- In Milan, the city council rejected the request to join proceedings as a civil party against Ultima Generazione for the actions targeting the Arco della Pace and the equestrian statue of Vittorio Emanuele II in Piazza Duomo.
- A few days earlier, the municipality had joined proceedings as a civil party in the case involving Maurizio Cattelan's Love artwork.
- The difference lies in the content of the "eco-vandals" law, passed by parliament yesterday: the municipality is in favour of compensation, but believes criminalising activists is wrong.
Nine months after the government launched the decree, the law that toughens sanctions against the so-called eco-vandals officially became law yesterday with 138 votes in favour and 92 against. Conceived by the government in response to the increasingly frequent protest actions by Ultima Generazione activists against institutional inaction on climate, it has however met with disapproval from the Municipality of Milan — the city that more than any other was the stage for Ultima Generazione's actions throughout 2023, with an average of one per month.
Eco-vandals, the clash in Milan that anticipated the law
Just three days earlier, on Monday 15 January, Milan's city council had rejected three motions tabled by a Lega councillor, Samuele Piscina, calling for the Municipality of Milan to join proceedings as a civil party over the damage caused by activists from the environmental movement Ultima Generazione to the Arco della Pace in Piazza Sempione during an action on 15 November last, and to the equestrian statue of Vittorio Emanuele II in Piazza Duomo on 9 March 2023.
The motions called on the city council to explicitly back the eco-vandals bill (as the centre-right calls it), which was then definitively passed by parliament yesterday: the request was rejected by the council majority. Samuele Piscina, the councillor whose motions were turned down, reacted in very harsh terms: "Once again the city council takes the side of criminals, backing and supporting the vandals of Ultima Generazione. As usual, the left does not defend honest citizens but those who break the rules by committing any act contrary to the law and civil coexistence."
SINISTRA DIFENDE GLI ECOVANDALI SE FINGI DI DIFENDERE L'AMBIENTE A MILANO PUOI DELINQUERE – #vandalism #graffiti #vandal #spraypaint #vandalismo #vandali #ecovandali #ecovandalism #delinquenti #criminali #giustizia
Posted by Samuele Piscina on Wednesday, January 17, 2024
And yet, just ten days earlier, the Municipality of Milan had joined proceedings as a civil party against Ultima Generazione over another action — the one targeting Maurizio Cattelan's Love statue — for which three young people have already been committed for trial on charges of criminal damage.
Yes to compensation, no to criminalisation
A contradiction? Not at all, as Filippo Barberis, the councillor who took the floor on 15 January to set out the centre-left's position, explained to us. In the case of the Cattelan statue, in fact, "Milan joined proceedings as a civil party because there was actual damage and we cannot avoid, even under the terms of the law, seeking compensation for material damages": the three young people behind the action are indeed charged with criminal damage, not defacement. And then, Barberis explains, in that case the municipality also wanted to "suggest" to the activists that yes, they should protest for a cause considered just, but within the proper bounds.
Different is the reasoning that led to the rejection of the Lega motions and to declining to join proceedings as a civil party over the Arco della Pace and Vittorio Emanuele II: "The reason here is above all political: we do not share the approach of those motions, which called for the imprisonment of activists for every such demonstration" precisely on the basis of the new law "and asked us to consider them criminals tout court." In short, compensation for damage is acceptable "when it is not negligible as in the two cases in question, where after all we are talking about washable paint," but moral damages and criminalisation are not.
The new law against eco-vandals, in fact, as well as establishing fines of up to €60,000 for those who deface monuments or works of art, also amends the offence of defacement and disfigurement of others' property, providing for a prison sentence of 1 to 5 years for anyone who destroys, disperses, deteriorates or renders, in whole or in part, unusable movable or immovable property during public demonstrations. And the fact that the Municipality of Milan is forgoing civil-party status in the cases of the Arco della Pace and Vittorio Emanuele will not in any case prevent the opening of further proceedings against Ultima Generazione.