War and crisis are great business for oil companies
Economy & innovation — di Maurizio Bongioanni
Oil companies are doing great business thanks to market instability and war. And extraction projects keep on growing.

Oil companies are doing great business thanks to market instability and war. And extraction projects keep on growing.
The war in Ukraine has, so far, proved to be a boon for "Big Oil". The four largest oil companies (Shell, ExxonMobil, Chevron and BP) have hit record profits during this period. More broadly, the entire fossil fuels sector is in excellent health.
The numbers speak for themselves: in the first quarter of 2022, Shell made more than $9 billion, almost triple its figure for the first quarter of 2021. ExxonMobil doubled its profits compared with the same period the previous year, posting $5.48 billion last week. Chevron reached $6.3 billion, while BP, with an increase of $6.2 billion, recorded its highest figure in ten years of accounts.
In short, Russia's invasion once again demonstrates how deeply the global economy is built around fossil fuels. The enormous gains made by oil & gas companies should shine a spotlight on their failure to reinvest windfall profits in the urgently needed energy transition.

Failing to reinvest profits in the transition has two consequences. The first is that the costs of the market crisis will continue to weigh on consumers' pockets (petrol and heating above all). Not to mention atmospheric emissions: if oil and gas extraction continues, the climate targets over which so many words have been spent will never be met. And this despite the International Energy Agency having been quite clear: in its May 2021 report, the IEA called for all new oil and gas extraction projects to be blocked if we want the rise in temperatures to stay below 1.5 degrees Celsius.
Unfortunately, "money makes money," and the excellent revenues earned by the companies have, as revealed by a Guardian investigation, convinced Big Oil that it is worthwhile planning hundreds of new fuel extraction projects. An investment plan drawn up in great secrecy that will translate into an "emissions bomb" for our planet.
A catastrophe, then, in the name of profit. The fossil fuel industry's short-term expansion plans specifically envisage the launch of 195 projects that will produce a quantity of greenhouse gases equivalent to a decade's worth of emissions from China, the world's largest "polluter." But this time it is not China that holds the record for planned projects — it is the United States, Australia and Canada. Most seriously of all, 60 per cent of these projects are already operational, and the extraction techniques chosen are — needless to say — among the most impactful: fracking, tar sands and extraction in Arctic waters.
But new projects are only part of the problem. Seen in the right perspective, the Western world's Big Oil companies hold only around 10 per cent of reserves and a similar share of global hydrocarbon production. The largest extraction projects are those carried out by the so-called NOCs (National Oil Companies), i.e. the state-owned giants: we are talking about Gazprom, Saudi Aramco and Qatar Energy. It is therefore essential to bring these players into the global conversation on the transition as well.

In truth, fossil fuel multinationals have not enriched themselves solely thanks to the instability caused by the war. The profits of Italy's Eni, for example, already recorded a jump of 53 per cent in the final four months of 2021, when the price of gas had begun to rise. Despite calls for decarbonisation, Eni's hydrocarbon exploration portfolio has been renewed with new permits around the world: Angola, Ivory Coast, Egypt, the United Arab Emirates, Norway, the United Kingdom and Vietnam, as the association Re:Common explains.
According to Eni's plan, the windfall profits generated will be reinvested in fossil fuels, whose peak will only be reached in 2025. And Italy is comfortable with this: in February 2022 the Italian government had introduced a windfall profits levy to claw back gains from those who had grown rich and to provide support to families and businesses hit by price rises. Paradoxically, the decree struck part of the renewables sector (such as cooperatives) while leaving Eni's investment plan untouched.
But why is it so difficult to compel the oil & gas sector to reinvest windfall profits in the energy transition? While it is true that oil and gas companies are diversifying their portfolios to include renewable energy sources, it is equally true that they are not abandoning their core business: fossil fuel extraction.
Last year, Shell spent $2.4 billion, or 13 per cent of its investments, on the energy transition — that is, on projects centred on renewable sources. In the first quarter of 2022, the company spent $985 million in the clean energy sector. Barely a tenth of its profits for the first quarter.

And yet civil society has been far from lacking in protests: a year ago last May, an activist fund managed, through shareholder activism, to gain seats on ExxonMobil's board of directors and exert pressure from within on issues of environmental responsibility. During the same period, a Dutch court ordered Shell to drastically reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 2030. Shell contested the ruling and has since moved its headquarters from the Netherlands to the United Kingdom.
Rulings of this kind also target the responsibility of governments: Canada was recently taken to court by the organisation Ecojustice (of which an NGO co-founded by current Canadian Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault is also a member), before the federal court, in an attempt to block Norwegian company Equinor's plan to extract 300 million barrels of oil off the coast of Newfoundland.
At the end of the first quarter of 2021, when the chief executives of the three largest US oil and gas companies presented their companies' earnings, investors had raised a series of questions about how the firms intended to address climate change. In 2022, by contrast, the same shareholders, faced with enormous profits, focused solely on dividends, abandoning their environmental aspirations.
Money talks, as the saying goes, and this year – unlike last – the oil & gas sector is the best-performing sector on the financial markets. "In a free-market economy, where profit reigns, how do you gradually wind down a product that is generating enormous profits?", journalist Justin Worland asks in Time. "These have driven the sector's climate denial from the start; and now they are driving investment decisions. The age of oil will end when it is no longer a good investment." But how? The answer is always the same: invest in renewable energy sources and eliminate all subsidies to fossil fuels. Only then will we be able to make oil and gas "uneconomical".