What citizens' income 2019 is, what the requirements are to apply for it and who is entitled to it. But above all: will it manage to restart employment and the economy in Italy?
From today, the official website is online where Italians will be able to find information on citizens' income (rei) and, from next month, submit their application. It is an important day for the government led by Giuseppe Conte and above all for one of the two political partners supporting it, the Five Star Movement, which had also built its campaign for the 2018 general election around this promise. Even before the first card is issued, one thing seems certain: it is a divisive measure, which has been met with fervent enthusiasm on one side and sharp controversy on the other. Let us therefore try to bring some order to understanding how citizens' income works and, with the help of some experts, to speculate on its consequences for our economy.
First of all, it must be clarified that the Italian version is formally not a citizens' income. Technically, in fact, this expression denotes an income paid by the state to anyone (rich or poor, employed or unemployed) simply by virtue of being a citizen. A measure that is in itself very costly, and one that has been tested in the world only sporadically and on a very limited basis. The only notable exception is Alaska, which in 1972 established a state fund financed by revenues from the oil and extractive industry. Since 1982, this fund has paid an annual dividend to all citizens, which reached a maximum of around 2,000 dollars per capita per year, before being reduced in 2016 due to some budgetary problems.
In Italy, something different will get under way in the coming months — namely (as stated in the government's official presentation) "a measure for reintegration into the world of work that serves to supplement family incomes." Deputy Prime Minister Luigi Di Maio, when on 19 January he announced the approval of the package that also included quota 100, expressed it this way: "Today a new welfare state is born in Italy, one that helps people in difficulty and places them at the centre of a revolution in the world of work."
The requirements to apply for citizens' income 2019
These people in difficulty, who fall below the absolute poverty threshold indicated by Istat, number around 5 million in Italy (equal to 1 million 778,000 households). To identify them, the law sets out a series of requirements: an Isee (Equivalent Economic Situation Indicator) of less than 9,360 euros per year, real estate assets of up to 30,000 euros per year (excluding the primary residence) and financial assets not exceeding 6,000 euros, which can rise to 20,000 if there is a disabled person in the household. The requirements are identical for pensioners living below the poverty threshold, who can apply for the citizens' pension (the only exception is financial assets, which rise to 8,000 euros for couples).
The incidence of absolute poverty, says Istat, shoots upward when households are made up exclusively of foreign nationals. Despite this, the law provides an additional hurdle for non-EU nationals, who must have been resident in Italy for at least 10 years, the last two of which must be continuous. Otherwise, there is nothing to be done. According to Il Sole 24 Ore, the households made up entirely of foreign nationals that would be entitled to citizens' income number 256,000, but once those excluded are removed, 164,000 remain. That is 12 per cent relative to the 1 million 322,000 households that will receive it. Here too, the potential pool is wider, but the technical report from Palazzo Chigi estimates that around 85 per cent of those entitled will actually apply.
Massimo Baldini, who teaches Economics at the University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, reminds us that the Five Star Movement's original plans were far more ambitious: "The initial idea was to include relative poor people too; it would have been an enormous, very generous measure, with no equivalent in Europe. Subsequently, however, it was scaled back for many reasons. The first is the lack of resources, given that the estimated expenditure was around 15–16 billion euros; then there is also a cultural reason, because the proposal had been accused of welfare dependency. From there it changed a great deal, becoming closely tied to work."
Potential pool
Effective pool
Italians
1,544,000
1,158,000
Foreign nationals
256,000
164,000
Total
1,800,000
1,322,000
Estimate of the households that will apply for citizens' income
The obligation: committing to look for work
The Italian version of citizens' income will therefore be a monthly contribution paid via a prepaid card. The amount varies according to the specific circumstances of the recipient: up to 780 euros for a person living alone, up to 1,180 euros for a family with two minor children, and so on.
There is, however, a time limit of 18 months, renewable; there are some restrictions (the money must be spent by the end of the month, but not on gambling); and above all there is a "dual track" to follow in order to ward off the accusations of welfare dependency cited by Professor Baldini. Those who are able to work must sign the work and training pact, accepting the offers that will be put to them by the job centre: the first may come from within 100 km of their place of residence, the second from within 250 km, the third from anywhere in Italy. These requirements become progressively stricter over time, but for households with disabled members the maximum distance remains 250 km. Those who are not in a position to work, on the other hand, sign the social inclusion pact, which also involves social services. Exempt from both tracks are people with severe disabilities and those caring for children under the age of 3 or for people who are unable to look after themselves.
The social track, Professor Baldini explains, is the one that most closely resembles the inclusion income, which had been introduced in 2017 by the government led by Paolo Gentiloni and which will be abolished from April. The employment track, conversely, is something new. "The fundamental difference between the two measures, in my view, lies in take-up: in the case of citizens' income it is easier to receive the cash transfer, which is also much higher especially for individuals. With the inclusion income there is a more direct relationship with the municipality's social services, which on average know the families in difficulty," he explains.
ActionAid's response was very harsh — the NGO that fights poverty in Italy and beyond: dismantling the inclusion income is "a mistake" and replacing it with citizens' income, without consulting experts, "risks generating chaos and ineffectiveness, despite the new resources available."
