Anarchist Alfredo Cospito transferred to hospital ahead of ruling on 41bis

Anarchist Alfredo Cospito transferred to hospital ahead of ruling on 41bis

Rights · ·

Anarchist Alfredo Cospito, after nearly 4 months on hunger strike, has been transferred to hospital. On 24 February the Court of Cassation will rule on the 41bis regime.

Last updated 13 February 2023

"Free Alfredo Cospito from 41bis", and then the A inscribed in a circle, the anarchists' symbol: at first it was just a handful of scattered words on city walls; today it is a slogan, a political demand voiced ever more loudly, with an ever more serious tone. And with increasingly violent demonstrations, such as the dozens of cars set on fire in Rome, Milan, Athens, Berlin, Barcelona, Madrid, and even La Paz, on the other side of the world.

L'anarchico Alfredo Cospito trasferito in ospedale in attesa della decisione sul 41bis
An anarchist poster for Alfredo Cospito © Laura Lezza/ GettyImages

The case of Alfredo Cospito, the anarchist currently held in the Opera prison in Milan under the special regime normally reserved for mafia members, has in just a few weeks become an affair that is worrying politicians and risks undermining social peace, evoking the darkest years of our Republic. But who is Alfredo Cospito, and why have he and his case become so important to the Italian anarchists who have been roused in his name?

The origins of the story

Born in Pescara and an adopted Torinese, 55 years old, Alfredo Cospito is an anarcho-insurrectionist militant, active since the mid-1990s and known to the justice system since 2012, when he was responsible for the kneecapping of Roberto Adinolfi, chief executive of Ansaldo Nucleare, together with his associate Nicola Gai.

During the trial of the two men (tracked down from the number plate of the scooter they were riding, which Adinolfi managed to read, and arrested as they were preparing to leave Italy), Cospito read a statement explaining that "it was just me and Nicola, no one else took part in our plan", carried out nonetheless on behalf of the Fai, the Federazione anarchica informale. "We do not recognise this democratic order. I am an anarchist and I am a nihilist because I act and do not wait for a revolution." A year later, he was sentenced to 10 years and 8 months in prison.

From the statement he made, and from the mistake of allowing himself to be identified ("we were naive, we were guilty of inexperience", was the admission), it is clear that Cospito was not, and has never been, the leader of a movement that, by its very definition, has never had a well-organised, hierarchical structure. If Cospito's figure has suddenly become so important today, it is for another reason. While he was already in prison for the attack on Adinolfi, Cospito was also sentenced to a further 20 years for the 2006 attack on the Carabinieri training school in Fossano, in the province of Cuneo, which fortunately caused no casualties.

What changed in 2022

Cospito's legal situation appeared at that point to be definitively settled, but in 2022 the matter suddenly reopened, with a twofold tightening of the sentence for the anarchist militant. The first came from the Ministry of Justice which, in the person of the then Minister of Justice Marta Cartabia, decided to place him under the 41bis regime, also to prevent Cospito from continuing to write regularly, as he had always done until then, for anarchist publications from prison.

The 41bis, also known as hard prison, is a regime introduced into Italian law in 1986 to prevent communications in prison between members of organised crime: in practice, to stop mafia bosses from continuing to give orders even from inside. It entails, among other things, solitary confinement in a cell, restricted time outside, the possibility of receiving only one visit per month, and no telephone calls during the first six months of detention. The 41bis regime has been challenged on numerous occasions over the years for its particular harshness and because it conflicts with Article 27 of the Constitution, which states that "punishments may not consist of treatment contrary to the sense of humanity and must aim at the rehabilitation of the convicted person".

Chiediamo che il regime di detenzione speciale, noto come 41-bis, applicato ad Alfredo Cospito abbia immediatamente fine e che egli abbia accesso senza indugio a tutte le cure mediche necessarie a garantire la sua sicurezza fisica e psicologica. amnesty.it/amnesty-intern…

Until the European Court of Human Rights, called upon to rule in two cases, did not find the regime, in principle, to be in conflict with international conventions, while criticising certain aspects of it: in the ruling concerning the detention of Bernardo Provenzano, it contested the denial of access to medical care for the mafia boss, who was suffering from cancer; in the ruling concerning Marcello Viola, another former mafia boss, it contested the denial of a rehabilitation pathway. As of October 2022, as many as 728 prisoners in Italy, including 12 women, were held under the 41bis regime. Among them, for example, is Matteo Messina Denaro, the fugitive mafia boss just captured after 30 years on the run and convicted of multiple murders.

