One snowfall does not make a glacier. How are Italy's Alpine glaciers faring
Environment — di Camilla Soldati
Italy's Alpine glaciers have recorded abundant snow accumulation. But how does this season fit into a broader climatic picture?

Italy's Alpine glaciers have recorded abundant snow accumulation. But how does this season fit into a broader climatic picture?
"After the great drought, record glaciers. The most abundant in twenty years." That is how some Italian newspapers headlined their stories in early July, after measurements by Arpa (the Regional Agency for Environmental Protection) of Valle d'Aosta, Piedmont and Lombardy recorded abundant snow accumulation on glaciers across the Italian Alpine arc during the spring 2024 season. But, contrary to those headlines, we cannot say that the glaciers are now doing well.
The past few months — late winter and early spring in particular — were rich in precipitation that continued well into May, allowing the snowpack to persist even at the start of summer. What we are talking about, then, is an abundance of snow, not of ice.
For example, data collected by Arpa Valle d'Aosta together with the Diati department of the Polytechnic of Turin show that snow accumulation (measured as water equivalent in the snowpack) on the Rutor glacier, in the Vallone di La Thuile, is the second highest in the past twenty years, just below the record set in 2013. Data collected by Arpa together with the Gran Paradiso National Park on the Timorion glacier likewise show that this year's snow accumulation exceeded the previous record set in 2013 by 30 per cent, and was three times greater than that recorded in winter 2022–2023.
The years 2022 and 2023 were indeed characterised by prolonged dry spells in the Alps and by temperatures well above average, with the freezing level reaching altitudes never previously recorded. These conditions contributed to worsening the drought that had already persisted from the winter months and to accelerating ice melt. This year's figures for snow accumulation are therefore positive, and give us some breathing room in terms of water resources too, since snow constitutes reserves capable of gradual release. But we must consider the broader picture in which they sit: we cannot judge the state and health of a glacier on the basis of a single season.
"We need to draw a distinction between the snapshot of today and an image that instead takes a longer time interval into account — a trend," begins Giovanni Baccolo, a researcher at Roma Tre University specialising in glaciers, environment and climate and a member of the Italian Glaciological Committee, with whom we discussed the issue. "The snapshot shows us that part of the Alpine glaciers is still covered in snow, now well into July. Last year, by contrast, the ice was already bare and beginning to melt as early as late May. So things are certainly better."

This year, the ice remained covered by snow and, receiving no direct sunlight, the point in the season at which it begins to melt was delayed. "In a sense, the accumulated snow sacrifices itself in place of the ice: it is the snow that should melt first, with the ice doing so only at the end of the season. So this year is certainly a positive one," Baccolo continues. "Yet if we place this snapshot in an album of photographs showing how glaciers have fared over the past few decades, we certainly cannot say that things are going well, or that this season's snow accumulation has in some way resolved the problem of glacier retreat, because a single season is not capable of influencing a glacier's behaviour — it takes many consecutive years to generate a response."
A glacier's behaviour indeed unfolds over a long period of time. To understand the role of snowfall — such as that captured in the snapshot we have just taken — in relation to a glacier, we need to take a step back and understand how the latter functions. "To be defined as such, a glacier must produce new ice every year," Giovanni Baccolo explains. "This means it must be able to retain at least a minimal quantity of the snow that accumulates on its surface during winter, which goes on to create new ice year after year. If we observe a glacier at the end of summer and see no snow but only dirty, blackened ice, it means the glacier can no longer produce new ice — it is therefore a fossil. The fundamental thing is therefore the presence of snow at the end of summer, which generates the production of new ice, and which in turn automatically sets a flow in motion: the new ice produced at altitude must be transported downslope, moving downward. If new ice is no longer produced, the flow slows until it becomes stationary. At that point it can no longer even be defined as a glacier, because a patch of ice with no dynamics is defined as a glacieret."

