How are the large carnivores of the Alps? The report from the Province of Trento

How are the large carnivores of the Alps? The report from the Province of Trento

Environment · ·

The Grandi carnivori 2018 report has been published, analysing the state of health of bears, wolves and lynxes and the challenges associated with their management.

Large carnivores are species fundamental to the balance of ecosystems, capable of triggering cascade effects that influence not only other animals but also vegetation. In many areas of the planet, large predators are experiencing a dramatic decline; in Italy, however, thanks to protection measures and conservation efforts, they are returning to their historic territories, from which they had been forcibly eradicated. The presence of large carnivores is nonetheless capable of arousing deep-rooted and unjustified fears, heightened by the lost habit of coexistence and by the alarmism and sensationalism with which much of the press covers these animals. The Grandi carnivori 2018 report by the Forestry and Wildlife Service of the Autonomous Province of Trento analyses the state of health of the bear (Ursus arctos), the wolf (Canis lupus italicus) and the lynx (Lynx lynx) in Trentino, as well as the actual damage caused by these animals, with the aim of providing an objective picture and fostering coexistence between humans and predators.

Lupo grigio in una giornata nebbiosa
The large carnivore report was produced using data collected via camera traps, direct observations and genetic analyses © Ingimage

There is no predator emergency

The report, edited by Fabio Angeli, Daniele Asson, Natalia Bragalanti, Claudio Groff, Luca Pedrotti and Paolo Zanghellini, and produced with the contribution of the Museo delle Scienze di Trento (Muse), parco naturale Paneveggio Pale di San Martino (Pn Ppsm), Istituto superiore per la protezione e la ricerca ambientale (Ispra) and the Fondazione Edmund Mach (Fem), found above all that there is no predator emergency whatsoever. The damage caused by bears, wolves and lynxes is in fact limited, testifying to the effectiveness of the prevention measures adopted by the province.

How many bears are there

For 2018, estimates of the bear population present in the province were based, unlike in previous years, solely on data collected through opportunistic monitoring — that is, the collection of organic samples found on the territory during routine service activities and in connection with damage assessments and the inspection of scratching trees. The data collected showed that the population is estimated at between 60 and 78 individuals. In 2018, 21–23 cubs were born, while the death of only one individual was recorded.

Read also

Daniza and KJ2's cubs are doing well

The cubs of Daniza and KJ2, the two female bears killed in Trentino in 2014 and 2017 respectively, were allowed to grow up in the wild as provided for by the "Guidelines for the management of motherless bear cubs" and, as monitoring has confirmed, they are growing up healthily. KJ2's two cubs, the report states, "entered the young age bracket in 2018, which in any case involves definitive separation from the mother, while Daniza's cubs, whose presence was also confirmed during 2018, have reached adult age class (they are in fact 5 years old at the end of 2018)".

The return of the wolf should not cause alarm

No other animal, at least in Italy, is capable of provoking such polarising opinions as the wolf, which is precisely why the study of the actual size of its population and its real impact is particularly important. The wolf, after disappearing from the province of Trento around the mid-19th century, returned naturally from 2010 onwards. Monitoring activity carried out in 2018 detected the presence of seven family groups and other individuals, possibly dispersing. The technicians who compiled the report sought to deepen understanding of predator-prey dynamics by monitoring one pack in particular. It emerged that "in the territory occupied by the pack, within which approximately seven alpine pastures fall, no cases of predation on livestock have been recorded to date. All predations identified so far, both on the basis of satellite data and from occasional findings, involve wild ungulates, in particular red deer and roe deer."

Read also

The last lynx in the province

Monitoring the presence of a species as elusive as the lynx is particularly difficult. Europe's largest felid is indeed a true ghost of the forests, in which it lives by blending in perfectly, hunting at dusk and at night and carefully avoiding any contact with humans. In the province of Trento there lives a single individual, a male called B132, originating from the small, reintroduced Swiss population of the canton of St. Gallen. The animal, which settled in the area in 2008, established itself in the south-western part of the province, particularly in the mountains of the Val d'Ampola, and during 2018 it was possible to document its presence with certainty.

Lince  appostata durante la caccia
Monitoring of the species began with the return of the lynx to the provincial territory, that is from the second half of the 1980s, in connection with the appearance of several individuals in eastern Trentino © Cloudtail the Snow Leopard/Flickr

How much damage have large carnivores caused

The province of Trento has, since 1976, compensated 100 per cent of the damage caused by bears; this provision was extended in 2011 to cover damage caused by wolves and lynxes as well. "In 2018, 222 cases of damage by large carnivores were verified, of which 157 were caused by bears and 65 by wolves," the report states. "None by lynx. In 97 per cent of cases, a damage report was followed by an on-site inspection by forestry personnel, who drew up the verification report. A total of €171,567.46 was paid out, of which €94,977.52 for damage caused by bears and €76,589.94 for damage caused by wolves." The actual expenditure incurred in compensating for bear and wolf attacks is therefore limited and does not justify the alarmism and the repeated attempts by the province to authorise the capture and culling of wolves and bears.

Read also

How to prevent attacks

The return of large carnivores requires farms, shepherds and beekeepers to protect their activities. To support these people, the Forestry and Wildlife Service has drawn up the document "Management and prevention of wolf damage in the province of Trento". The promotion of protective tools, such as fencing and guard dogs, is proving successful, and in 2018 207 applications were submitted — compared with 129 in 2017 — for prevention measures to protect livestock and beekeeping assets. According to the report, approximately €148,000 was spent on implementing such measures.

Mucche sulle Alpi austriache
To prevent wolf attacks, the province launched a pilot project to test electrified fencing for the protection of cattle. The trial was based on the installation of electrified fencing to protect livestock during the night and produced positive results © Sean Gallup/Getty Images

Coexistence is possible

Where correctly implemented, prevention measures have proved entirely effective. "In all the mountain farms where prevention works were carried out, no subsequent predation by wolves or bears was recorded, either on protected animals or on unprotected ones." Whereas on alpine pastures, only six attacks on protected livestock were confirmed in total. These figures demonstrate, once again, that coexistence between humans and large predators is possible, provided adequate protection is in place. Large predators, as well as playing a fundamental role in the environment they inhabit, enrich our lives by making them more exciting, and have always exerted a profound fascination on our species, as evidenced by the ancient bear cult in prehistoric caves, or the role of the wolf in numerous mythologies. We cannot squander this natural and cultural wealth in the name of an illusory sense of security.