The government has presented an ambitious Plan for Southern Italy, focusing on education and sustainability, and linking its objectives to those of the United Nations' 2030 Agenda.
A South oriented towards young people, connected and inclusive, a frontier (of innovation) but also an open space to the world (looking out in particular over the Mediterranean). Above all, however, a South that serves as the engine of Italy's ecological transition. These are the five missions the Italian government identified when drawing up the new Plan for the South, an agenda whose time horizon is 2030 — as in the case of the sustainable development agenda, to which it makes explicit reference when setting out its own objectives.
The cover of the Plan for the South features a photo of Duino, Trieste: for the opposition parties it is a gaffe; for Minister Provenzano it carries the message that investing in the South means investing in the whole of Italy.
The economic and infrastructural gap has long thrown what should be Italy's balanced development out of kilter: the government's new plan attempts to intervene with an effort of 123 billion euros over ten years (to be guaranteed by the clause stipulating that 34 per cent of all public funding must henceforth be directed to the South) for infrastructure, economic development, tourism revival and eco-sustainable reconversion.
The plan is decidedly ambitious: it envisages investment in education, starting with the fight against child educational poverty, in order to reduce inequalities and reactivate social mobility. It also includes the modernisation and development of physical and social infrastructure as a factor of connectivity and social inclusion, to break the isolation of certain areas of the Mezzogiorno. And the strengthening of networks between research and business and a new industrial policy strategy; the reinforcement of an economic role in the Mediterranean as well, through the strengthening of Special Economic Zones and development cooperation programmes.
The South as the engine of the ecological transition
The ecological transition represents one of the most important chapters of the plan: the idea is to strengthen the commitments of the Green New Deal in the South and in inland areas, in order to achieve specific objectives of the UN 2030 Agenda and mitigate the risks associated with climate change". Specifically, these are the 5 points in the programme:
Un #Sud rivolto ai giovani. Investiamo su tutta la filiera dell'#istruzione, a partire dalla lotta alla povertà educativa minorile, per rafforzare il capitale umano, ridurre le diseguaglianze e riattivare la mobilità sociale. #SUD2030
The first proposal is for an energy income, meaning the possibility for households to achieve significant savings on their bills through self-consumption: the idea is to encourage the spread of renewable energy and increase distributed generation and small-scale photovoltaic installations, thereby reducing energy poverty among the less well-off sections of the population in the Mezzogiorno. The objective will be pursued through the creation of a National Energy Income Fund for the purchase of photovoltaic systems.
The second concerns a genuine circular economy experiment in the field of absorbent hygiene products, while simultaneously contributing to emissions reductions, and will be implemented through the placement of smart bins — digitally accessible waste-sorting devices with 100 per cent sustainable power — in pilot cities in the South; the transfer of collected waste to treatment facilities; and the introduction of "secondary raw materials" onto the market.
The 5 points (plus one) set out in the Plan for the South for the Green Deal
The third proposal involves the enhancement of sustainable transport, in particular regional and interregional rail transport, metropolitan and suburban transport, and connections with inland areas, in order to improve conditions for commuters — starting with journey time reductions — and to ease traffic congestion. Among the expected outcomes is a significant reduction in CO2 emissions. To achieve this objective, the plan provides for the electrification of certain lines currently still served by diesel locomotives, the purchase of new rolling stock, the improvement of urban railway station conditions, specific technical assistance to municipalities to draw up Sustainable Urban Mobility Plans (Pums), and new, lower-impact buses, particularly in inland areas.
The fourth area of intervention is linked to the development of supply chain contracts in the agri-food sector, to increase the competitiveness and sustainability of agricultural and agri-food businesses and strengthen ties between primary production and processing in the strongly agricultural areas of the South. This will be achieved through material and immaterial investments in agricultural enterprises and through research and development projects in the agricultural sector.
The fifth and final point provides for sustainable forest management, to meet environmental, economic and social needs particularly in inland areas, prevent hydrogeological instability, and stimulate supply chains dedicated to the wood-energy system. The lines of intervention range from support for forest consortia, agricultural universities, cooperatives or other corporate forms typical of local realities, to extraordinary maintenance of forest and mountain land and hydrogeological consolidation works.
