Why the Ischia tragedy has sparked debate on land consumption, adaptation and building amnesties

Why the Ischia tragedy has sparked debate on land consumption, adaptation and building amnesties

Environment · ·

Rescue workers are still on the ground in Ischia: 8 victims killed by landslides. Land consumption, building amnesties and the lack of an adaptation plan among the causes.

It was another night's work for the fire brigade in the Ischian municipalities of Casamicciola Terme and Lacco Ameno, following the dramatic landslide that at dawn on Saturday turned the Campanian island of Ischia upside down: the cloudburst triggered flooding and mudslides. 15 homes were swept away by the landslides, which also carried off cars, roads and, tragically, people. Eight victims have been confirmed, but four people are still missing. Around 230 people have been evacuated.

🔴 #Ischia #nubifragio, individuato dai #vigilidelfuoco in via Celario il corpo senza vita di un disperso, in corso le delicate operazioni di recupero. Sale a 8 il numero delle vittime accertate [#28novembre 9:45]

To assist the population and search for missing persons, 160 firefighters with 70 vehicles have been operating on the island since Saturday morning, arriving from Campania, Lazio, Tuscany, Abruzzo, Puglia and Molise. The national corps teams are deployed across the Casamicciola area: experts in search-and-rescue topography, Usar (Urban search and rescue), Saf (Speleo alpino fluviali), dog units and Sapr (remotely piloted aircraft systems) operators have got to work in the upper section of via Celario for search operations. Divers from Tuscany are operating with sonar to scan the seabed in the stretch of water near the port.

Nuclei subacquei di @guardiacostiera e sommozzatori dei @vigilidelfuoco in azione a #Ischia per verificare l'eventuale presenza di dispersi nelle auto trascinate a mare dalla colata di fango
#27novembre

Time to stop calling these exceptional events

Following what Civil Protection describes as exceptional weather events that struck the island of Ischia, the Council of Ministers resolved to declare a state of emergency lasting 12 months. Two million euros from the National Emergencies Fund have been allocated for the implementation of the first urgent measures aimed at rescuing and assisting the affected population and restoring the functioning of public services and strategic network infrastructure.

🔴 #Ischia #nubifragio, 100 #vigilidelfuoco impegnati con 40 automezzi sull'isola: continuano i soccorsi alla popolazione e le operazioni di ricerca dispersi [#26novembre 19:45]

Hidden within this last point, however, are at least two enormous conceptual problems. The first is that definition: "exceptional weather events." Events that are, in reality, no longer so exceptional. Coldiretti notes that in Italy, in November alone, no fewer than 242 extreme weather events struck the country — cloudbursts, downpours, windstorms, tornadoes and hailstorms — battering a territory made more fragile by abandonment and concreting over, which have reduced the land's capacity to absorb rainfall and put the environment and the safety of citizens at risk through landslides and floods.

Il comunicato stampa del Consiglio dei Ministri n. 7⤵️governo.it/it/articolo/co…

The second problem is, yet again, the fact that action is taken exclusively on an emergency basis, in response to a disaster — as the Council of Ministers has (rightly) done — but never in a preventive manner.

When will land consumption be stopped and an adaptation plan introduced?

The proposed law to halt land consumption has been stalled in the Italian Parliament since 2016: approved by the Chamber of Deputies, it envisaged reaching zero — that is, not a single additional square metre of concrete — by 2050.

In the meantime, in 2021 land consumption in Italy reached its highest level of the past decade, with 69.1 sq km sacrificed for the construction of buildings and infrastructure. "In the immediate term it is necessary to intervene with concrete assistance to help the affected populations," states Coldiretti president Ettore Prandini, while stressing that "we must accelerate the approval of the land consumption law, which has been languishing in Parliament for years and could give Italy a cutting-edge tool for the protection of its territory."

#Consumodisuolo: nel 2021 il valore più alto degli ultimi 10 anni.
70 km2 di nuove coperture artificiali in un solo anno.
È il consumo di suolo in Italia fotografato dal Rapporto @SNPAmbiente 2022.
Leggi il comunicato stampa completo: bit.ly/3BhETlV

But above all, Italy still lacks a Climate Change Adaptation Plan — the instrument every country should have in place to mitigate the impacts of climate change on its territory. That too has been at a standstill since 2018, after Italy approved its Climate Change Adaptation Strategy in 2015: what is missing, in practice, is its implementation. To be fair, on that very Sunday the Council of Ministers itself assured that "the National Climate Change Adaptation Plan will be approved before the end of the year": all that remains is to hope.

Chi ha ragione? la casa o la montagna? Un test semplice semplice per capire se anche dentro di voi (come nel 90% degli italiani) vive un piccolo cementificatore edilizio...almeno risparmiateci le solite litanie su cordogli e maltempo (foto @repubblica)

The 2018 building amnesty for Ischia

In the meantime, beyond the immediate rescue efforts and the declaration of the state of emergency, the search for responsibility in the Ischia case began immediately. While the Naples public prosecutor's office has opened an investigation file on the hypothesis of the offence of culpable disaster, with no names entered in the register of suspects, the political controversy is focused on the 2018 Genoa Decree — enacted by the Lega-M5S government in the wake of the collapse of the Morandi Bridge — which also contained an article providing for a building amnesty specifically for the Ischia municipalities struck by the earthquake the previous year.

The decree addressed the more than 27,000 amnesty applications submitted by Ischia residents (according to data from the Legambiente dossier Mare Monstrum 2016), across the three municipalities of Casamicciola Terme, Forio and Lacco Ameno, under the three national amnesty laws enacted over the past 30 years: specifically, the one dating back to 1985, that of 1994, and that of 2003.

Intervista a "Mezz'ora in più" | 27/11/2022

Poco fa sono stato ospite a "mezz'ora in più", qui il video della mia intervista ⤵️

Posted by Giuseppe Conte on Sunday, November 27, 2022

Then-prime minister Giuseppe Conte and his movement have, in recent hours, assured that "article 25 of the Bridge Decree was in no way an amnesty; we simply tried to unblock a situation that already existed without waiving hydrogeological constraints. The Conte government in 2018 found itself faced with the emergency of earthquake victims and their requests for help in rebuilding their homes. Faced with this emergency situation, a very simple decision was made: that on the amnesty procedures dating back years and decades, the state had to speed up its responses — a yes or a no to citizens within 6 months, in compliance with existing constraints (landscape, hydrogeological, etc.)."

The article contained in the decree, subsequently converted into law, reads verbatim as follows:

"I Comuni di Casamicciola Terme, Forio, Lacco Ameno dell'Isola di Ischia "definiscono le istanze di con