Climate finance: why we need it and what its main instruments are

Climate finance: why we need it and what its main instruments are

Environment · ·

Tackling the effects of climate change requires enormous financial resources: that is why climate finance plays a fundamental role.

Decarbonising the global economy, making territories resilient in the face of climate disruption, protecting (and compensating) the most vulnerable: these are all absolute priorities, on which our future on the only planet we have depends. For them not to remain merely on paper, enormous financial resources are needed. That is why climate finance has – and will have – a fundamental role.

What climate finance is

When we talk about climate finance (or finanza per il clima, as it is known in Italian), we are referring in general to the resources and financial instruments that are invested in the fight against climate change. The latter is structured around three pillars. On one side there is mitigation — that is, the reduction of climate-altering greenhouse gas emissions — which essentially requires a radical transformation of the global economic system. On the other side there is adaptation, the set of measures aimed — precisely — at adapting territories to climate change in order to limit damage to people and property. Finally, there is loss and damage, meaning compensation for the losses and damages suffered by countries that are most vulnerable yet, at the same time, least responsible for global warming. These three directions are very different from one another, but they have one thing in common: they require immense financial resources.

How many resources are needed and how many have been allocated

How immense? Making a precise calculation is extremely complex, but some studies have arrived at credible estimates. The Climate policy initiative, for example, argues that in the two-year period 2021–2022 average annual financial flows reached $1.3 trillion, a figure that almost doubled compared to 2019–2020 levels. The lion's share belongs to mitigation finance, which stands at $1.15 trillion per year — $439 billion more than in 2019–2020. By contrast, adaptation stops at $63 billion; a further $51 billion is attributable to both objectives.

It is again the Climate policy initiative that underlines how these figures, albeit on the rise, remain largely insufficient. In the median scenario, the annual need for climate finance will increase from $8.1 trillion to $9 trillion by 2030. At that point, it will break through the $10 trillion ceiling through to 2050. Annual financial flows will consequently need to increase at least fivefold.

The investment is therefore considerable, yet nonetheless worthwhile. Under the — rather optimistic — assumption that the increase in average global temperature remains within 1.5 degrees above pre-industrial levels, between 2025 and 2050 a total of $266 trillion will be needed for climate finance. A gigantic volume of money, but still far less than the $1,062 trillion in economic losses that will in any case be recorded as a result of climate change (a trillion being one thousand billion). If, on the other hand, business as usual continues, cumulative damages will total $2,328 trillion, again between 2025 and 2050.

finanza climatica
Volumes of climate finance disbursed in 2021–2022 © Climate policy initiative

Multilateral funds for climate finance

The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (Unfccc) has established a number of multilateral funds over the years, aimed at providing the necessary resources to developing countries. Let us look at some of them.

Green climate fund

One of the first and most important instruments of climate finance is the Green climate fund (Green climate fund), established in 2010. It remains to this day the world's largest multilateral climate fund, despite having fallen short of its stated objectives. During Cop15 in Copenhagen, industrialised countries had committed to jointly mobilising $100 billion per year until 2020 in support of developing economies. This deadline was subsequently extended to 2025. According to the latest data from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (Oecd), in 2021 the total reached $89.6 billion.

Cop29 in Baku, Azerbaijan, will be the place to define the new collective quantified goal for climate finance (new collective quantified goal), valid from 2025 onwards.

Loss and damage fund

After a debate that had dragged on for three decades, in the final hours of Cop27 in Sharm el-Sheikh the parties agreed on the creation of a loss and damage fund, subsequently formalised on the first day of the following Cop28 in Dubai. This involves a transfer of financial resources from industrialised countries (responsible for the vast majority of greenhouse gas emissions) to developing countries, which are particularly vulnerable to the impact of the climate crisis despite having contributed only minimally to causing it.

For the first four years it is the World Bank that manages the operation of the fund — a choice resented by developing countries, which fear that industrialised nations will hold the reins, perhaps imposing very tough conditions for access to resources. To ensure equitably representative governance, the board is composed of 26 members, of whom 12 are designated by advanced economies.

