Why there is talk of a building amnesty in Ischia and what it involves
Rights — di Simone Santi
Why the emergency decree mentions a building amnesty in Ischia and what it involves — everything you need to understand.

Why the emergency decree mentions a building amnesty in Ischia and what it involves — everything you need to understand.
It has been nicknamed the Genoa decree, the one approved today in its final reading by the Senate, but it also contains an important provision for Ischia, the Campanian island struck by the earthquake in August 2017. A provision that has been hotly debated: for some it represents an acceleration of the process for rebuilding the buildings damaged by the earthquake, while for others it is nothing short of a disguised building amnesty.

The article contained in the decree-law, approved today by the Senate in its final reading, reads verbatim as follows:
"The municipalities of Casamicciola Terme, Forio, Lacco Ameno on the island of Ischia shall settle the pending amnesty applications relating to buildings destroyed or damaged by the earthquake of 21 August 2017, submitted pursuant to Law no. 47 of 28 February 1985, Law no. 724 of 23 December 1994, and Decree-Law no. 269 of 30 September 2003. For the settlement of the applications referred to in this article, only the provisions of Chapters IV and V of Law no. 47 of 28 February 1985 shall apply. 1-bis. For applications submitted pursuant to Decree-Law no. 269 of 30 September 2003, converted, with amendments, by Law no. 326 of 24 November 2003, the procedures referred to in paragraph 1 shall be settled subject to the issue of a favourable opinion by the authority responsible for protecting the landscape constraint."
The decree effectively intervenes on the more than 27,000 amnesty applications submitted by the inhabitants of Ischia (according to data from the Mare Monstrum 2016 dossier by Legambiente), in the three municipalities of Casamicciola Terme, Forio and Lacco Ameno, familiar also to readers of Elena Ferrante's My Brilliant Friend saga, on the occasion of the three national amnesty laws that followed one another over the past 30 years: specifically, the one dating back to 1985, that of 1994 and that of 2003.
Technically, therefore, no new building amnesty is envisaged, as Agostino Santillo, senator for the Movimento 5 Stelle, also recalled in his voting declaration: "Article 25 merely provides for the settlement of pending amnesty applications. Ischia has made illegal construction its hallmark, but its citizens have the right not to be abandoned." The aim is therefore to unblock the process, in order to facilitate the resolution of cases within six months, there being among other things over 600 dwellings subject to a demolition order.
The bone of contention, however, is the passage in the article stipulating that "in the settlement of the applications, only the provisions of the 1985 law shall apply" — that is, the oldest of the three (dating back to the government of Bettino Craxi) and the one with the broadest scope. The issue is well explained by Legambiente president Stefano Ciafani, for whom "the 1985 legislation would make it possible to regularise buildings that even the two amnesties subsequently approved by Berlusconi governments in 1994 and 2003 prohibited, precisely because they are located in areas that are hazardous from a hydrogeological and seismic standpoint, as well as being subject to landscape protection constraints."
This is because the two subsequent laws impose increasingly strict constraints, referring to environmental regulations approved in the meantime from 1985 onwards: in practice, had the provisions of the 2003 law applied, many buildings constructed in areas subject to environmental and landscape protection constraints would not have qualified for amnesty. It is for this reason that Legambiente itself speaks of a de facto amnesty.
What continues to keep the debate open, even after the final approval of the text, is another passage of the article in question, the one stating that "the procedures shall be settled subject to the issue of a favourable opinion by the authority responsible for protecting the landscape constraint." Approval of the amnesty application will not be automatic: the final say rests with the Superintendency for Archaeology, Fine Arts and Landscape for the Municipality of Naples.