Modi wins India's election, but his is a compromised victory

Modi wins India's election, but his is a compromised victory

Rights · ·

Narendra Modi wins India's general election, but with a reduced majority. To form a government he will have to rely on allied parties.

The National Democratic Alliance, the Indian political coalition led by the Bharatiya janata party (Bjp) of outgoing prime minister Narendra Modi, won 293 seats in the lower house of Parliament (240 of which went to the Bjp), against 234 for the opposition, the India coalition led by Rahul Gandhi's Indian National Congress.

Narendra Modi, 73, is thus set to begin a third consecutive term as Prime Minister of India, after the Electoral Commission confirmed at the start of Wednesday 5 June that the parties making up his coalition had collectively surpassed the parliamentary majority threshold.

His victory, however, was not as overwhelming as expected: 293 seats is a result well below the target of 400 seats announced on multiple occasions during the election campaign, and below the 303 seats won in 2019. And there is more: now that he is no longer invincible, Modi will have to negotiate his nationalist agenda with his allies.

Modi vince le elezioni in India, ma la sua è una vittoria compromessa
Modi takes a crowd bath during a campaign event in Uttar Pradesh © Elke Scholiers/Getty Images

Modi will not be able to form a government on his own

Modi's Bjp, the dominant force in Indian politics for a decade, was expected to maintain its firm grip. But the results of the world's largest election shook the Hindu nationalist party, which is 33 seats short of governing alone (the minimum threshold is 272 seats) and is therefore now forced to rely on allies to form a government.

Some of Modi's biggest losses came in India's most populous state, Uttar Pradesh, in the north, with around 240 million inhabitants. His party has led the state government for ten years and won 62 of the 80 lower-house seats in the national Parliament at the previous election in 2019. On Tuesday evening, as the count entered its final stages, the Bjp was ahead in only 33 seats. In his own constituency, Varanasi, Modi's winning margin shrank from half a million on the previous occasion to around 150,000.

But the most glaring defeat may be the one suffered in the constituency of Faizabad: the state is home to the magnificent Hindu Ram temple, in the city of Ayodhya, built on land wrested from Muslims. Its construction was the cornerstone of the Hindu nationalist movement, and Modi had hoped that its inauguration, shortly before the election campaign began, would unite his Hindu support base and bring new supporters into the fold. But voices within the Bjp have said that the party's ostentatious display of the temple may have made a large section of Hindus uncomfortable — those at the bottom of the rigid caste hierarchy. The opposition quickly seized on this contradiction and painted Modi as pursuing an upper-caste agenda while in effect abandoning the most disadvantaged.

Other reasons behind the Bjp's loss of support can be found in rising prices, the unemployment rate and the controversial army recruitment reform. But the greatest weight was probably carried by an aggressive and divisive election campaign that may have alienated voters in some parts of the country.

Looking back at a decade of political activity, it becomes clear how the leader of the Indian right has worked to transform a country that is extremely heterogeneous, held together by a secular democratic system, into an overtly Hindu state, marginalising India's large Muslim minority. His increasingly authoritarian turn — with a crackdown on dissent that has created a chilling climate of self-censorship — has pushed Indian democracy towards a one-party state, his critics say.

rahul-gandhi
Opposition leader Rahul Gandhi © Elke Scholiers/Getty Images

The revival of the opposition party

The real surprise came from the unexpected revival of the Congress Party, which many had seen as irreparably weakened after the heavy losses suffered in the two previous elections, but which instead almost doubled its results compared to 2019 in this round. Credit goes to an election campaign that placed all its bets on social justice, framing the picture as one in which Modi's authoritarianism benefits the wealthiest class while the country sinks into unemployment. India's economic growth has, so far, primarily enriched those at the top and the better-off classes in India.

The opposition's result is all the more extraordinary given that the Congress party also had to overcome the legal difficulties of Rahul Gandhi, the public face of the India coalition. While Gandhi was seeking to strengthen his standing by leading long marches across India, the Bjp ensnared him in a court case that led to his expulsion from Parliament. Gandhi was subsequently reinstated by the Indian High Court and will now be eligible to stand for re-election.

देश की जनता-जनार्दन ने एनडीए पर लगातार तीसरी बार अपना विश्वास जताया है।

भारत के इतिहास में ये एक अभूतपूर्व पल है।
मैं इस स्नेह और आशीर्वाद के लिए अपने परिवारजनों को नमन करता हूं।

मैं देशवासियों को विश्वास दिलाता हूं कि उनकी आकांक्षाओं को पूरा करने के लिए हम नई ऊर्जा, नई
177660 18189 4 giu 2024 · Apri su X →

Modi's next steps

The Bjp will be able to govern thanks to the strong performance of two regional parties: the Telugu desam party, in the southern state of Andhra Pradesh, with 16 seats, and the Janata dal united in the eastern state of Bihar, with 12 seats. Both parties are openly secular, which gives Modi's opponents hope that their influence may slow the prime minister's nationalist drive.

But beyond nationalism, Modi's other headache is the economy: the narrow victory could jeopardise the growth plans projected at around 8 per cent, writes the financial publication Bloomberg.

Despite all these concerns, Modi made an effort to maintain a positive outlook, announcing his victory at around 4pm on X (formerly Twitter): "It is a historic feat in India's history," he wrote. "With such a generous reading of the result," writes the New York Times, "Modi seems to be suggesting that his party managed to overcome local unpopularity solely thanks to his personal drive." Alternatively, having once again centred the entire election campaign on himself could mean that the "Modi brand" too may have run its course. But that is a conversation for the next election.