The Taranto construction site
Furthermore, special attention is devoted in the plan to the so-called Cantiere Taranto, where, in the government's own words, "the main emergencies of the southern regions converge: the productive emergency, of which the now three-decade-long crisis of the former Ilva and its supply chain represents only the most visible tip; the environmental emergency, which demands repairing the damage of the past while simultaneously rethinking the production model, safeguarding health, employment and development; and the social and demographic emergency, with a city that has lost almost fifty thousand inhabitants since the 1970s".
A skyline of Taranto, with the Ilva, the Apulian steelmaking complex
The absolute priority of the plan for the South is a definitive resolution of the crisis at the former Ilva steelworks, freeing the city of Taranto from the coercion of a forced choice between development and public health: the challenge put forward is the relaunch of the former Ilva with a green and sustainable development outlook, potentially extending the Just Transition Fund — the European fund for sustainable transition worth a total of 7.5 billion euros — to the steel sector as well.
The Plan for the South and the objectives of the 2030 Agenda
According to the plan drawn up by Minister for the South Giuseppe Provenzano, the mission "A South for the ecological turning point" in particular is linked to several objectives of the UN 2030 Agenda for sustainable development, starting with number 2, namely zero hunger: both envisage sustainable food production systems and resilient agricultural practices that, by conserving ecosystems, improve land and soil quality. The plan's objectives also coincide with "goal 3" (good health and well-being), in an attempt to reduce deaths and illnesses from hazardous chemicals and from the pollution and contamination of air, water and soil. But also with "goal 4" (quality education), which calls for the spread of education for sustainable development and sustainable lifestyles, and with "goal 6" (clean water and sanitation), which aims to improve water quality by reducing pollution and increasing water efficiency.
Il ministro @peppeprovenzano presenta il piano per il Sud #sud2030 citando l'impegno del Governo nel collegare 5 missioni all'#Agenda2030 per un Sud più inclusivo, ecologico, innovativo, aperto al mediterraneo e rivolto ai giovani. #SDGs
Parallels have also been identified with "goal 7" (affordable and clean energy), in terms of increasing the share of renewable energy and improving energy efficiency; with "goal 8" (decent work and economic growth), in improving efficiency in consumption and production, in an attempt to decouple economic growth from environmental degradation; with "goal 11" (sustainable cities and communities), by reducing the per capita environmental impact of cities, particularly with regard to air quality and waste management, and by providing safe, inclusive and accessible public green spaces. Then with "goal 12" (responsible consumption and production), in an attempt to avoid the overexploitation of natural resources and halve food waste; with "goal 13" (climate action), in particular by strengthening resilience and adaptive capacity to climate-related risks and natural disasters in all countries. And even with "goal 14" (life below water), by conserving and correctly using the resources of the Mediterranean for sustainable development, and "goal 15" (life on land) by promoting sustainable use of ecosystems and halting the loss of biological diversity.
"Il piano per il Sud presentato oggi da @peppeprovenzano ci convince. Ma funzionerà solo se sapremo fare come con la ex DDR, partendo dalla riqualificazione della amministrazione pubblica." @StefanoCiafani su @HuffPostItalia 🔽
Inevitably, given the very close references to the objectives of the 2030 Agenda, the plan has come under the scrutiny of Asvis, which gives it an overall positive assessment, albeit one that must inevitably be suspended pending the test of facts: for the time being, however, Luciano Forlani of the secretariat of the Italian Alliance for Sustainable Development explains, "it is certainly a plan that has a soul. The road ahead for any plan for the South is certainly uphill from the start, but there is a discernible attempt to tackle some key issues. Perhaps the figures are not equal to the challenge at hand, but we cannot blame the government for that, because it is objectively working within a context of European budgetary constraints, economic stringency and cyclical difficulties. But there seems to be an ambition to do better from a procedural standpoint."
Forlani was favourably struck by the emphasis placed on and education, "because it is important that significant investment is made in full-time schooling in areas where there is juvenile deviance and where school dropout rates are showing a slightly upward trend for the first time in a long while." On the environmental dimension of the plan, however, "there is some attention, even if certain key junctures that also create friction within the governing majority do not appear to have been definitively resolved." For instance, the attempt at synthesis is somewhat puzzling: by identifying, for each intervention, the body or bodies responsible for carrying it out, it "does not make the governance terrain between the state and local authorities entirely clear." In practice, who will do what? Will coordination between bodies work?