On 14 December, the first hearing takes place in the case brought by citizens and organisations against the government. The charge is climate inaction in relation to the Paris Agreement.
The day of 'universal judgement' has arrived: on 14 December, with a first remote hearing, the first lawsuit brought against the Italian state for climate inaction gets under way. A historic event, in which Italy will appear "in the dock" for the first time, accused of having failed to act adequately in the fight against the climate crisis and in pursuit of the goal of limiting the rise in average global temperature set out in the Paris Agreement: as close as possible to 1.5 degrees centigrade above the pre-industrial average.
These failures would have the effect of violating numerous fundamental rights. Indeed, one of the central arguments of the legal case is the relationship between human rights and climate change. This, at least, is the framework of the lawsuit brought by the claimants — 203 in total — gathered under the evocatively named awareness campaign Giudizio Universale, intended to underscore the global scale of the climate challenge and the urgency of deploying countermeasures: among them 17 minors — represented in court by their parents — 162 citizens and 24 organisations.
Anche l'Ecomuseo Mare Memoria Viva di Palermo è tra le associazioni promotrici di @il__giudizio: "Abbiamo scelto di fare causa perché la compromissione dei mari è stata causata dall'inazione dello Stato". Firma l'appello su giudiziouniversale.eu#FacciamoCausa
Siamo i primi promotori - tra le più di 200 associazioni e cittadini - della causa allo Stato italiano per inazione climatica, con la campagna @il__giudizio. Sostieni la causa, basta una firma! giudiziouniversale.eu
The specific requests put to the judge by the claimants are:
to declare that the Italian state is responsible for failing to act on the climate emergency;
to order the state to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 92 per cent by 2030 relative to 1990 levels.
In particular, explains A Sud spokesperson Marica Di Pierri, the figure of 92 per cent — far more ambitious than the 65 per cent envisaged by the framework climate law currently being prepared in Parliament — "was obtained by applying the principle of equity and the principle of common but differentiated responsibility: we relied on Climate Analytics (a German NGO with offices worldwide that has specialised since 2008 in the study of the impacts of climate change, ed.). We commissioned them to carry out a calculation based on Italy's annual greenhouse gas emissions — a country that has yet to adopt a carbon budget — and also taking into account its current technological and financial capacities. Various parameters were used, so that the result would be absolutely equitable and unassailable."
L’#italia dal #suolo fragile. Serve spendere di più e spendere meglio per prepararci a contrastare gli effetti, già drammaticamente visibili, del #ClimateChange
In the filing, the campaign's promoters explain, "the unlawful conduct of the state is contested, as it has failed to pursue a climate policy in line with the most advanced scientific findings." The legal case, they continue, "is by no means symbolic in nature, but aims to achieve a radical change in the state's climate policies, through a decisive increase in reduction ambitions and the guarantee of full protection of human rights, in compliance with the climate obligations the state is required to observe under the Constitution, international agreements and national legislation."
According to the World Atlas of Desertification, the areas at high risk of desertification in the event of temperatures rising above 2 degrees by the end of the century cover at least 20 per cent of Italian territory: rainfall could fall by 30 per cent by the end of the century compared with 1971–2000, according to the worst-case scenario outlined by the Ipcc, and entire coastal areas are at risk of disappearing due to rising sea levels. Not only Venice and the northern Adriatic, but also vast areas of Abruzzo, Puglia (on the Adriatic) and Tuscany, Lazio, Campania, Sardinia and Sicily (on the Tyrrhenian) are at risk of coastal erosion or flooding. On the Giudizio universale website, one can sign up to the campaign and leave a message: among the many left by ordinary citizens, one that stands out is from Luca Mercalli, president of the Società meteorologica italiana: "I am tired of green policies that exist only in words and not in deeds."
The Italian government faces trial for climate inaction for the first time
Rights — di Simone Santi
On 14 December, the first hearing takes place in the case brought by citizens and organisations against the government. The charge is climate inaction in relation to the Paris Agreement.