The second intervention, in July 2022, came from the Court of Cassation, which at final instance modified the offence attributed to Cospito for the 2005 attack: from "massacre against public safety" to massacre against the security of the State. This led to a tightening of the sentence: from 20 years to ergastolo ostativo.

The ergastolo ostativo has also been the subject of much debate in recent times. Introduced in 1991, again to combat the mafias and strongly championed by anti-mafia judges Falcone and Borsellino, who were killed by the mafias the following year, it differs from an "ordinary" life sentence in that it prevents a person convicted of certain offences from accessing alternative measures or other benefits should they refuse to cooperate with the justice system.

Luigi Manconi scrive al papa per Cospito. È un appello lacerante: mostra la gravità della situazione e la viltà della classe politica italiana. Ma la battaglia per un cattolico o per un ateo è la stessa: per la dignità umana, la cancellazione del 41bis e dell'ergastolo ostativo.

The problem, however, is that in April 2021 the Constitutional Court ruled it unconstitutional, as it conflicts with Article 3 of the Constitution, which states that "all citizens have equal social dignity and are equal before the law", and of course the aforementioned Article 27. Just in recent weeks, Parliament, by amending a government decree, intervened on the ergastolo ostativo, providing that it will be up to the judge to determine whether the convicted person may or may not access the sentence reductions available to those convicted of "ordinary" offences, also on the basis of information obtained as to whether or not they may still be in contact with their criminal background.

The beginning of the protests

It was from the second half of 2022 that the Cospito case began to ignite. First came a few words daubed on walls in various cities, then threats, and before long there were demonstrative attacks. Which had already occurred sporadically from 2020 in Turin, Livorno, Genoa and the north-east of the country. But it is precisely what is happening to Cospito that, according to investigators, has raised the level of confrontation, contributing to a coming together of the various anarchist cells in Italy that are usually accustomed to acting autonomously. In this sense, it can be said that Cospito has for the first time truly become the leader, if not the "martyr", of the protest.

Scontri a Roma durante la protesta degli anarchici per il caso Cospito. Ferito un poliziotto, 41 persone denunciate. L'allarme dell'intelligence dopo gli attacchi alle sedi diplomatiche italiane a Berlino e Barcellona

The key date is 20 October 2022: on that day, as the "anarcopedia" page — a kind of diary of world anarchism in recent years — also records, Cospito began his hunger strike, which is still ongoing, more than 100 days later. On 8 December the anarchist group "Carlo Giuliani Revenge Nuclei" claimed responsibility for an arson attack on the cars of Susanna Schlein, an official at the Italian embassy in Athens and sister of Elly Schlein, who was then a candidate for the leadership of the Partito democratico. It was the beginning of the escalation, in the media as well.

"Attentato contro il Primo Consigliere dell'Ambasciata d'Italia in Grecia. Ho telefonato a Susanna Schlein per esprimerle la mia solidarietà. Oggi sarò ad Atene per incontrare il Primo Ministro kmitsotakis. Lo scrive su Twitter il ministro degli Esteri, Antonio Tajani. #ANSA

Similar attacks would take place over the following month and a half at the Italian consulate general in Barcelona and in Berlin. Cars were also set alight in Milan and Rome, with police stations in the crosshairs, as well as a Tim car park in the capital. Several militants were arrested by law enforcement over the past month, either caught in the act or as a result of investigations. On Saturday 4 February, two anarchist demonstrations were held in Rome and Milan, raising serious public order concerns, not least because a number of unauthorised marches had already ended in clashes: the Rome demonstration concluded with two people injured and three detained.

Cospito's state of health

As political tensions mounted, Alfredo Cospito's health was deteriorating: as a result of the hunger strike, he had come to weigh just 73 kilogrammes at a height of around 1.95 metres. Only on day 103 of the strike was Cospito finally transferred — on 30 January, on the express recommendation of doctors from the Asl of Sassari, the city where he had been held — to the Opera prison in Milan, identified as the most suitable place of detention for him to receive treatment and be kept under observation.

#AlfredoCospito trasferimento preventivo motivato dalle precarie condizioni di salute. Il governo, però, chiude alla revoca #41bis. In fiamme 2 veicoli dei vigili a Milano e 5 auto nella sede Telecom di Roma: la rivendicazione degli anarchici
tg.la7.it/cronaca/cospit…

In the preceding days, the Guarantor for the rights of persons deprived of their liberty had also publicly called for the transfer, noting that "the protection of the health of those in the custody of the State, as persons deprived of their personal liberty, is the responsibility of the administration that has charge of them" and stating that "a transfer of Alfredo Cospito can no longer be deferred".