In the United States, nuclear power is in the red and needs public subsidies to survive

In the United States, nuclear power is in the red and needs public subsidies to survive

Energy · ·

In the United States, nuclear power is suffering from competition from natural gas and renewables. The only way to keep obsolete, uncompetitive plants running is to resort to state funding.

Nuclear power is in deepening crisis. In the United States, 99 nuclear reactors are currently operating across 30 states. Nuclear energy contributes 60 per cent of America's carbon-free electricity, yet it is increasingly uncompetitive. In recent weeks, another announcement has laid bare the sector's difficulties. The owner of the Three Mile Island plant, Exelon Corporation, has revealed its intention to shut down by 2019 unless the state of Pennsylvania — where the plant is located — decides to put up the money to fund a rescue.

nucleare manifestanti usa
Protesters against nuclear power at the anniversary of the Three Mile Island nuclear accident © Jeff Fusco/Getty Images

The closure of the plant at the centre of America's worst nuclear accident

More than five years of losses have driven the Chicago-based energy company to announce the closure of Three Mile Island, the plant known for the nuclear accident of 28 March 1979 — the most serious to have occurred in the United States. The decision to close the plant was also influenced by its failure to be selected as a guaranteed energy supplier to the regional grid. That status would have allowed the company to receive the preferential treatment and payments applied in Pennsylvania to renewables such as wind and solar. With that option gone, Exelon has no choice but to seek a publicly funded bailout — one on which Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolf has made no commitment, despite expressing concern about job losses: the plant employs 675 people, most of whom would be left without work if it closes.

The hunt for public funds to keep nuclear power alive

In some US states — Ohio and Illinois, for example — the hunt for public resources by companies operating nuclear plants has borne fruit. Exelon, the nation's largest nuclear owner, recently secured nearly 2.5 billion US dollars from the Illinois legislature to keep three nuclear reactors running despite their no longer being competitive in the energy market. In Ohio, FirstEnergy is asking the legislature to invest 300 million dollars a year to prop up the currently loss-making Perry and Davis-Besse reactors, which are also beset by serious structural problems. Any rescue plan will have to contend with FirstEnergy's own announcement that the company, on the brink of bankruptcy, has already stated it will sell the reactors regardless. Making matters worse, Ohio legislators have blocked around 1.6 billion dollars in investment earmarked for building eight wind farms, which have now been put on hold — without apparently considering that developing those parks could provide new jobs for the very people who will inevitably lose theirs when FirstEnergy's nuclear plants close.

solare fotovoltaico
Renewable energy sources represent an important source of employment for the United States © Biel Morro / Unsplash

New jobs can only come from renewables

Across the United States, nuclear plants are in crisis, facing competition from facilities that generate electricity using natural gas — an abundant and inexpensive resource. In recent years, another competitor has been growing ever stronger: renewable energy. Wind, solar and other clean sources are increasingly reliable and low-cost, and they are creating new jobs. The closures of nuclear plants are being counterbalanced by investment from companies such as Tesla, a company that is revolutionising the American energy sector. Having inaugurated, in late July 2016, a Gigafactory just outside Sparks, Nevada, that will produce lithium batteries for its vehicles, Tesla is investing around 700 million US dollars in building a new Gigafactory on the east coast of the United States, in Buffalo, in the state of New York. The new facility, which will produce solar roof tiles, will create at least 500 new jobs — clean, well-paid and secure. A further 1,440 positions are expected from spin-offs forecast to emerge around the plant's support activities.

In New York state, the commitment to solar tarnished by the nuclear bailout

The new Gigafactory in Buffalo is just one part of what is happening in New York state, which, despite a strong commitment to solar that grew by nearly 800 per cent between 2011 and 2016, has yielded to the demands of the nuclear energy industry. Governor Andrew Cuomo has allocated 7.6 billion dollars over the next 12 years to keep four ageing reactors owned by Exelon in operation. The bailout plan has been vigorously challenged in court by environmental groups alongside industrial operators, who have accused the intervention of introducing unfair competition into the market and driving up the final cost of energy. Had Governor Cuomo invested the 7.6 billion dollars in clean energy sources, he could have built seven gigafactories like the one in Buffalo, and New York would have gained thousands of new jobs while keeping electricity tariffs lower. It would have been an investment capable of guaranteeing citizens clean and safe energy, transforming the state's energy landscape and improving employment prospects.

powered by Behind Energy