The entire framework of the decree is based on the assumption that "poor people don't want to work"; but we know that isn't the case: what prevents people from having decent work is the mismatch between supply and demand in the labour market, insufficient training, a lack of transferable skills, the incompatibility of work with caring responsibilities, the vicious cycle of underpaid irregular work. These are problems the decree does not address, but instead tries to work around: by exempting from job-seeking those who have caring responsibilities (but do we really want to keep women even further out of the labour market?), by introducing criminal penalties for those receiving citizens' income who simultaneously hold irregular employment (even if underpaid), and by flooding employment centres with people without strengthening the structures that can offer training and pathways into work.
In general, according to Professor Baldini, "we must be careful not to conflate poverty with the absence of work in such a mechanical way", because "work is an individual characteristic, whereas poverty is a family characteristic".
Il principale problema del #redditodicittadinanza sta nella fretta con cui si è voluto realizzarlo. Su un tema delicato e in un contesto difficile, sarebbe stato più saggio aumentare progressivamente gli importi e la platea del reddito di inclusione.lavoce.info/archives/57064…
"Those who are unemployed are almost never a capable and qualified thirty-year-old: very often health problems (physical and mental) and low human capital come into play. When a job does exist, it is increasingly precarious and low-income. Istat data tell us that in half of poor families in Italy there is at least one person in work, which means two things: income is too low and family burdens are high, so perhaps that wage is enough for one person, but not for three or four," he concludes.
To press down on the accelerator of employment, contribution relief has been introduced for every company that takes on a citizens' income recipient; on the condition, however, that the contract is full-time and permanent (no small requirement, given that many of those involved will have been excluded from the labour market for years). A bonus is also envisaged for those who decide to become self-employed after having received citizens' income for a certain period.
Employment centres will bear the delicate task of acting as a bridge between supply and demand. The question, then, is a legitimate one: are they ready to handle the incoming wave of requests? The 2017 Monitoring Report on the Structure and Functioning of Employment Services, published in June 2018 by Anpal (Agenzia nazionale politiche attive lavoro), reveals that the national network consists of 501 "principal" employment centres (i.e. directly connected to provincial or regional coordination), 51 secondary offices and 288 satellite offices or local desks. Their staff across Italy totals 7,034 employees: Sicily alone accounts for 1,737, 22 per cent of the total, followed by Lombardy (775) and Lazio (687). Each of them, already last year, had an average of 380 people on their caseload. All of this, often, without having adequate IT equipment (as declared by 46 per cent of the centres surveyed) or a fast internet connection (36 per cent).
It is therefore no surprise that the budget law allocates up to one billion euros a year, in both 2019 and 2020, to strengthen employment centres, with 10 million euros in 2019 for Anpal Servizi Spa. The government has guaranteed that in the coming months 6,000 "navigators" will be hired — the coaches who will support users. At present, the Anpal website provides no further details.
Costs and benefits for our economy
In addition to the billion euros earmarked for employment centres, the state will spend 6.11 billion euros on citizens' income in 2019, rising to 7.75 billion in 2020, 8.01 billion in 2021 and 7.84 billion in 2022. Expenditure that — according to the technical report — will trigger an increase in employment and consumption, which will drive growth in our economy.
Boiling things down to the bare essentials and simplifying greatly, it is possible to distinguish several approaches to the management of public spending. The austerity approach, which has virtually monopolised European policy over the past ten years, prescribes tightening the belt: if GDP collapses and businesses are in difficulty, the state must try to spend as little as possible, even at the cost of cutting schools, healthcare and social services. A choice taken to its extreme consequences in Greece. On the opposite side stand the Keynesian positions, which instead bet on public investment, triggering an effect known as the "multiplier": every euro spent, in short, causes the economy to grow proportionally.
According to the economic model applied in the government's technical report, the 6.1 billion euros spent in 2019 on citizens' income will have an additional impact on real GDP of 0.1 per cent, rising to 0.2 per cent in subsequent years. Can we therefore say it is a Keynesian measure? "No, or only in a very marginal way," answers Laura Pennacchi bluntly — she directs the Scuola per la buona politica of the Fondazione Basso and coordinates the Cgil's Forum economia nazionale. "For Keynes, what truly matters is the push towards investment. More recent analyses carried out by the IMF (International Monetary Fund) and the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) also agree that the multiplier of public expenditure on monetary transfers — such as citizens' income or a tax cut — is 0.5. The multiplier of investment spending, on the other hand, reaches as high as 3."
A work such as "Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren" dates back to the 1930s, Pennacchi continues, yet proves far ahead of its time in issuing a warning: we cannot limit ourselves to chasing the numbers of economic growth, but must also pause to reflect on our development model. "This element has become far more important today, given that we face a devastating climate crisis and in our country we need to meet a series of social needs ranging from hydrogeological instability to education, cultural heritage, child protection and so on," she explains. "In this sense, current expenditure on a monetary transfer is absolutely irrelevant, because it changes nothing. We are witnessing a abdication of responsibility by the public operator: when there is a problem, providing a monetary compensation after the fact is far easier than solving it. What is needed, on the contrary, is investment spending oriented towards full employment and quality of life. And yet, over the next three years Italy will spend 40 billion euros on monetary transfers and 10 billion on investment."
What citizens' income is, what the requirements are to apply for it in 2019, and what effects it will have on our economy
Environment — di Valentina Neri
What citizens' income 2019 is, what the requirements are to apply for it and who is entitled to it. But above all: will it manage to restart employment and the economy in Italy?