What is life imprisonment without parole, what did the Constitutional Court ask for, and what did the government decide

What is life imprisonment without parole, what did the Constitutional Court ask for, and what did the government decide

Rights · ·

The institution of life imprisonment without parole was the subject of a decree by the Meloni government, converted into law on 30 December with some amendments.

On Monday 31 October, at the first Council of Ministers meeting of the government led by Giorgia Meloni, a legislative decree was approved. The text covers numerous subjects, including the question of life imprisonment without parole, which had been debated on several occasions in recent months, and which came to completion in the law converting the decree, approved on 30 December last.

What is life imprisonment without parole

Life imprisonment without parole represents a specific type of custodial sentence which, as well as being perpetual, unlike "ordinary" life imprisonment prevents the convicted person from accessing alternative measures or other benefits. In other words, whereas an ordinary life sentence can, for example on grounds of good behaviour or other merits of the prisoner, be converted into a sentence with a fixed term, life imprisonment without parole allows for such possibilities only if the person in question decides to cooperate with the justice system — that is, to become what is known as a "pentito" (informant).

For this reason, life imprisonment without parole, which has existed in our legal system since the early 1990s, represents an "extreme" punishment, imposed only in cases of particularly serious offences. This is the case, for example, for those convicted of Mafia association. Although considerably harsher than ordinary life imprisonment, there are nonetheless many life prisoners on whom the bar on accessing ordinary benefits has been imposed: approximately 70 per cent of those sentenced to life imprisonment, according to figures provided by the National Ombudsman for the Rights of Persons Deprived of Personal Liberty, Mauro Palma.

Il garante delle persone private della libertà critica la riforma: "Il testo licenziato dalla Camera sull'ergastolo ostativo è in tensione con le indicazioni date dalla Corte costituzionale e introduce disposizioni decisamente peggiorative rispetto alla disciplina" #ANSA

What criticisms have been levelled at life imprisonment without parole

The rule was introduced shortly before the period of Mafia massacres in which judges Giovanni Falcone and Paolo Borsellino lost their lives. The state's intention was to send a clear signal of "certainty of punishment" to criminals, in the hope that this might serve as a deterrent. And any possible repeal of the rule would risk allowing certain criminals — including bosses of the Mafia, the Camorra and the 'Ndrangheta — to leave prison. Even those who have never cooperated with the authorities and who could therefore, at least in theory, resume control of their criminal organisations.

Those who have criticised life imprisonment without parole have nonetheless pointed out that it appears to conflict with the principle, enshrined in our legal system, according to which the function of imprisonment must not be solely punitive but also rehabilitative. This means that in prison it should be possible, at least in theory, to reform oneself and be supported along a path whose goal is to return as free individuals to society.

Why the Constitutional Court deemed it unconstitutional

It is precisely for this purpose that the Constitutional Court was consulted. This was done by an ordinary judge, in the course of a trial during which the defence of a defendant raised a question of constitutionality regarding the rule. In practice, the judge in question considered that the constitutional legitimacy of the law concerned was decisive for the purposes of the judgement, and therefore suspended the proceedings pending a ruling from the Court.

That ruling arrived in April 2021, and concerned in particular Law 203 of 1991 in the part that, precisely, «excludes that a person sentenced to life imprisonment, for offences committed by exploiting the conditions referred to in art. 416-bis of the criminal code or in order to facilitate the activities of the associations provided for therein, who has not cooperated with the justice system, may be admitted to conditional release».

Il carcere di Santa Maria Capua Vetere
Santa Maria Capua Vetere prison © Ivan Romano/Getty Images

In particular, according to the Court, the rule conflicts with Articles 3 and 27 of the Constitution. The first states that "all citizens have equal social dignity and are equal before the law"; the second provides that "punishments may not consist of treatments contrary to the sense of humanity and must aim at the rehabilitation of the convicted person".

