Qatar World Cup, what Gianni Infantino said about human rights

Qatar World Cup, what Gianni Infantino said about human rights

Rights · ·

Fifa president Gianni Infantino on criticism of the Qatar World Cup: “I feel gay, disabled, a migrant worker. So much hypocrisy from Europe.”

He had asked the federations competing in the tournament to talk only about football, and not about human, civil and environmental rights. But on the eve of the Qatar football World Cup, pressed by investigations, protests and boycott initiatives from fans, public authorities and civil society, Fifa president Gianni Infantino simultaneously went on the defensive and on the attack, during a lengthy press conference that was supposed to be a simple presentation of the tournament, which kicks off tomorrow with the opening match between Qatar and Ecuador.

Arab, African, gay, migrant

From the outset, however, it was clear that the Fifa president's would not be a routine press conference. To respond to accusations of human rights violations by Fifa and the Qatari organisers against migrants from Asia who were forced to work punishing shifts in gruelling conditions to build the infrastructure for Qatar 2022, Infantino brought his own past as an emigrant into the picture. "Today I feel Qatari. Today I feel Arab. Today I feel African. Today I feel gay. Today I feel like a migrant worker."

Infantino compared the situation of today's construction workers in Qatar to that of his Italian parents who had settled in Switzerland in the 1960s: "The conditions were tough. When I first came to Qatar six years ago, some of the things I saw reminded me of my childhood. But just like Switzerland years ago, Qatar has made progress." And then: "Obviously I am not Qatari, I am not Arab, African, gay, a migrant worker. But I know what it means to be discriminated against. I myself was bullied."

Europe's hypocrisy

FIFA President Gianni Infantino on Europe's criticism of the Qatar World Cup.
109674 5032 19 nov 2022 · Apri su X →

The empathetic approach then gives way to an attack on the Western press and on Europe itself, accused of hypocrisy: "In recent years we have witnessed a double standard on the part of Europeans and Westerners. And yet it is Europeans who should be apologising for what they have done around the world over the past three thousand years." According to Infantino, "Qatar has given thousands of workers job opportunities. We in the Western world, on the other hand, close our borders. We do not allow legal entry into our countries. And migrants often live in conditions that are far from the best. This is why many migrants are forced to seek illegal routes to reach Europe. And only a few survive. Just as few are those who truly care about the fates of these people, and in particular about the fate of children." Qatar, on the other hand, according to Infantino, "gives them a future."

🇶🇦⚽ | La cifra podría ascender a 6.500 trabajadores muertos desde 2010, cuando Qatar fue elegido sede del Mundial 2022, según el periódico británico The Guardian. Murieron en la construcción de los estadios migrantes de India, Pakistán, Nepal, Bangladesh y Sri Lanka. #Qatar2022

A future that the more than 6,500 workers — most of them from Pakistan, India, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh — who died over the last ten years building the facilities and infrastructure needed to hold a World Cup in the desert will not have. For the victims' families, Amnesty International has called for financial compensation, so far denied by the Qatari government, on which Fifa once again declined to comment, as Amnesty Italia spokesperson Riccardo Noury points out.

A una domanda, una, doveva rispondere: "La Fifa istituirà un fondo di risarcimento di 440 milioni di dollari in favore dei lavoratori che hanno subito violazioni dei diritti umani e alle famiglie di quelli morti ?". E ha parlato d'altro.
repubblica.it/sport/calcio/e…

Infantino instead assured that in Qatar "there is already a permanent office dealing with migrant workers, compensation exists." He then announced that Fifa will create a fund dedicated to establishing a centre of excellence for labour in collaboration with the International Labour Organization (Ilo) to develop better labour practices and support adherence to the United Nations guiding principles on business and human rights. The fund "will be financed by a percentage of the commercial revenues generated through the competition."

On LGBTQ+ rights, it's "a matter of time"

The rights of homosexual people, one of the points on which Qatar is strongly criticised, was also at the centre of the Fifa meeting in Doha. "I have spoken about this issue several times with the Qatari authorities: everyone is welcome here. Of course some prefer to stay at home and criticise because living one's homosexuality openly in public is not permitted here, but this is a process that takes years. My father would probably have had a different opinion from mine on homosexuality, just as my son certainly has a different opinion from mine. Let us try to convince others by building relationships, by helping, not by dividing, but rather by uniting."

🗣 "I am sitting here in a privileged position on a global stage as a gay man in Qatar. Just because Gianni Infantino is not gay, does not mean he does not care."

FIFA's Director of Media Relations Bryan Swanson defends FIFA president Gianni Infantino

But the most striking moment, on the LGBTQI+ question, was the coming out of Bryan Swanson, Fifa's head of communications, who had been sitting next to Infantino throughout the press conference: "I am here, in this privileged position, on a global stage, as a gay person, as a free man in Qatar. We have received assurances that everyone is welcome. Just because Gianni Infantino is not gay, that does not mean he does not care about this issue." In reality, same-sex couples in Qatar are not recognised in any way, and sodomy is punishable by one to three years' imprisonment. Just a few days ago, Qatar's World Cup ambassador Khalid Salman had described homosexuality as a "mental disorder."

Khalid Salman, ambasciatore dei mondiali di calcio in Qatar, dice all'emittente tedesca Zdf che l'omosessualità è una malattia mentale.
#QatarWorldCup2022

And what about the environment?

There was no mention, however, of the question of environmental rights, which have also been severely trampled in the organisation of the World Cup in Qatar: between air conditioning in open-air stadiums and daily air shuttles between Doha and Dubai, it is estimated that in under a month of tournament, CO2 emissions will be produced equivalent to those generated by a country like Iceland over eight full years. Furthermore, the carbon footprint of the stadiums built for the occasion — according to Carbon Market Watch — is at least 1.4 million tonnes of CO2, the equivalent of the emissions produced in one year by 180,000 American families through their energy consumption.