Industrial, artisan or organic ice cream? Ice cream can have its rightful place in your diet, as long as it is healthy and natural, free from fats and colourings
Publicato per la prima volta: 7 Gennaio, 2010
Ice cream in your diet
From the point of view of ingredients, ice cream can be divided into three different categories: cream-based, vegetable fat-based and fruit-based. Cream-based ice creams are four times fattier than fruit-based ones, which are preferable for anyone who wants to stay in shape during the summer. That said, cream-based ice creams contain a good thirty per cent more protein. The energy and nutritional contribution of a milk ice cream can comfortably replace a snack, as it does not weigh the body down and helps provide energy to effectively resume study or work activities.
Vegetable fat-based ice creams, in which fat is used in place of milk, have a different profile of fat-soluble vitamins.
Fruit pulp, sugar and water go into fruit ice creams, which — especially when fresh fruit is used — provide a good dose of vitamin C. The protein content depends on the amount of milk used, on whether eggs are present, and on whether a biscuit or wafer cone is included.
All types of ice cream introduce proteins, sugars and fats into the body, along with a good dose of phosphorus and calcium. Ice cream performs a useful function at a digestive level because it stimulates stomach emptying (reducing the working time of gastric juices) and promotes bile secretion, to the overall benefit of fat digestion. The important thing is to eat ice cream either immediately after a meal or well away from one, as its low temperature may not be conducive to the digestive process.
Industrial or artisan ice cream? Organic or conventional? Cream or fruit? The key is to look for a healthy, natural product, free from unwanted fats and colourings.
To produce it, every ice cream maker must comply with a "Disciplinare sul gelato artigianale" that guarantees the use of fresh ingredients and sound production techniques. "Artisan ice cream is a food preparation brought to a solid and creamy state by mixing and freezing the blend of ingredients," the Disciplinare states.
During freezing, as the mixture is stirred, air is incorporated, giving the ice cream its softness and creaminess. To be entitled to bear the label "artisan", it must be characterised by the predominant use of fresh raw materials: the other ingredients may then be chosen directly by the maker according to their own creativity. Artisan ice cream must be sold within a few days of production.
Characterising ingredients (which may be fresh, frozen, or already in purée or paste form): milk, cream; eggs; fruit. Semi-finished products: "In the preparation of milk-based ice creams, the use of semi-finished products (i.e. preparations intended exclusively for ice cream production, not for direct consumption) is permitted, provided they do not exceed 10% by weight of the recipe," the Disciplinare states.
Additives: (from the Disciplinare): "The use of additives legally permitted under current regulations is allowed, with the exclusion of artificial colourings and flavourings. Artificial colourings, artificial flavourings and synthetic or so-called artificial sweeteners must not be present in semi-finished products either."
The first difference from artisan ice cream concerns freshness: this product is in fact prepared many months before consumption. Its ingredients typically include powdered milk, sugar, vegetable oils, hydrogenated vegetable fats, colourings, emulsifiers, stabilisers and flavourings.
Industrial ice creams are produced with a massive introduction of air (min. 70%) during the freezing phase, which makes them particularly soft.
Used as binding agents and emulsifiers, hydrogenated or partially hydrogenated vegetable fats are among the most common ingredients in products found at the supermarket (snacks, industrial pastries, stock cubes, ready-made fried foods). In ice creams they are used as stabilisers and emulsifiers.
Flavourings: if the label simply reads "flavourings", they are without doubt artificial. They are ubiquitous in tub ice creams.
Hydrogenated (or partially hydrogenated) vegetable fats: these are industrial compounds widely used in ice creams. They have the particular property of going rancid slowly, thus extending the product's commercial shelf life. They also cost less than natural fats such as butter and have a higher melting point. Hydrogenated fats have negative health implications. They contain the feared "trans" fats, which are considered responsible for raising "bad" cholesterol levels and increasing blood viscosity, thereby worsening the risk of cardiovascular problems. For this reason it is important to read labels carefully, bearing in mind that in organic ice creams their use is prohibited by law.
Colourings: the presence of colourings is indicated on the label. European regulations require them to appear under the code E followed by a number between 100 and 200. Ice cream can be excellent without containing them — colourings have no flavour or nutritional value, but serve only to make our ice cream more visually appealing. Let's choose ice cream makers who do not use them (or who at least use natural colourings): we will discover the true colour of our favourite flavour, and gain in naturalness.
Made with ingredients from organic farming, organic ice cream is not only tasty and healthy but also a clear example of how the quality of raw materials can influence the final product. The milk used is in most cases fresh whole milk, the sugar is unrefined cane sugar, and fresh cream, eggs, fruit, honey, and yogurt are used — all produced without the use of pesticides. Additives and flavourings are never artificial, colourings are prohibited, as are GMOs, with everything guaranteed through organic certification bodies.
Beyond these already well-established practices, a growing trend is emerging that favours the production of ice cream with 'free-from' options, where the absence of added sugars, lactose, colourings and artificial flavourings meets the growing demand from health-conscious consumers. These options not only continue to promote a sustainable approach to food production, but also respond to the desire to indulge responsibly, with products that respect both human health and the environment. Innovations include the offering of vegan and plant-based variants, which use milk alternatives such as almond, soy or oat, reinforcing the commitment to a more inclusive ice cream production that is attentive to diverse dietary needs.
Ice cream consumption in Italy and European regulations
In Italy, per capita ice cream consumption stands at around 8 litres per year, demonstrating a consistent preference for this dessert. This figure helps us better understand the importance of ice cream in the Italian diet and underlines the need for high-quality products.
In parallel, European regulations play a crucial role in guaranteeing this quality. For example, German laws require that ice cream produced with milk must contain at least 70% real milk, and cream ice creams must have at least 10% milk fats and 270 grams of eggs per litre. These standards ensure that the end consumer receives a product that is not only delicious but also nutritionally sound.
Ice cream FAQs
What are the main ingredients of artisan ice cream? The main ingredients of artisan ice cream include milk, cream, sugar and, depending on the flavour, eggs and natural flavourings such as fruit, chocolate, vanilla and hazelnuts may be added.
How is artisan ice cream made? The production of artisan ice cream begins with the selection of high-quality ingredients. These are mixed and pasteurised at around 85°C. After rapid cooling of the mixture, churning follows — a process that incorporates air and ensures a soft, creamy consistency.
How many times a week is it advisable to eat ice cream? Ice cream can be consumed 2–3 times a week, preferably artisan and fruit-based.
What is Italians' favourite ice cream flavour? In Italy, the most popular ice cream flavours include custard cream, chocolate and hazelnut, which are considered classics beloved by generations.
Which European country consumes the most ice cream? The European country that consumes the most ice cream is Finland, with an estimated per capita consumption of 14.2 litres per year. Despite Finland being known for its cold climate, ice cream consumption takes place mainly during the short summer periods.
Ice cream: everything you need to know about diet and types of ice cream
Food — di Redazione
Industrial, artisan or organic ice cream? Ice cream can have its rightful place in your diet, as long as it is healthy and natural, free from fats and colourings