Furthermore, in the proceedings that gave rise to the Court's ruling, it was argued that cooperation with the justice system cannot "be elevated to the sole indicator of the absence of any connection with the criminal environment to which the person belongs and that, consequently, other elements may in practice constitute valid and unequivocal indicators of the absence of such connections and therefore of social dangerousness". Moreover, cases may arise of prisoners who are sincerely repentant but who do not wish to become official cooperating witnesses, for example out of fear of reprisals against family members.

What the Constitutional Court asked of parliament

For this reason, the Constitutional Court had decided to grant parliament one year to pass a new law in line with the requirements of the Constitution. The previous legislature, however, was unable to act in this direction: a reform bill was approved in the lower house last February, but it proved impossible to obtain the green light from the Senate as well.

Vista dal carcere
The authors of the experiment formed two partnerships with National Geographic and Nasa to bring into prisons not only nature videos but also images from space telescopes © Ingimage

The issue therefore immediately resurfaced on the new government's agenda, also because a new hearing of the Constitutional Court, which was to assess the reform itself, was scheduled for 8 November. At that point, the Court will examine the new decree, which, however — despite being an act with the force of law — must be converted into law within sixty days of its enactment. Otherwise it will lapse.

Parliament therefore has two months at its disposal. But the ruling of the constitutional judges will be crucial; they could declare the new legislative decree (whose contents mirror the text approved by the lower house in February) unconstitutional as well. This, at least, is the view of the Union of Criminal Chambers, which, in a lengthy document published shortly after the approval of the decree itself, spoke of "evident and serious profiles of unconstitutionality".

What is the Meloni government's position on life imprisonment without parole

There has also been debate over the Meloni government's use of the legislative decree instrument. This instrument, in fact, may be used only in cases of "necessity and urgency": this is because, in practice, it entails the executive power assuming, on the specific matter, the role that normally belongs to the legislative power, namely parliament.

Meloni: "Abbiamo approvato un primo decreto molto importante per provvedimenti. Avevo detto che la lotta alla criminalità organizzata era uno degli obiettivi del governo, e sono contenta che il decreto contenga una norma che va in questo senso, sull'ergastolo ostativo" #ANSA

The Union of Criminal Chambers has in this respect criticised the choice, declaring that recourse to a decree-law is unlawful, since there would be an "absolute lack of any plausible reason of urgency". In this regard, given the sensitivity of the matter, it would have been preferable to allow parliament to follow an ordinary legislative process.

In any case, the Meloni government's position is clear: life imprisonment without parole is necessary to guarantee certainty of punishment and to fight organised crime effectively. It remains to be seen whether the text approved by the Council of Ministers, as well as the conversion law, will satisfy the requirements set by the Constitutional Court in order to comply with the constitutional dictate.

The final version: it will be up to the judge to decide

Parliament, however, partially amended the content of the Council of Ministers' decree. Article 1 of the conversion law of the so-called rave decree, approved definitively on 30 December last, in practice resolves the matter by granting broad discretionary powers to the judge, who is called upon to establish whether the convicted person can or cannot benefit from the provisions available even in the event that they decide not to cooperate, on the basis of specific investigations. In particular, according to the final version of the law, the judge

acquires, including for the purpose of verifying the validity of the elements provided by the applicant, detailed information regarding the continued operational status of the criminal association to which they belonged or of the criminal context in which the offence was committed, the criminal profile of the detainee or internee and their position within the association, any new charges or precautionary or preventive measures subsequently imposed against them and, where significant, disciplinary infractions committed during detention.

Deontologic La settimana di Altalex: rinvio della riforma Cartabia ed ergastolo ostativo - Altalex dlvr.it/ScCP0K

In practice, therefore, the judge will have to establish whether the convicted person can or cannot access the sentence reductions provided for those convicted of "ordinary" offences, also on the basis of information obtained regarding the possibility that they may still be, or may no longer be, in contact with their criminal background. The other major innovation introduced is that offences against the public administration have been removed from the list of offences for which the benefits are not triggered.