Glaciers yesterday and today. How they have changed in Fabiano Ventura's photographs
Environment — di Martina Girola
We met photographer Fabiano Ventura to discuss the health of glaciers through his photographic comparisons.

We met photographer Fabiano Ventura to discuss the health of glaciers through his photographic comparisons.
"How the landscape is changing, what new elements are appearing or disappearing — you can see it for yourself." This is the wording on the signage accompanying the hike to the Fellaria glacier, in Valmalenco. Along the route, a series of markers makes it impossible to ignore the glacier's history. Due to the climate crisis, glaciers are disappearing ever more rapidly from our Alps too, and all it takes is ten minutes beside the Fellaria to hear the sound of ice breaking and chunks falling into the water. Almost two centuries ago, the retreat of the glacial tongue freed the valley floor from ice; then, over the two decades from 1990 to 2010, it retreated faster and faster. A new lake formed in the process, the base disappeared, new rocks became visible, and the glacier split into two parts. What can be seen today is but a shadow of what it once was — something one readily appreciates when visiting, and above all when looking at the photographs of photographer Fabiano Ventura.

Fabiano Ventura has dedicated the past 12 years to studying and photographing the glaciers of the Earth in order to understand and document their state of health. His work gave rise to Sulle tracce dei ghiacciai, a photographic-scientific project that produces visual comparisons of the condition of the world's glaciers, thanks to the contribution of specialist photographers and glaciologist scientists. Some of the sample locations analysed include the Karakoram, the Caucasus, Alaska, the Andes, the Himalayas and our own Alps.
Behind each comparison lies a lengthy process of analysis that combines the aesthetic requirements of photography with the study of locations and scientific outreach. "The research work before each expedition is the foundation of everything. Without the historical photographs we could not work. This is why we spend months searching through various public and private archives, foundations and museums, specifically to select those images that we then go on to repeat in the field at the same time of year, in the same geographical location, but also at the same time of day," Ventura explains — he is also a National Geographic Explorer. "During the expeditions we involve a number of researchers, above all glaciologists and climatologists, to extract quantitative data on the state of health of the glaciers."
The comparisons are made at the same time of year, in the same geographical location and at the same time of day.
Fabiano Ventura
Finally, a series of public events is organised to disseminate and communicate the findings gathered. This can take the form of travelling exhibitions, documentaries, conferences, video installations or full-scale museum exhibitions, such as the one that will have its world première at Forte di Bard in June 2022.

"Personally, I wanted to create this project in order to produce a photographic record that is unique and unequivocal on the subject of glacier retreat," he explains. "These photographic comparisons have a strong emotional impact and are also unequivocal — they show precisely how the great masses, the great glaciers of the world, are retreating."
Glaciers are considered true sentinels of the climate, terrestrial thermometers that must be preserved, studied and understood, he explains. "Unfortunately, in the Alps there has been a rise of two degrees compared to many other parts of the world — practically double that of all other mountain ranges. Much the same has happened in the Caucasus, and this has meant that over the past 40–50 years we have lost 60 per cent of our glaciers."
From his words, however, it is also clear that the worst is not yet over: "Even if we were able to stop CO2 levels in the atmosphere today and temperatures were to remain as they are for 50 years, glaciers would still continue to melt and collapse, precisely because there is currently no equilibrium — a stable equilibrium has not yet been reached given how much temperatures have risen. Glaciers have a strong inertia; they don't stabilise in three or four years."

Beyond the visual impact on the landscape, their disappearance would have enormous consequences from a public safety perspective too: the melting of permafrost within the mountains is increasing the risk of hydrogeological instability, which is why many slopes are giving way. Comparing Ventura's photographs, one notices how the glacial lakes visible today did not exist in the past. And the Fellaria is just one of many examples: "Large supraglacial lakes can be dangerous because they can collapse at any moment and cause major flooding of the valleys within minutes," he explains. "We are talking about tonnes of ice and rock that could give way."
Furthermore, their disappearance would also affect the supply of drinking water for valley communities and the seasonality of European rivers such as the Rhône, the Danube, the Rhine and the Po, progressively lowering their levels. This is an aspect that would have major repercussions for the economies of individual countries, given the large volume of goods transported along these rivers.
Last but not least, a question of borders could also enter the debate, as happened recently at the Plateau Rosa at the Guide del Cervino mountain hut which, due to the melting of the glacier on which it stands, shifted from Italy into Switzerland, with all the risks — including fiscal and bureaucratic ones — that this entails.

"We are developing in an unsustainable way and this falls back on us. Perhaps we are the only species that is sawing off the branch it lives on," he reflects. "Sea levels will rise ever higher due to the increase in temperature: a heated body occupies a greater mass than a cooler one; it is a matter of physical chemistry. This is also why sea levels are rising: their temperature is increasing, which has dramatic consequences for marine biodiversity."
It is often said that we must save the planet. The planet saves itself, nature regenerates on its own — it has no need of us. It is we human beings who need nature, because we ourselves are nature.
Fabiano Ventura
"That is why ours is an interdisciplinary approach that seeks to build awareness among the widest possible audience: art supports science and science supports art — that is our working method," he concludes.
Ventura's photographs are proof of what once was and what has now been lost. But perhaps, one day, thanks to these very photographs, someone will be able to carry out a third comparison to show that our species understood what was happening. And acted.