According to the regional governments of Trentino and Veneto, carnivores have become dangerous or harmful to farmers and livestock keepers — and should therefore be culled, overlooking the fact that they are protected by law.
The green light for culling, then. Or perhaps not. The matter has not yet been fully resolved because, while the regional governments of Veneto and the autonomous provinces of Trento and Bolzano, backed also by Piedmont, are voting on management plans for wolves and bears that provide for capture and culling, the Ministry of the Environment has made it known that it "rules out culling". All the more so given that Ursus arctos and Canis lupus are among the particularly protected species under Law 11 February 1992 no. 157.
Update
On 29 February last, thanks in part to pressure and awareness-raising work by environmental associations and the mobilisation of Lav activists, the law did not even come to a vote because the rapporteur was absent from the session. The wolf in Veneto is safe, for now.
The management plans in Veneto and Trentino-Alto Adige
Last summer, the two autonomous provinces of Trento and Bolzano had already given the go-ahead for the "removal, capture or killing of specimens" of bear and wolf in Alpine territory. Last January, the president of the province of Trento, Maurizio Fugatti of the Lega, declared that: "there is a safety problem linked to the presence of wolves, especially in the areas of Val di Fassa, Ala and Rumo in the upper Val di Non. We cannot accept wolves coming so close to homes, in the valley floor. Citizens cannot be exposed to such risks and we must guarantee their safety. As I emphasised in the Committee, I am ready to take on my responsibilities to ensure the peace and safety of citizens".
According to data provided by the province itself, Trentino records 7 packs totalling around fifty specimens: 27 in the Monti Lessini area, 18 specimens in Val di Fassa and 7 wolves in the upper Val di Non. These packs reportedly recorded 69 cases of damage in 2018, amounting to more than 70,000 euros. In the Apennines today, there are estimated to be around 2,000 wolves.
Veneto would also like to cull bears and wolves
In Veneto, after an initial distancing, a vote in favour was reached on the law entitled "Misure di prevenzione e di intervento concernenti i grandi carnivori", presented by the Lega Nord group leader Nicola Finco, although in this case the bear would have been excluded. The law, however, did not even reach a vote in the Regional Council. A non-starter, then, for now.
According to the promoters of the law, "regions and autonomous provinces will be able to carry out a precise census of large carnivores, including in agreement with neighbouring regions; draw up a technical-scientific report to define the minimum population levels of large carnivores required to safeguard the species, as established by European directives; prepare a thorough analysis to define an intervention plan for controlling the number of specimens present in their respective territories, also employing sterilisation or forced removal with captivity. And finally identify the cases in which it may be possible to proceed with the culling of individual specimens deemed dangerous to public safety".
Come ho sempre detto i #lupi e gli #orsi non si toccano: pronto il #PianoLupo che in questi giorni ho condiviso anche con i presidenti delle Province autonome di #Trento e #Bolzano. 23 punti per gestire la convivenza e mitigarne gli effetti senza abbattimenti. 🐻🐾
But from the ministry the answer has always been the same. As far back as last July, Environment Minister Sergio Costa was convinced that this decision was "a serious mistake" on the part of the provinces of Trento and Bolzano in "wanting to claim autonomy over wildlife management, which is inalienable state heritage, forcing the balance between the powers of the State and those of the autonomous provinces on important and very sensitive issues, which must be addressed with genuinely sound scientific and technical solutions and a great deal of reasonableness", while also explaining that "there are many alternative solutions that can be found together".
For this reason, on 22 February last, on the sidelines of the State-Regions Conference, a first "wolf plan" was presented that rules out culling and provides for 23 management actions, including — a significant novelty — the trialling of mitigation initiatives at a micro-territorial level".
The minister concludes that "more damage is attributed to the wolf's activity than it actually causes. Hence the particular attention devoted to the problem of hybrids and to sterilisation as an appropriate intervention tool, even though responsibility for hybrids lies with the health authorities."
How many wolves are there in Italy
According to the monitoring plan presented by Ispra in December, for the Alps reference is made to the presence of 47 packs, 6 pairs and 1 solitary individual, and a minimum of 293 individuals (Wolfalps project data). For the remaining portion of the national peninsular territory, two estimates exist, though neither derives from a comprehensive monitoring programme and both are therefore associated with a high degree of uncertainty. The first, at national scale, reports 1,580 animals — with an uncertainty range of between 1,070 and 2,472; the second gives an overall figure for Italian territory of between a minimum of 1,269 individuals and a maximum of 1,800. It remains to be understood where the objective threshold lies at which one can speak of an "invasion" and of public safety concerns — and, above all, whether regional governments can consider themselves above national law.
Trentino-Alto Adige against wolves and bears, but in Veneto the law does not pass
Environment — di Rudi Bressa
According to the regional governments of Trentino and Veneto, carnivores have become dangerous or harmful to farmers and livestock keepers — and should therefore be culled, overlooking the fact that they are protected by law.