Harvey Weinstein sentenced to 23 years in prison for sexual assault and rape

Harvey Weinstein sentenced to 23 years in prison for sexual assault and rape

Rights · ·

The New York Supreme Court has convicted former film producer Harvey Weinstein of rape and sexual assault. Despite acquittals on other charges, the verdict marks a turning point for women's rights.

Last updated: 12 March 2020

"With his manipulations, his resources, his lawyers, his publicists and his spies, he did everything he could to silence the victims. But they were not silenced. They spoke from the heart, and they were heard." Former American film producer Harvey Weinstein, for years at the centre of the scandal over sexual harassment against dozens of women, was found guilty of first-degree sexual assault and third-degree rape by the New York Supreme Court on Monday 24 February, before being sentenced to 20 years in prison for the first offence and 3 years for the second on 11 March.

Read also: The Weinstein case. What happened over 30 years and why sexual harassment was reported now

At the end of a trial lasting several weeks, the Hollywood mogul was convicted on two of the five charges brought against him: sexual assault and rape, against Miriam Haleyi and Jessica Mann respectively. The two women were involved in the trial as complainants, joined by a further 27 women who testified as witnesses. Weinstein, now 67, must serve the sentences of 20 years (out of a maximum of 25) and 3 years (out of a maximum of 4) consecutively.

L'ex produttore cinematografico statunitense Harvey Weinstein
Former American film producer Harvey Weinstein has for years been at the centre of the scandal over sexual harassment allegations by dozens of women © Spencer Platt/Getty Images

What crimes Harvey Weinstein is guilty of

Miriam Haleyi was a production assistant on the programme Project Runway when, on 10 July 2006, Weinstein brought her to his apartment in SoHo under the pretence of a meeting. There, he approached her, pushed her into the bedroom and physically forced himself on her, compelling her to submit to oral sex.

I refused him but he insisted. I kept saying no. Every time I tried to get up from the bed he pushed me back down and held me there. At that point I understood what was about to happen. He forced me to receive oral sex. I was in shock, I dissociated.Miriam Haleyi

First-degree sexual assault — the most serious charge on which Weinstein was found guilty — refers to when a person performs oral or anal sex on someone without their consent, or when force or threats are used to commit the crime. It is punishable by 5 to 25 years in prison.

Jessica Mann was an aspiring actress in 2013 and at that time had a "real but humiliating and oppressive" relationship with Weinstein. After attempting to end their relationship in the lobby of the Midtown East hotel, Weinstein asked Mann to come to his room, where he forced her to undress before assaulting her.

When I got to the room I started arguing with him. He seemed like a sergeant: hard, angry. He came towards me, ordering me to undress. I was in a panic, my worst nightmare was about to happen. I was angry and scared. I gave up.Jessica Mann

Third-degree rape refers to non-consensual sexual intercourse with another person. Under the New York Penal Law, there are three degrees of rape: the third is the least serious, the first the most serious. It is punishable by a maximum of 4 years' probation.

Following the verdict, Weinstein was taken away in handcuffs to prison, where he awaited the final sentencing on 11 March.

Harvey Weinstein alla corte suprema di New York
Former film producer Harvey Weinstein at the New York Supreme Court on 24 February 2020 © Scott Heins/Getty Images

What he was acquitted of

Weinstein was acquitted of first-degree rape, a charge that, in addition to non-consensual intercourse, requires the use of force. Weinstein was also found not guilty on two counts of predatory sexual assault, the most serious charge in the category (it is a class A-II felony) and one that accordingly carries a potential sentence of life imprisonment. A person is guilty of predatory sexual assault if the jury determines that they also committed first-degree rape, sexual assault or aggravated sexual abuse against more than one other person.

How it came to this

The victims present at the trial were not the only ones. Nearly 100 women from the film and entertainment industry have come forward in recent years to report being victims of sexual harassment by Weinstein, including well-known names such as Gwyneth Paltrow and Uma Thurman, among others. The allegations, moreover, span a very wide period of Weinstein's working life: going back to the 1980s. Indeed, in 2017 an investigation by the New York Times revealed numerous cases of harassment by Weinstein.

Read also: #MeToo. Time's 2017 person of the year is anyone who broke the silence on sexual violence

From that moment, within just a few days, more and more victims began to come forward, encouraging others to do the same and bringing ever more cases to light. One after another they started to speak out, as if a Pandora's box had been opened. Giving them still more strength was the birth of the #MeToo movement, culminating in the first lawsuit filed by the state of New York seeking compensation for the victims and holding the mogul accountable for human rights violations.

Weinstein molestie sessuali new york
The Weinstein case sparked a wave of allegations against other figures in the entertainment world. The hashtag #MeToo was born, giving women the courage to break the silence on sexual harassment © David McNew/Getty Images

The legacy of the verdict

Then as now, Weinstein proclaimed his innocence, stating that he had never had non-consensual sexual relations and presenting as supporting evidence — as put forward by his defence in court — the fact that some women had maintained contact with him even after the events, a scenario that is in fact common in sex crimes, as confirmed in court to the jury by psychiatrist Barbara Ziv: "It is normal to have contact with the aggressor."

I know the history of my relationship with him. But that doesn't change the fact that he raped me.Jessica Mann

This is precisely one of the points on which the prosecution, led by attorneys Joan Illuzzi-Orbon and Meghan Hast, focused heavily: establishing a precedent in which this type of relationship between victim and perpetrator is acknowledged. Furthermore, the prosecution mapped out the defendant's guilt in an impeccable manner: through the presence of dozens of witnesses and their accounts, the figure of Weinstein emerged as a cold and calculating sexual predator, who selected his victims on the basis of need or vulnerability, grooming and abusing them with the same methodical approach over time and across the years.

BREAKING: A New York jury has found Harvey Weinstein guilty on two counts - criminal sexual act in the first degree and rape in the third degree.

The following is a statement in response from 23 #Silencebreakers:

The courage of the women

What's more, despite being acquitted on three of the five counts, the verdict was the first test for the women's rights movement. A turning point, because it was perhaps the first confirmation — belated, but never expected — that yes, it is possible to hold men accountable, regardless of their position of power in society, for harassment, assault and sexual violence in the workplace and beyond, and to see them convicted for it. A reward for the courage and strength of the women who fought and who put themselves forward, a hand extended towards the silence of those who have yet to do so.

No matter how powerful a person may be, or how much mud is thrown at those who have the courage to come forward. Times have changed. The era of the #MeToo movement has begun to unmask these systems of abuse of power. Now women can be heard and believed.Michelle Simpson Tuegel, attorney