Just how important the global context is — and not only the local one — is made clear by the latest record we recorded in June 2024: it was the hottest June ever, the thirteenth consecutive month of temperature records, and the twelfth in a row with a temperature increase of more than 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. Italy's glaciers sit squarely within this context. Indeed, as Baccolo reminds us: "The Alps are not only following the trend of rising temperatures — they are also surpassing it. They are warming faster than the planetary average, with a temperature increase of 2 degrees above the pre-industrial period, while the global average is 1.5. The lower glaciers, moreover, have not yet had time to come into equilibrium with the climate. This is why I call them climate fossils: they move only by inertia, but from a climatic and glaciological standpoint they should have disappeared, because they no longer know how to make new ice."
It is no coincidence that the Alps, like Europe as a whole, are considered hotspots for climate change — that is, areas particularly sensitive to its effects. And the past two years have been a demonstration of this. "They were the worst ever since we began our measurements," Baccolo continues. "The mass loss of the glaciers was enormous, the most negative balance ever recorded, to the point that scientists had to update the axes of their graphs to fit these two years in. In the Swiss Alps, between 2022 and 2023, 10 per cent of all the ice was lost, and this figure gives us an idea of what has happened across the other Alpine sectors too, including those of Italy's glaciers."

"If I try to think about the future, I think precisely of the summer of 2022, the summer of the Marmolada collapse, which was very violent from a climatic point of view for the Alps," Baccolo recalls. "The zero-degree isotherm above 4,000 metres, in some events above 5,000 metres: practically on those days all the ice present on the Alps was melting, as on the summit of Mont Blanc. In certain respects, that summer can anticipate the typical summers we can expect in the coming decades." Following this trend, indeed, all glaciers below 3,500 metres are destined to disappear by the end of the century.
What we do know, however, is that something can still be done. Indeed, one specific thing: reducing emissions. Models indicate that by the end of the century, depending on how much we manage to reduce emissions, several scenarios are possible. If we succeed in respecting the Paris Agreement, limiting the increase in average global temperature to within 1.5 degrees, between 30 and 40 per cent of the ice present in 2015 will survive by the end of the century. "The only solution is to reduce emissions," Baccolo confirms. "In this way we have seen that on the Alps we would save a significant portion of the ice. It may seem like little, but in reality there are other parts of the planet where the Paris Agreement would make it possible to save an even greater quantity of ice. We cannot expect glaciers to return to the conditions they were in a few decades ago, but we should absolutely try to limit the damage, and science tells us it is not yet too late to do so, even if the time available is growing ever shorter."

It is precisely for this reason that accurate information and communication about the state of glaciers and, above all, about the broader climatic picture is essential. A balance that is far from obvious, yet essential for ensuring that focus remains on the actions needed to counter the effects of climate change, without overstating the alarmism and without falling into oversimplification. "I believe that glaciers have played an important role in helping people to learn about these issues and especially to see for themselves the effects of climate change: the retreat and disappearance of glaciers is one of the most powerful images," concludes Baccolo. "But we also need to try to offer pointers on the possibilities available to us, whether adaptation or mitigation, the two ways we have of limiting the damage of climate change. We need to tell people what is happening but also to push for greater communication of what we can do to ensure the least possible harm both to natural systems and to our civilisations."
Glaciers all over the world, not just in the Alps, contain more than 60 per cent of all the fresh water on our planet. Entire communities, habitats, ecosystems and part of our future depend on them. Knowing them and understanding their state of health gives us greater awareness to preserve at least part of these immense masses of ice, which hold within them stories of a time that is difficult to imagine. It is no coincidence that we feel a sense of powerlessness when we find ourselves in their presence. A feeling we must continue to experience before their majesty.
Glaciers are a world different from that of everyday life. The rules and processes that occur here are unique; it is like stepping onto another planet temporarily, but within reach. They are a fragment of a different world that has remained trapped on Earth.
Giovanni Baccolo, glaciologist