Fifa to the federations competing at the Qatar World Cup: “Let's focus on football.” The European sides respond: “We will continue to stand up for human rights.”
"Let's focus on football, please." Fifa has officially asked the federations of the 32 national teams competing at the Qatar World Cup, which kicks off on 20 November, not to carry out any protest initiatives or criticism of the emirate over its failure to respect human rights, whether or not related to the organisation of the tournament. Some European federations, however, have hit back sharply: "We will continue to stand up for human rights." And given that World Cup ambassador Khalid Salman has reiterated that in Qatar homosexuality is considered a mental disorder, that effort is clearly very much needed.
For months, if not years, the Qatar World Cup has been in the crosshairs of organisations fighting for human and environmental rights, and recently some of the competing national teams have also made their grievances known: Denmark will play in a kit bearing no technical sponsor's logo — the sponsor not wishing to lend its image to the tournament — and in an all-black third kit as a sign of mourning for the at least 6,500 migrant workers who died on the job building the infrastructure needed to host the World Cup.
Australia's national team players published a video criticising Qatar over its human rights laws and calling for the decriminalisation of same-sex relationships, which are strictly prohibited in Qatar, receiving in response a message from the organisers that amounted to a "nobody's perfect."
Conversely, Iran's players had asked Fifa to exclude their own federation from the Qatar World Cup as a signal of condemnation of the repression taking place in their country following the death of young Mahsa Amini. Ukraine, too, had called for the Iranian national team to be excluded, on account of the Tehran government's support for Russia in the ongoing conflict. The participation of Iran was, needless to say, confirmed.
So Gianni Infantino and Fatma Samoura, president and secretary general of Fifa respectively, put pen to paper and wrote to the heads of the federations, warning them that "as one of the 32 participating teams, you carry on your shoulders the hopes and dreams of your home nation and all your people. So please, let's now focus on football!"
Practically speaking: let's not ruin the dream of billions of fans for the rights of a few more million. Of course, the letter continues, "we know that football does not live in a vacuum and we are equally aware that there are many challenges and difficulties of a political nature around the world. But please do not allow football to be dragged into every ideological or political battle that exists."
At Fifa, Infantino and Samoura continue, "we try to respect all opinions and beliefs, without lecturing the rest of the world. One of the great strengths of the world is its diversity, and if inclusion means anything, it means having respect for that diversity. No people, culture or nation is 'better' than another. This principle is the cornerstone of mutual respect and non-discrimination. And this is also one of football's core values. So please, let us all remember this and let football take centre stage."
According to Fifa, the football World Cup, far from legitimising the emirate's policies on human rights, is therefore a means of inclusion: "We have the chance and the unique opportunity to welcome and embrace everyone, regardless of origin, background, religion, gender, sexual orientation or nationality. Let's take this opportunity and unite the world through the universal language of football."
The response of the European federations
Fifa's letter did not, however, go unanswered: according to the Swiss daily Le Temps (Switzerland is home to both Uefa and Fifa headquarters, and Gianni Infantino is himself Swiss), ten federations — all European — took Infantino and Samoura's message rather badly and replied with a joint letter, reaffirming their commitment to defending human rights, supporting migrant workers and continuing to put pressure on Fifa to honour the promises made within the framework of the Qatar football World Cup.
Dans une lettre commune, dix associations nationales réaffirment leur volonté de défendre les #droitshumains et des travailleurs migrants et d’obliger la @FIFAcom à tenir les engagements pris dans le cadre de la Coupe du monde. #Qatar#FIFAWorldCupletemps.ch/sport/dix-pays…
The countries that responded to Fifa are Germany, England, Belgium, Denmark, Norway, the Netherlands, Wales, Portugal, Sweden and Switzerland: they all belong to the Uefa working group on human and labour rights, and eight of them (Norway and Sweden did not qualify) will be in Qatar. "We recognise and welcome, as we have done in the past, that Qatar has made significant progress, particularly with regard to the rights of migrant workers," the signatories immediately clarify, according to Le Temps, which was able to review the letter, and "we welcome the assurances provided by the Qatari government and Fifa regarding the safety, protection and inclusion of all fans travelling to the World Cup, including Lgbtq+ fans."
Nevertheless, the ten write, "embracing diversity and tolerance also means upholding human rights. Human rights are universal and apply everywhere. And we will continue to support the momentum for positive and progressive change and to advocate for a positive outcome and an update on the two key outstanding issues we have been discussing with Fifa for a long time." The captains of the eight qualified national teams will wear a special armband at the World Cup, featuring a multicoloured heart and the words "One Love", as a symbol of diversity and the fight against discrimination.
For the World Cup ambassador, homosexuality is 'haram'
Khalid Salman, ambasciatore dei mondiali di calcio in Qatar, dice all'emittente tedesca Zdf che l'omosessualità è una malattia mentale. #QatarWorldCup2022
Further proof that, despite some ritual openings made necessary to cast the World Cup in a less negative light, human and civil rights in Qatar still have a very long way to go, is now provided by the case of Khalid Salman, a former Qatari footballer appointed as Qatar World Cup ambassador by Fifa and the organisers: Salman, in an interview with German broadcaster Zdf, reiterated that "homosexuality in our country is haram (forbidden, ed.) and people must accept our rules. It is a mental disorder, and children must not see gay people because that would be wrong."
Qatar World Cup, clash over human rights between Fifa and European national teams
Rights — di Simone Santi
Fifa to the federations competing at the Qatar World Cup: “Let's focus on football.” The European sides respond: “We will continue to stand up for human rights.”