Women, young people and families: who are the new poor of the pandemic
Rights — di Luca Cereda
45 per cent of people who turned to Caritas facilities since the start of the pandemic did so for the first time.

45 per cent of people who turned to Caritas facilities since the start of the pandemic did so for the first time.
The pandemic has caused forms of poverty to balloon in Italy: the new poor are above all families with children, women and young people. This is what emerges from the 2020 report on poverty and exclusion by Caritas Italiana, which captures a snapshot of the economic and social effects of the pandemic.
The emergency measures introduced by the government to counter rising poverty have helped, "but have not been sufficient", explains Dr Federica De Lauso, sociologist and editor of the report; and owing to a lack of clarity and the "cumbersome nature of administrative procedures", they have once again shifted the burden of supporting those on the margins onto private solidarity and the third sector.
In the period from May — that is, after the end of the lockdown — to September 2020, 45 per cent of people who turned to the aid facilities of the CEI body, such as soup kitchens, did so for the first time. In the same months of 2019, the percentage of "new poor" stood at just 31 per cent. In pre-pandemic Italy, out of a population of 60 million, there were already over 4 million people in absolute poverty: "the situation resulting from the onset of Covid-19 is therefore grafted onto an already fragile social fabric for a large part of the population", analyses Dr De Lauso.
The peak of requests reached Caritas in large cities but also in provinces during the spring period, "when we faced over 450,000 requests for help caused by new forms of poverty", De Lauso continues. But if we consider that behind a single cry for help there is often not just one person but an entire family unit, "the needs at least double. At the very least".

Women who sought help from Caritas services immediately after the lockdown accounted for 54.4 per cent, compared with 50.5 per cent in 2019. On the rise, therefore. "Among the new poor, women are growing in number, but so are families — above all Italian ones. Families with children. And this also opens up the issue of educational poverty that will come with the return of distance learning." Severe marginalisation, that of the homeless, remains stable by contrast. With the pandemic, a new phenomenon is taking shape, the report's editor continues: "A sort of normalisation, and above all a spreading, of poverty among people and families who at the start of the year would never have been considered poor by any kind of analysis".
That is not all: the number of young people aged between 18 and 34 below the poverty line has risen from 20 per cent in 2019 to the current 22.7 per cent. Poverty certainly does not look at passports: Italians now account for 52 per cent of the country's poor, up from 47.9 per cent the previous year, thus surpassing foreign nationals.
Among the main reasons for the collapse in income of so many people who have fallen into poverty in recent months is the loss of work. Almost 80 per cent of self-employed workers — those with a VAT number — who turned to Caritas listening centres during the lockdown experienced a drop in their income, sometimes down to nothing. And for 36 per cent the fall amounted to more than half of the household income. In total, 2,073 small traders and self-employed workers were supported by Caritas during that period. The self-employed are and will continue to be among those most exposed to poverty due to lack of work, "given the absence of a stable protection scheme in their favour", the report explains. In many cases these people relied solely on the help of Caritas.
There will be many "in-and-out" fluctuations for those who find themselves — through no fault of their own — in the large category of people hovering around the poverty line. Among them are a great many minors who will face a double blow: the hardships of the present, where children in poor families access education only intermittently, and a compromised future, because for them it will be almost impossible to escape poverty and uncertainty in order to access solid, stable and lasting educational pathways.
The report has shown that a tool such as the emergency income effectively protected only some groups, while excluding too many others. "Those who were left out saw their situation worsen. And there are many of them", De Lauso adds. Originally, the emergency income was intended to help those not entitled to any other benefit. According to the Caritas analysis, however, it reached the same pool of citizens' income recipients: predominantly households made up of adults over 50, mostly single people and single parents with adult children, with an income of up to 800 euros and low rates of employment. This amounts to "a profile that entirely overlaps with that of those receiving the citizens' income", De Lauso comments. "The perverse effect stemming from the lack of clarity in the measures and the cumbersome nature of administrative procedures has been to create a rift between those who already benefited from forms of public protection and assistance, and those who, by contrast, had never before this period had access to the support system".
The Caritas Italiana report analyses data collected up to September, but from October infections have been rising again and ever more closures are on the horizon, including indefinite ones. If even Banca d'Italia has found that during this spring's lockdown one in two Italians saw their income shrink compared with before the pandemic, there is little reason to look to the autumn and winter months with equanimity. Not least because even those who made use of the wage supplementation scheme — which covers only 80 per cent of salary — also suffered a reduction in income. "In the event of a new lockdown or localised territorial closures, we need to think about support tools that act as an immediate social and economic safety net for people and families — De Lauso concludes — and prevent the new poor from soon becoming the 'old' poor. The concern that this will happen, however, remains far too high".