Nuclear: more than half of the United States' power plants are in the red
Energy — di Cecilia Bergamasco
American nuclear energy is in crisis: 34 out of 61 nuclear power plants can no longer hold their own against natural gas and renewable sources.

American nuclear energy is in crisis: 34 out of 61 nuclear power plants can no longer hold their own against natural gas and renewable sources.
More than fifty per cent of America's nuclear power plants are operating at a loss. This is the finding of an analysis by Bloomberg New Energy Finance (Bnef) into the health of nuclear energy in America. Total losses for US nuclear amount to around 2.9 billion dollars a year — a figure that Nicholas Steckler, an analyst at Bnef, calculated by examining the costs of 61 nuclear facilities in the United States.
Steckler calculated that every megawatt-hour of electricity produced from nuclear power fetches between 20 and 30 dollars, yet on average that same megawatt-hour costs a plant around 35 dollars to produce. This is a precarious balance for the finances of the companies operating the plants — most of which are owned by Exelon, Entergy and FirstEnergy — particularly for the 34 plants that are now considered uncompetitive.
The decline of American nuclear power from mid-2014 (Source: Bloomberg New Energy Finance)
In recent years, in America and beyond, what was supposed to be the future of clean energy — nuclear — is becoming a broken promise. The growth of natural gas and renewable sources are the primary causes of nuclear energy's loss of competitiveness. Wind, solar and other clean sources have grown thanks above all to falling technology costs, proving themselves capable of supporting the growth of the world's economies and of competing in the market without the aid of incentives. It is no coincidence that renewables are attracting the attention of investors who, this year, could inject nearly 250 billion dollars into the clean energy market.

The growing pressure that nuclear power plants find themselves having to face is confirmed — more or less explicitly — by the owning companies. While Exelon declined to issue any comment, FirstEnergy said it had already publicly declared the lack of profitability of its plants, refusing to disclose the financial details of each individual generating unit. Entergy also declined to comment on the profitability of its plants, though it added that nuclear generators currently selling into wholesale markets are facing financial challenges caused by falling prices and other unfavourable market conditions.
Faced with the increasingly suffocating crisis in the sector, many nuclear companies are working to secure public subsidies to sustain their operations. Beyond the spectre of job losses that would result from plant closures, nuclear companies are leveraging the potential increase in carbon emissions to obtain state support. Paul Adams, an Exelon spokesperson, stressed that the measures being promoted by states such as New York and Illinois are — in his view — perfectly in line with the measures adopted to promote wind, solar and other forms of clean energy. In short, nuclear as a guarantee of zero-carbon energy. This argument is contradicted by Bnef's analysis: if one wanted to "win easily" on emissions, all that would be needed in the United States would be to shut down all nuclear reactors that are no longer cost-effective.