Those who protest by defacing monuments will face fines of up to €60,000

Those who protest by defacing monuments will face fines of up to €60,000

Environment · ·

Fines of up to €60,000 for those who deface monuments to protest against climate inaction: the government's response to Ultima Generazione.

Updated 18 January 2024.
Nine months after the government launched the decree, the law tightening sanctions against so-called "eco-vandals" has today officially become law, with the approval at second reading by the Chamber of Deputies. The content of the law, following parliamentary scrutiny, remained substantially unchanged from what had been drafted by Culture Minister Gennaro Sangiuliano: whoever makes a mess, pays. In its final version, the law imposes a financial penalty of:

Approvato il Ddl eco-vandali.
Chi deturpa o imbratta un monumento paga di tasca propria, questo principio è legge dello Stato.
Ringrazio il Parlamento, il Governo e i tanti cittadini che mi hanno sostenuto in questa battaglia di civiltà.

The new law also amends the offence of defacement and dirtying of property belonging to others (Article 639 of the penal code), tripling the fine (from €103 to €309) and introducing imprisonment of between 1 and 6 months for those who deface or dirty display cases, housings and other structures used for the exhibition, protection and conservation of cultural assets on display in museums, art galleries, galleries and other public exhibition venues. Most significantly, anyone who destroys, disperses, damages or renders, wholly or partly, movable or immovable assets unusable during public demonstrations faces between 1 and 5 years in prison.

—————————————————————————————————————————————————————–

The Italian government is no longer prepared to tolerate climate activist stunts of the kind carried out in recent months by members of Ultima Generazione against the Barcaccia and the Senato in Rome, or against Palazzo Vecchio in Florence and La Scala in Milan, and, further back in time, against some of the country's major museums. A bill approved by the Council of Ministers (not a decree, therefore: the text will not enter into force immediately) stipulates that protesting against climate inaction by defacing monuments could cost from €10,000 to €60,000 in fines, to be imposed "on anyone who destroys, disperses, damages or renders wholly or partly unusable or inaccessible cultural or landscape assets, whether their own or another's." All of this, the bill states, is "without prejudice to applicable criminal penalties."

Grande scalpore per il blitz di Ultima generazione al Senato
Ultima Generazione's stunt at the Senate caused a huge stir © Twitter Ultima generazione

Nothing changes on the criminal side

In recent days there had been talk of a crackdown on the criminal side as well, targeting those who protest against climate inaction using — it should be remembered — washable paint throughout. Instead, the phrase "without prejudice to applicable criminal penalties" means that nothing changes regarding the risk of imprisonment for activists fighting against climate inaction. That risk, however, is already far from negligible, as demonstrated by the case of Ultima Generazione activist Simone Ficicchia. The offence of damaging buildings and monuments is currently already covered by two separate articles of the penal code, which therefore remain in force and will sit alongside the new administrative sanctions:

Article 635: "Anyone who destroys, disperses, damages or renders, wholly or partly, unusable movable or immovable property belonging to others through violence against a person or through threats shall be punished with imprisonment of between six months and three years," and likewise anyone who damages "public buildings or buildings intended for public use or for the practice of a religion, or immovable property within the perimeter of historic centres."

Article 733: "Anyone who destroys, damages or in any way harms a monument or other object of their own of whose significant value they are aware shall be punished, if the act causes harm to the national archaeological, historical or artistic heritage, with arrest of up to one year or a fine of no less than €2,065."

Cdm approva Ddl eco-vandali, Sangiuliano “Chi danneggia deve pagare” dlvr.it/SmKKdS

The measure was strongly championed by Culture Minister Gennaro Sangiuliano, who explained it as follows: "Attacks on monuments and artistic sites" carried out in protest against the government's climate inaction "cause economic damage to the community. Cleaning them up requires the intervention of highly specialised personnel and the use of very costly machinery. Those who commit these acts must also bear financial responsibility. According to data provided to me by the Soprintendenza speciale di Roma, restoring the facade of the Senate cost €40,000. Those who cause damage must pay personally. Depending on the seriousness of the case, the amount ranges from a minimum of €10,000 to a maximum of €60,000. These sums are in addition to any amounts that offenders may be ordered to pay in criminal or civil proceedings." In essence, the purpose of the bill is: whoever protests and makes a mess, pays.