The choices of Germany and Luxembourg for affordable or free public transport

The choices of Germany and Luxembourg for affordable or free public transport

Mobility · ·

Luxembourg is the first country in the world to offer free public transport. Germany is considering a one-euro ticket and free transport for students.

It will be the small state of Luxembourg that becomes the first in the world to offer free public transport to its citizens.

mezzi trasporto pubblico lussemburgo gratis 2020 tram
The re-elected government is ready to make Luxembourg's public transport free, as promised during the election campaign, from 2020. Pictured, one of the trams. © GilPe via Wikimedia Commons su licenza CC BY SA 4.0

Germany had recently opened a debate on the possibility of making buses, underground trains and trams free of charge. The debate arose following the Volkswagen diesel scandal and the intention to pass measures to reduce air pollution caused by emissions from private vehicles with combustion engines.

Leggi anche: Trasporto pubblico gratis: la Germania apre un dibattito importante

There had been criticism of this possibility, which stalled the project, with the debate reopening around a capped ticket price — in contrast to what is happening in neighbouring Luxembourg.

The idea of free public transport was put forward by the government elected just a few months ago in the small European state for a new term: a commitment hinted at during the election campaign that also includes free trains for those who do not use first-class carriages. Initially the measure was due to come into effect in summer 2019, but Minister of Mobility François Bausch has stated that it will begin in March 2020.

Not just free public transport: the government's other measures in Luxembourg

Prime Minister Xavier Bettel, who leads a coalition comprising the Democratic Party, the Luxembourg Socialist Workers' Party and the Greens, has placed great emphasis on measures dedicated to environmental protection.

As early as summer 2018, free public transport had been guaranteed for all children and young people up to the age of twenty. From 2020, all tickets will be abolished. Among the other measures already in place in favour of public transport are free shuttle services for secondary school students and a two-euro ticket covering two hours of travel — which, for a state the size of the province of Piacenza, represents a decidedly affordable price.

Leggi anche: Copenaghen avrà solo bus elettrici entro il 2030

The capital of the grand duchy has long suffered from traffic congestion owing to the significant number of commuters from neighbouring European states. Luxembourg City has around 115,000 inhabitants, but a further 400,000 people enter the city for work. Every day, around 200,000 people travel to Luxembourg from France, Belgium and Germany. This causes, according to a study cited by The Guardian, traffic bottlenecks that leave each person travelling by car stationary on the road for several dozen hours — thirty-three in 2016 alone. The hope is that measures in favour of public transport will manage to ease vehicular traffic at least within Luxembourg's borders.

Free or affordable public transport: what Germany has done

The project put forward by the German government at European level to test fare-free public transport did not succeed. The cities that had been selected for the experiment declined after learning that they would not receive public funding from the state.

Some have proposed making public transport free for students and Azubis (those following a training course known as an Ausbildung) and reducing the cost of a ticket to one euro. The latter is a possibility that could be trialled by five cities (Bonn, Essen, Herrenberg, Mannheim, Reutlingen) in place of the free buses, trams and underground project. This follows the model introduced in Vienna as far back as 2012, with an annual pass at 365 euros.

In the meantime, at municipal level there are places that already offer free public transport on certain days, and others that have decided to pursue the elimination of fares in the coming years.

In Tübingen, since February 2018, it has been possible to travel free of charge on public transport on Saturdays. The same choice was made by Aschaffenburg, a town in Bavaria not far from Frankfurt am Main. Remaining in Bavaria, the city of Augsburg has proposed free public transport in the city centre by 2020, a decision driven by the goal of improving air quality in the area.

Rostock is offering free public transport for 20,000 students from 2020, an initiative that will cost the northern German city around 3.3 million euros per year. In Berlin, students from low-income families will be able to use public transport free of charge from the 2019/2020 school year.