Lombardy appeals against the (partial) ban on fox hunting

Lombardy appeals against the (partial) ban on fox hunting

Environment · ·

The region, with questionable timing, has lodged an appeal against the suspension of the fox culling plan in the province of Lodi.

The red fox (Vulpes vulpes) has, more or less always, enjoyed a bad reputation. Its extraordinary capacity for adaptation and ecological plasticity has been viewed in an anthropomorphic and negative light by popular tradition, which portrays it as a cunning and opportunistic animal. For a long time, the fox was considered a "pest", on a par with other carnivores and mustelids, and was consequently hunted for decades in every conceivable way and without mercy.

Read also: La caccia è finita, quante vittime ha fatto la stagione venatoria

Today we know that the concept of "pest" is wrong and unscientific; these predators in fact have beneficial effects on agriculture and even on our health, by keeping populations of rodents and insects in check and preventing the spread of certain diseases. Yet even today in Italy, thousands of foxes are culled every year. The main reason given is that hunters regard these canids as unwanted competitors in the capture of game, particularly farm-bred game destined for hunting purposes.

Volpe rossa che corre in una radura innevata
The fox culling plan covering the territory of the province of Lodi would also have allowed foxes to be killed at night, from motor vehicles and using artificial light sources © Ingimage

Lombardy on the side of hunters

Despite the absence of reliable scientific data on any actual negative impact of foxes on domestic and wild animals, and the current grave situation in Italy, which has been particularly hard hit by the Covid-19 pandemic, the Lombardy region decided to lodge an appeal against the ruling of the Tar that had suspended the fox culling plan in the province of Lodi.

Read also: La Lombardia approva l'abbattimento di quasi mille cormorani per far contenti i pescatori

On 10 January last, the Lombardy Tar, following an appeal by Enpa, Lac and Lav, had in fact provisionally suspended, pending a decision, certain parts of the plan that provided for the killing of foxes across the territory of the province of Lodi. According to the order, the plan — which allowed, among other things, foxes to be killed using the cruel method of den hunting — violated national law 157 on the protection of wild animals.

Testa di volpe imbalsamata appesa come trofeo
The systematic hostility towards predatory animals, labelled "pests", dates back to law 1420 of 1923 © Christopher Furlong/Getty Images

An illegitimate culling plan

In particular, Lav explained, the plan allowed the killing of foxes by private individuals — that is, hunters — "in contrast with the national rule that permits such activity only to public officials, and in breach of the numerous rulings of the constitutional court that have already struck down other regional laws similar to that of Lombardy."

Cucciolo di volpe rossa tra la vegetazione
Fox control plans are entrusted to individual regions © Ingimage

Questionable timing

"It is horrifying to have to note that, in the midst of the coronavirus emergency, in Lombardy — the most battered region in our country — administrators have found plenty of time to devote to hunters' interests and the protection of their pastime," the animal welfare associations commented in a statement.

Read also: Theresa May potrebbe riaprire la caccia alla volpe in Inghilterra e Galles

Moreover, as noted, the Tar order does not represent a definitive ban, but must be assessed by the Council of State, which is due to reach a decision on 16 July next. The region could therefore simply have waited for the ruling and, if appropriate, lodged an appeal at that point, rather than concerning itself with culling foxes in the middle of lockdown.