Contributions to the fund are voluntary: by the close of Cop28, pledges stood at just below $700 million. Some studies argue that the actual need is of an entirely different order of magnitude: figures of $400 billion (not million) per year are cited.

loss and damage
A protest inside Cop27 © Tommaso Perrone/LifeGate

Adaptation fund

As its name suggests, the Adaptation Fund (Adaptation fund) finances adaptation projects in developing countries that have ratified the Kyoto Protocol and are particularly vulnerable to the negative effects of climate change. It is financed partly by governments (including the Italian government), partly by private donors and partly by the proceeds from CO2 emissions reduction certificates. Since 2010, the fund has allocated more than one billion dollars to projects that have benefited 43 million people around the world. During the first week of Cop28, donors pledged a further 191.2 million, a figure below the target of mobilising 300 million dollars in 2023. The value of projects still awaiting funding has in fact reached 425 million dollars.

Global environment facility

Launched in 1991, the Global environment facility (Gef) is a family of funds focused on climate change, biodiversity loss, pollution and pressures on the health of land and oceans. Over three decades it has allocated more than 23 billion dollars and mobilised 129 billion in co-financing for more than 5,000 national and regional projects, primarily to help developing countries address their environmental priorities and align with international environmental conventions.

To give a few more detailed examples, 27 per cent of the funds distributed between 2018 and 2022 went to forest projects, reaching a total of 3.7 billion over three decades; since its establishment, the fund has also allocated 1.2 billion for the conservation of marine resources, with a further 500 million in co-financing from other sources.

🌟 2023: A year of resilience, optimism, and groundbreaking strides in environmental action. Check out the timeline below to witness the journey of the GEF partnership in shaping a better future for our planet. 💚

wrld.bg/IOuM50QlbHG

The pledges made at Cop28 in Dubai

On 4 December, at Cop28 in Dubai, it was the day dedicated to climate finance. An opportunity to put on record the commitments made by various parties in the opening days of negotiations, totalling 57 billion dollars, broken down as follows:

Cop28 di Dubai
A journalist films the speech by Cop28 President Sultan al-Jaber © KARIM SAHIB/AFP via Getty Images

Other innovative forms of financing

Multilateral funds are important instruments for climate finance, but they are not the only ones. Over time, various innovative forms of financing have been proposed or tested.

Breaking out of the debt trap

One of the main obstacles facing developing countries is the so-called debt trap. Since 2000, global public debt (domestic and foreign) has quadrupled, reaching 92 trillion dollars. For developing countries in particular, between 2010 and 2021 total public debt rose from 35 to 60 per cent of GDP. External debt — that is, what governments owe to foreign creditors — rose from 19 to 29 per cent of GDP over the same period.

What does all this mean? That their economies are crushed by the weight of debt and, in order to finance themselves, they must pay interest rates far higher than those required of advanced economies. As a result, they struggle to make the investments needed to decarbonise their economies and become more resilient in the face of the climate crisis. A trap, indeed.

There have long been movements calling loudly for debt cancellation. A radical option that would unlock crucial resources for the transition. For now, mechanisms such as debt for climate swaps have been tested: the creditor "forgoes" part of the debt owed to it by a foreign state, on the condition that the equivalent sum (usually converted into a bond) is used for climate-related projects. Applied to biodiversity protection, this mechanism is known as a debt for nature swap.

Another mechanism, to which various governments and international financial institutions committed at Cop28 in Dubai, is that of climate-resilient debt clauses: in essence, when a country is struck by a climate disaster, the creditor temporarily suspends debt servicing to give it some breathing room.

#COP28 has just come to a close, but what were the outcomes for debt justice?

Check out our new blog outlining all the debt-related outcomes and why #COP28 has left a legacy of deepening #DebtCrisis

There is no #ClimateJustice without #DebtJustice

👇
debtjustice.org.uk/blog/cop28-out…

Carbon tax

Another possibility lies in imposing a tax on energy resources that emit CO2, the so-called carbon tax. The director of the International Monetary Fund herself, Kristalina Georgieva, has stated that a carbon tax, combined with the removal of subsidies for fossil fuels, would be enough to find the funds needed to respond to the climate crisis.

Green bond

Among the most widely recognised instruments of sustainable finance are green bonds, securities whose proceeds must be invested in environmentally oriented projects, such as energy efficiency or renewable energy production. First tested in 2006, green bonds have experienced