Lombardy approves the culling of almost a thousand cormorants to please fishermen

Lombardy approves the culling of almost a thousand cormorants to please fishermen

Environment · ·

In mid-November, 10 per cent of the regional cormorant population will be culled to “safeguard fishing”.

In Lombardy, 993 cormorants (Phalacrocorax carbo) will be killed to "protect valuable fish species". These birds are extraordinary fishers, and the region fears they have an excessive impact on fish populations, which apparently only far less skilled but far more influential predators — fishermen — may benefit from. The regional council has approved, this year as well, a plan providing for the culling of around 10 per cent of Lombardy's cormorant population. The hunt for these waterbirds — whose numbers, after decades of persecution, have been growing again over the past thirty years thanks to protection laws — began on 1 October 2019, will continue until 15 March 2020, and will affect the provinces of Como, Varese, Lecco, Bergamo and Brescia.

Cormorano che nuota in un lago
The cormorant, a species widespread in various subspecies across Europe, Asia, Africa, the Americas, Australia and New Zealand, feeds mainly on fish © Ingimage

The reasons for the cull

The cormorant is a protected species, under both the Bern Convention and Italian law no. 157 of 1992. For years, however, these animals have been the target of various culling campaigns owing to conflicts with human activities. The Lombardy region, together with the Istituto superiore per la protezione e la ricerca ambientale, has authorised the selective control of these animals specifically to "safeguard fishing — explained Agriculture, Food and Green Systems councillor Fabio Rolfi —. The excessive presence of cormorants is damaging sport and professional fishing in Lombardy".

Pesca sul fiume
The introduction of non-native fish species, for the benefit of fishermen, is one of the main causes of biodiversity loss in our country © Ingimage

Natural predators

The troubling thing is that Rolfi, judging by his statements, maintains that the cormorant is a non-native species. "It is necessary to defend the ecosystem from the devastating effect of non-native species in excessive numbers," the councillor declared. This is of course not the case: cormorants are native predators that play an important ecological role. If our river and lake environments are in a state of degradation and their biodiversity is increasingly diminished, it seems absurd to blame the cormorants; it would be far more appropriate to turn our attention to harmful human activities, such as the repeated release of non-native fish species for sport fishing — that, indeed, is one of the main causes of biological diversity loss.

Tre cormorani mentre volano
Cormorants are gregarious in habit and form large concentrations of individuals © Ingimage

Why the hunt is pointless

The selective hunting of cormorants, as well as being unjust, would also be pointless. This is the conclusion of the study Licensed control does not reduce local Cormorant Phalacrocorax carbo population size in winter, published in 2013. The authors found no substantial differences in growth rates of the cormorant population between areas where culling had been carried out and those where it had not. Indeed, it appears that where hunting was most intense, population growth was also greater. "These results provide no evidence that removal of cormorants at a local scale has an effect on long-term population size," the study reads. "They also suggest that control measures have not influenced national population trends".

Read also: Nei fiumi italiani saranno introdotte specie alloctone, a rischio la biodiversità

Cormorants are certainly not charismatic predators like wolves and bears, capable of capturing public sympathy. That almost a thousand individuals are nonetheless being killed, simply to please a handful of fishermen, amid general indifference, strikes us as yet another unscientific measure adopted by our country.