India is about to begin the longest and largest democratic elections in the world

India is about to begin the longest and largest democratic elections in the world

Rights · ·

On 19 April 2024 elections begin in India. They will last 44 days and will call almost one billion people to vote.

Elections in India begin on 19 April. They will be the greatest exercise in democracy in history, even though that same democracy is, by many accounts, at risk. Almost one billion people will vote in the general elections to choose the new members of the Lok Sabha, the lower house of parliament. The electoral process will last several weeks, involving a total number of voters that far exceeds those who went to the polls in the first months of 2024 in countries considered populous, such as Bangladesh, Pakistan, Russia and Indonesia. Among the almost 700 parties at the ballot box is the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) – the Indian People's Party – led by the incumbent prime minister Narendra Modi, today at the peak of his popularity after 10 years in government during which he has steered the country of 1.4 billion people – which recently overtook China as the most populous in the world – towards a new nationalism. No longer secular, but belonging to a political Hinduism, decisive in the exercise of a power that has ended up marginalising other religions. More than the outcome of the elections – Modi's victory appears certain – many are questioning the progressive distancing of India from democracy. Rahul Gandhi, one of the opposition leaders, has spoken of the risk that a reconfirmation of the BJP, perhaps with even more crushing numbers, could lead to a reform of the Constitution in an authoritarian direction, destined to "inflame" the country. A process already under way, confirmed by the political repression of opponents.

In India stanno per iniziare le elezioni democratiche più lunghe e imponenti del mondo
Modi is engulfed in a crowd during a campaign event in Uttar Pradesh © Elke Scholiers/Getty Images

The out-of-scale numbers of India's elections

Whether in the mountains of the Himalayas, the arid zones of Rajasthan or the almost uninhabited islands of the Indian Ocean, members of the Indian electoral commission must ensure the smooth running of the elections that will give rise to the new Lok Sabha, the lower house of the Indian parliament, composed of 545 members. This year, state officials have set up a polling station at 4,650 metres above sea level, in a village in the northern state of Himachal Pradesh. It is the highest polling station in the world. In the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, off the eastern coast, voting locations have sprung up in the middle of the jungle.

popolazione india
India becomes the most populous country in the world ©Anindito Mukherjee / Stringer

In short, the challenge is monumental. The data made available by the commission also paint a picture of an unprecedented electoral process. Registered voters number 969 million, distributed across 28 states and 8 territories, including that of the capital, New Delhi. In just over one million polling stations scattered across the country, more than 5 million electronic voting machines will be put into operation.

A vote lasting 44 days

The vote for the Lok Sabha matters because it is the more powerful of the two chambers that make up the Indian parliament. The party or coalition that wins a majority nominates one of its elected members as prime minister, who has no term limits under the constitutional order.

Indian electoral law for the lower house of parliament provides for a single-member plurality system, where each party puts forward only one candidate per constituency. The candidate who wins the most votes is elected. In the allocation of seats, the law provides for a quota of 25 per cent reserved for the so-called Dalits – "untouchables" – belonging to the most marginalised sections of the population. A similar criterion applies to the Adivasis, the indigenous peoples of the Indian subcontinent. In these electoral constituencies, only candidates from the protected groups may stand, even though all eligible adults may cast their vote. Although the Indian parliament recently passed a new measure to reserve a third of legislative seats for women, the implementation of this law has been delayed until after 2024.

aria-condizionata-india
Buildings in Uttar Pradesh, India © Anindito Mukherjee/Bloomberg via Getty Images

It is referred to as an electoral process because the elections will be structured in seven phases, the first of which will get under way on 19 April, when the polls open. Further voting dates are scheduled for 26 April, and 7, 13, 20 and 25 May, and 1 June. While in some states voting will be completed in a single day, others will have several dates available. In total, the process spans 44 days, as the count is postponed to 4–5 June, after which the results will be announced. India is accustomed to holding elections "broken up" across several days, so much so that the historical minimum was the 4 days of 1980, while in 2019 it took 39.

"The longer the process, the greater the opportunity for the ruling party to use government infrastructure to campaign," said Nadendla Bhaskara Rao, president of the Center for Media Studies in New Delhi, to Al Jazeera. Indeed, the government has already put together an immense deployment of personnel ahead of the vote – 15 million people between polling staff and police officers – who will exercise comprehensive oversight: from poll-related violence to attempted fraud. Although it is very complicated to definitively establish the electoral expenditure of each party, partly owing to a weak monitoring system, Rao's official estimate puts the figure at 1,200 billion rupees, equivalent to 13 billion euros.

The keys to Modi's victory

Narendra Modi's BJP intends to replicate its landslide victory of 2019, with the aim of tightening its grip on the Lok Sabha. The Hindu nationalist party leads a coalition in which dozens of parties participate: a trifle when one considers that the political formations registered this year number over 2,600. For these elections, Modi has set a target of 370 seats, 67 more than in 2019. If the incumbent prime minister were to regain the confidence of voters by securing a third term, he would have the opportunity to become the third longest-serving prime minister in Indian political history at the end of the five years. The country's first prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, governed for approximately 16 years and 9 months consecutively, while his daughter Indira Gandhi governed for a total of approximately 15 years and 11 months.

The cornerstone of Modi's project for the elections in India lies in his, to date, unchallenged popularity. In tracing its origins, reporter Mujib Mashal of the American daily New York Times said that "Modi has many avatars: yoga teacher, poet, technology champion, nature photographer, even a holy man dressed in colourful robes and headdresses." A profile that converges in the pervasiveness of his orations to the Indian people, whether delivered by radio in the thirty-minute live broadcasts that have now become the most listened-to programme in the country, or when he speaks before communities.

