The harassment in advertising agencies that sparked Italy's #MeToo

The harassment in advertising agencies that sparked Italy's #MeToo

Rights · ·

Testimonies against the harassment suffered by women inside major Italian advertising agencies continue to grow.

And now for the personal question. Massimo Guastini: I have a feeling (just a feeling, mind you…) that in your world, the world of advertising, there is currently a problem with sexual harassment. Is that right?

This is the thirty-third question from an interview conducted by Monica Rossi, an anonymous Facebook profile belonging to a figure who has long been interviewing various intellectuals, with Massimo Guastini, a well-known face in Italian advertising. The question, but above all the answer, have in recent weeks set off a #MeToo of advertising agencies, through which many women are sharing their experiences of harassment that took place inside advertising firms. #MeToo is a feminist movement against sexual harassment and violence against women, which spread from October 2017 following accusations of sexual violence against film producer Harvey Weinstein, and has been used on social networks to demonstrate the prevalence of gender-based violence, particularly in the workplace.

Massimo Guastini, in fact, responded to the question posed by Monica Rossi first and foremost by confirming that "yes, that's exactly right", and then citing a "famous chat in which various men catalogued and rated — some the backside, some the breasts, some the legs — of these young interns who could have been their daughters." A confession that sparked controversy and debate, but also a wave of testimonies from people who have been victims of harassment in the workplace, paving the way for a kind of #MeToo of advertising agencies.

The accusations made by Guastini

In the interview with Monica Rossi, the advertising professional Guastini levelled serious accusations against Pasquale Diaferia, another well-known name in the world of communications, referring to him as "one of these serial harassers."

Diaferia has never been convicted of sexual abuse and, as far as is publicly known, has never been investigated or reported for such an offence either. According to what Guastini reported, however, the advertising professional allegedly engaged in abusive behaviour "between 2007 and 2016. Because about a dozen women have told me about it. The most recent one just these past few days, even though the events she described to me took place in 2012." Guastini also recounts a specific episode, in which an intern working at his agency told him about her direct experience, in which Diaferia "attempted unwanted sexual advances since she kept rejecting him. There was no rape, but those were definitely sexual harassment." Following these statements, the Art Directors Club Italiano (Adci), which had recently invited Diaferia to serve as a mentor, unanimously decided to remove him from its membership for "violation of the Statute."

The accusations, however, do not stop there. The well-known advertising professional, in the interview, also refers to a men-only chat, nicknamed the "chat degli 80," in which sexist comments about female colleagues were shared on a daily basis at "a very famous, very powerful, very important advertising agency."

Molestie donne
Testimonies of workplace harassment suffered by women are constantly on the rise © Getty Images

"We are social" and the sexist chat targeting female colleagues

The story of the chat is not new: back in January 2020, the podcast Freegida had already reported on its existence in episode number 5, entitled "È solo un'altra stupida storia di molestie," without, however, making the name of the agency public.

On this occasion, however, the name of the agency came out, and it was made known by one of the founders, Gabriele Cucinella, on Facebook itself. The agency in question is We Are Social, a company with thousands of employees, offices around the world, and a base in Milan.

The first person to have discovered the existence of this chat, in 2017, was Zahra Abdullahi, who at the time worked at We Are Social as a writer. Abdullahi told Il Post that "On any given day, the comments ranged from 'she's so hot', 'how does she walk around without a bra', 'she put on a little dress thinking she had a nice arse but she doesn't know she's a fucking whale', 'that one's smiling today, you can tell she got laid by her boyfriend last night'."

Molestie donne
Stories that also include experiences of women who found the courage to speak out, but were silenced © Getty Images

Mario Leopoldo Scrima is, to date, the only member of that chat to have spoken about it publicly, also like Guastini through an interview conducted by the Monica Rossi profile. Scrima worked for the agency from 2017 to 2021 and, according to his account, it was a chat on Skype — a programme used to exchange communications between agency employees — which had existed since 2015/2016, was made up of men only, and in which "there were literally ALL of us: team directors, account directors, account managers, account executives, editors, writers, creatives, art, interns," with the exception of Cucinella, Magi and Nava, the three heads and founders of the agency.

Scrima's account added details about the content of the chat, stating in the interview with Monica Rossi that "during meetings, our female colleagues didn't know that before — or even during — we were meanwhile chatting in real time commenting on their annoying voice, their big arse, their unripe little breasts or things like that. And when the meetings ended, they don't know that very often the men would stay on for a few extra minutes to 'go deeper' into conversations that had started in that famous chat." One of the three founders of We Are Social, Gabriele Cucinella (currently the regional lead for the EU Area of the structure), recounted his version of events to Prima comunicazione.
Cucinella stated that he had discovered the existence of the chat in 2017, when it was shut down, adding that "the company always considered this initiative to be ignoble and shameful, and we condemned it immediately. We also carried out an internal review, but on our systems we had no way of identifying any content, because the Skype chat was not officially used by the company."

None of the people involved in the chat were dismissed and no disciplinary action was taken, but the chief executive of We Are Social added that, in light of the new elements that had come to light, "we reiterate that we consider what happened to be unacceptable," announcing that the company has decided to take new action and has engaged a third party to redo the investigation.

The #MeToo of Italian advertising women

As well as provoking a wave of outrage and accusations against the sexist practices that continually take place inside workplaces (and beyond), the affair has sparked a full-blown Italian #MeToo.

On 19 June 2023, a few days after the story about the chat created by We Are Social employees broke, Tania Loschi, a freelance copywriter, gathered on her Instagram profile hundreds of testimonies from people who had suffered harassment, particularly in the workplace and in the fields of communications and advertising, also denouncing what she herself had personally experienced. "It is a systemic culture, in which agencies have their roots," she explained.

Women spied on through bathroom keyholes, and others, like her, who recount how they were repeatedly treated as objects and, on some occasions, used as bargaining chips for dissatisfied clients. Stories that also include accounts from women who found the courage to speak up, only to be silenced, belittled or simply not believed, discouraging others from coming forward in turn.

Stories of violence, harassment and abuses of power tied to professional position, which together paint a picture of a toxic, sexist and misogynistic environment that sexualises women's bodies and, once again, brutally reduces them to objects, obscuring each woman's personality and, above all, her professionalism. Giulia Scanna, digital copywriter, social media manager and lecturer, told Repubblica her own story of abuse suffered as an intern at the hands of a 50-year-old man she had met at a work event. In a post published on Facebook, Scanna also explained the "reasons that led the twenty-year-old me of 12 years ago not to seek help from the authorities." Those reasons range from the sociocultural context of that period, in which the #MeToo movement did not yet exist, to the fear of retaliation, through to professional isolation and the terror of public shaming.

@MeTooEP has been working hard since 2018, creating campaigns & building strong networks across EU🇪🇺

To be able to ensure productivity, visibility & far-reaching campaigns we have started a crowdfunding.

Support the fight against harassment!🙏⬇️gofund.me/a1fd4c3b

This is not the first time that women working in the advertising industry have spoken out against this kind of violence. As far back as 2021, hundreds of women workers, following an appeal launched by advertising professional Zoe Scaman, had declared that they had been victims of harassment and discrimination in the workplace at the hands of male colleagues.

Stories from women who still struggle to come forward out of fear, yet who are increasingly bearing witness to the toxicity of work environments in which sexism and misogyny remain all too present.