channels belonging to the main opposition leader, Ilan Shor, convicted in absentia to 15 years for fraud and money laundering and accused by many of being the man the Kremlin used to influence the outcome of the vote.

From criticism to threats: one of Russia's leading propagandists, Dmitry Kiselev, declared that "if this course continues, territorial losses for Moldova are inevitable: Transnistria will leave for good, and the fate of Gagauzia is far from clear". The risk that the Ukrainian scenario may repeat itself, with a possible Russian intervention in the pro-Russian separatist regions, therefore appears to be a very real threat.

Reactions

European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen, who had visited Chișinău just ten days before the referendum to announce the aid package of 1.8 billion euros, congratulated the Moldovan people on the victory of the "yes" vote: "You did it again! In the face of Russia's hybrid tactics, Moldova shows it is independent, strong and wants a European future!", she wrote on X (formerly Twitter).

Congratulations to the people of Moldova and to you, @sandumaiamd

You’ve done it again!

In the face of Russia’s hybrid tactics, Moldova shows that it is independent, it is strong and it wants a European future!

"We fought fairly in an unfair battle and we won. But the fight is not over. We will keep pushing for peace, prosperity and the freedom to build our own future," tweeted Maia Sandu, who spoke of "criminal gangs" and of "irrefutable evidence" of an attempt to "buy 300,000 voters" in order to stage electoral fraud "on a scale never seen before".

Beyond the mutual accusations of fraud and interference, the fact remains that the "yes" victory was snatched by the narrowest of margins.

But what impact will this razor-thin victory have on the EU accession process? "If this referendum carried any weight at the final step before signing for EU integration, then questions would be raised. But we are at the beginning of a process that still has a long way to go — commented Alexei Tulbure, Moldova's former representative to the UN and the Council of Europe —. This referendum has more political than institutional value, and I am certain that the talks will continue. Moldovan society is divided and this vote has shown that clearly. And it sets before itself a fundamental task: that of unifying Moldovan society. This will be Maia Sandu's priority."

The presidential run-off will be held on 3 November. And unlike before, the two candidates have now agreed to face each other in a public debate.