How to read an ice cream label

How to read an ice cream label

Food · ·

An ice cream label contains a great deal of information. Here is how to read the label on artisan ice cream and on industrial ice cream.

The label on artisan ice cream

The cone and the tub we get at the ice cream parlour — a simple summer pleasure. It is artisan ice cream, fruit or cream flavoured, that accompanies our summer strolls. To make it, every ice cream maker must comply with a rigorous and wholesome "Disciplinare sul gelato artigianale" (artisan ice cream specification), which guarantees the use of fresh ice cream ingredients and sound production techniques.

"Il Gelato artigianale è una preparazione alimentare portata allo stato solido e pastoso mediante mescolamento e congelamento della miscela degli ingredienti" (artisan ice cream is a food preparation brought to a solid and creamy state by mixing and freezing the blend of ingredients), states the Disciplinare. During freezing, as the mixture is stirred, air is naturally incorporated, giving the ice cream its softness and creaminess. To be entitled to call itself "artisan", it must be characterised by the predominant use of fresh raw materials: the other ingredients may then be chosen directly by the artisan according to their own creativity. Artisan ice cream must be sold within a few days of production.

Il gelato artigianale è sottoposto a diverse regole. © Ingimage
Artisan ice cream is subject to various rules. Typical ingredients are: milk, cream; eggs; fruit. ©Ingimage

Sugars: sugar, fructose, honey, maple syrup, maltodextrins.

Semi-finished products: "Nella preparazione dei gelati al latte è possibile l'impiego di semilavorati (cioè quei preparati destinati esclusivamente alla produzione del gelato, ma non al consumo diretto), purché nella misura massima del 10% in peso sulla ricetta" (in the preparation of milk-based ice creams, the use of semi-finished products — that is, preparations intended exclusively for ice cream production and not for direct consumption — is permitted, provided they do not exceed 10% by weight of the recipe), states the Disciplinare.

Additives (from the Disciplinare): "Viene ammesso l'utilizzo degli additivi legalmente consentiti dalle disposizioni in vigore con esclusione dei coloranti e degli aromatizzanti artificiali. Nemmeno nei semilavorati possono essere presenti coloranti ed aromatizzanti artificiali ed edulcoranti di sintesi o altrimenti detti artificiali" (the use of additives legally permitted under current regulations is allowed, with the exclusion of artificial colourings and flavourings. Artificial colourings, artificial flavourings and synthetic — or so-called artificial — sweeteners must not be present in semi-finished products either).

Others: the artisan may use other finished products such as biscuits and/or biscuit pieces, candied fruit, cocoa, and salt, according to the creativity of the artisan ice cream maker.

The label on industrial ice cream

Il gelato industriale non è fresco
Unlike artisan ice cream, industrial ice cream is not a fresh product. © Ingimage

Here is a typical label from one of the tubs found in the freezer counters at the supermarket:

"Ingredients: rehydrated skimmed milk – sugar – glucose syrup – vegetable oils – partially delactosed skimmed whey – emulsifier: mono- and diglycerides of fatty acids – colourings – stabilisers: sodium alginate, locust bean flour – flavourings – gelling agent: pectin."

In short, it would appear to be nothing more than powdered milk, fats, sugars and flavourings. Let us look at a few ingredients in detail.

Rehydrated skimmed milk, milk proteins, whey, etc.: these are skimmed milk powder and residual by-products of processing. The quality is not guaranteed.

Vegetable oils: there is no obligation to declare on the label which oils are used. Some doubt about quality may arise.

Hydrogenated vegetable fats (mono- and diglycerides, etc.): used as binding and emulsifying agents, vegetable fats are among the most massively present ingredients in the products found at the supermarket (snacks, industrial confectionery, stock cubes, ready-made fried foods). In ice creams they are used as "stabilisers and emulsifiers". Beyond the possible intolerances, hydrogenated or trans-esterified vegetable fats pose risks to our health: their production process modifies the characteristics of fats in such a way as to make it impossible for our bodies to form the long-chain fatty acids that are essential for the formation of neurons and nervous tissue, and to cause serious interference in the systems that regulate cholesterol levels.

Flavourings: if the label simply reads "flavourings", they are invariably artificial. They are ubiquitous in tub ice cream.

There is another ingredient that is not listed on the label, and there is often a great deal of it: air. Pumped compressed air is a practice prohibited for artisan ice cream but is standard in mass-produced ice cream, used to inflate it, make it softer and seemingly more voluminous — at the expense, however, of substance.