The leader's strength lies in his profound knowledge of India's popular roots, developed over decades as a Hindu right-wing evangelist, above all among members of the country's most disadvantaged castes. The clearest proof of Modi's ability to attract support is that of the Other Backward Classes, a term encompassing various under-recorded sub-castes that together represent around 40 per cent of the population. Modi, who comes from this very same social fabric, made his greatest inroads among the poorer strata, winning almost 50 per cent of the vote at the last elections: "In the Modi system, communication is crafted very carefully, almost always positive and always framed to present the indistinguishability of Modi from India," researcher Joyojeet Pal of the University of Michigan told the New York Times.

The narrative of the Bjp's victory in the 2019 elections as the outcome of a predominantly identity-driven tension — pitting Modi's Hindu nationalist project against the traditional secularism of the Inc — is a partial one. It is unlikely that the prime minister would have managed to penetrate Indian social fabric so deeply without resorting to pragmatic measures broadly extended to the population. Nor would the management of the national security crisis with Pakistan, which escalated during those very years, have had this potential to build mass loyalty.

To secure over time the support shaped by the emotionalism of the nationalist narrative, it was necessary to exponentially increase state subsidies, forging a "new welfare", as Modi's former chief economic adviser Arvind Subramanian defined it — he was instrumental in shaping the prime minister's economic programme.

Narendra Modi coinvolto nel land grabbing in India
Narendra Modi, Indian prime minister © Ian Forsyth/Getty Images

Over time the government increased investment in the public distribution of private goods such as gas cylinders, sanitation facilities, bank accounts and electricity connections, to which were added direct cash transfers into household bank accounts. The startling figure, illustrated by researcher Suyash Rai of the Carnegie Institute, is that whereas between 2013 and 2014 the central government transferred 73.7 billion rupees in cash (800 million euros) to around 108 million beneficiaries, between 2019 and 2020 it channelled 2,000 billion rupees (31 billion euros) in cash to more than 700 million beneficiaries. Added to this were 1,400 billion rupees (18 billion euros) in in-kind benefits, further increased in the wake of the pandemic.

The faces of the opposition, weakened by legal proceedings

As mentioned, the political contest beginning on 19 April will see two sizeable coalitions facing off. On one side is the National Democratic Alliance (Nda), the governing grouping led by the Bjp that includes the parties of the conservative right. On the other side is the Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance, known by the acronym India and led by the Indian National Congress (Inc). The front is heterogeneous, ranging from the secular centrism of the Inc to left-wing parties, through to the populists of the common man's party, the Aam Aadmi Party (Aap).

The founder of the latter and former Chief Minister of New Delhi, Arvind Kejriwal, was arrested at the end of March and imprisoned in the Tihar jail in the Indian capital. Kejriwal is the founder of the Aap, and is currently in prison on corruption charges relating to a case involving the private licensing of alcohol sales. In 2021, the National Capital Territory of New Delhi had lowered the drinking age to 21, inviting private operators to open shops in order to liberalise sales. This policy was suspended in 2022, and a subsequent investigation led to the arrest of two members of Kejriwal's party. His arrest sparked heated protests in recent weeks, in which senior Aap figures also participated, accusing the judiciary of conducting a political trial against one of Modi's and his party's most "vocal" opponents on the very eve of the elections.

#ArvindKejriwal's petition before the Supreme Court states that if the Delhi CM is not released forthwith to participate in the upcoming elections, it will establish a precedence for ruling parties to arrest opposition leaders on flimsy charges before elections.

Kejriwal’s plea

Kejriwal rose to prominence in India in 2012, when, as an official of the state tax collection agency, he had come to lead a secular, populist movement whose primary objective was the fight against corruption. The Aap's symbol is, fittingly, a broom — to "sweep it away". In 2013 he was elected in the elections for the National Capital Territory of New Delhi, bringing to an end 15 years of Inc rule. He was subsequently re-elected both in 2015 — after having resigned early — and in 2020. The Aap governs the state of Punjab, in the north of the country, while at national level it is part of the coalition opposing Modi, towards whom it is among the most critical parties.

Rahul Gandhi sharply criticised Kejriwal's arrest, accusing the government of controlling the judiciary and going so far as to call Modi a "dictator". Gandhi, who officially stood as a candidate in the elections last March, is among the Inc's leaders, as well as being the latest scion of a highly successful political dynasty, which began with his grandmother Indira Gandhi and continued with his parents Rajiv and Sonia Gandhi. The current president of the party is Mallikarjun Kharge, who leads the opposition in the Rajya Sabha, the upper house of parliament.

The unemployment rate on the eve of the elections in India

What will dominate these seemingly endless elections will above all be the economic question in its broader sense, which will encompass national economic growth before landing on the distribution of wealth, welfare policies and employment levels. In recent years India's economy has overtaken that of Great Britain, becoming the fifth largest in the world.

This has not, however, coincided with a wealth redistribution system — as illustrated by a study from the World Inequality Database — with the result that the number of billionaires has almost tripled over the past ten years, while the great majority of the less well-off classes, often settled in rural India, have remained essentially stuck in place.

Tuk tuk
For some people, outdoor work is the only way to make a living © Pixabay

There is then another cumbersome debate linking the excessive resort to subsidies — so-called welfarism — to the rising unemployment rate. The shower of government handouts described earlier has not, in fact, been accompanied by employment policies, which today are registering alarming figures. According to