Coronavirus: why Italy's new infection figures look different from those in March

Coronavirus: why Italy's new infection figures look different from those in March

Well-being · ·

New coronavirus infections continue to rise in Italy, but the context in which they are occurring is very different from six months ago.

On Friday 28 August, Italy recorded 1,462 new coronavirus infections, a growth trend that has been continuing for weeks. Taken in isolation, this figure could seem worrying when one considers that back in May, when similar numbers of new infections were being recorded, the country was in lockdown.

If the context surrounding this figure is analysed, however, it emerges that in Italy the fatality rate of Covid-19 corresponds to approximately 1 per cent of those infected, making the new cases of recent days less worrying than those recorded between March and May.

We can understand why through an analysis by Matteo Villa, a researcher at the Institute for International Political Studies (Ispi), whom we first encountered at the end of May, when he spoke to us about the end of lockdown and how the country should have reopened.

bar durante coronavirus nuovi contagi
The context of today's new infections is no longer that of the beginning of the emergency © Marco Di Lauro/Getty Images

The difference between apparent and plausible fatality rates

Let us begin with a distinction between the terms most commonly used over these months to discuss coronavirus deaths. The mortality rate refers to how many people have died after contracting Covid-19 relative to the total population being analysed. The fatality rate, on the other hand, shows how many people have died solely among those who contracted the infection. Villa, in an analysis produced for Ispi on 27 March, gives the following example: "If in a country of 100 inhabitants there are 10 infected people and 5 deaths, the fatality rate will be 50% but the mortality rate will be only 5%".

The fatality rate can in turn be divided into the apparent fatality rate and the plausible fatality rate. The former refers to the data that are "visible" — that is, the number of confirmed cases indicating how many people would appear to be dying (the conditional is necessary because we do not know exactly how many people have truly contracted the virus). The latter, the plausible fatality rate, takes into account an estimate of actual infections, which is significantly higher than the official figure.

controllo di polizia durante coronavirus nuovi contagi
At a time when the coronavirus infodemic is fuelling the excessive circulation of news and information that is often unverified, a whole range of tools has been activated to distinguish what is true from what falls squarely into the realm of disinformation and so-called "fake news" © Emanuele Cremaschi/Getty Images

Monitoring procedures for new infections have improved in Italy

With these definitions in place, it becomes possible to understand why the new cases of recent days should be less concerning than those of the national emergency period.

As Matteo Villa explained on 20 August, the percentages of the two fatality rates have become very similar. Calculating the apparent fatality rate week by week, one can see how between March and June it was between 12 and 20 per cent, before plummeting to the current 1.4 per cent. Meanwhile, the real fatality rate, estimated by Ispi back at the end of March, is likely to be around 1.15 per cent.

This tells us something very important: Italy's procedures for monitoring and tracing new infections have improved, bringing the two values ever closer together. In practice, during the emergency period far more cases were slipping through the net than is the case now, when they are promptly traced and monitored.

🦠🇮🇹 #COVID19: siamo diventati molto più bravi a intercettare le persone infette.

Un nuovo caso oggi è UNDICI volte meno preoccupante di un nuovo caso a marzo.

È un po' complicato, ma provo a spiegarvelo in questo breve thread.

#Covid_19
#COVIDー19

The context of today's new infections is no longer that of the beginning of the emergency

Furthermore, the social and health context in which these figures are situated is extremely different from the initial one. One of the reasons why Italy, like other countries around the world, had opted for lockdown was to prevent the healthcare system from collapsing under the weight of the many cases requiring intensive care treatment. During the crucial months of the emergency, the number of hospital beds had been dangerously threatened by a wave of infections that grew larger every day. This had also caused difficulties in the care of patients hospitalised for other conditions, who could not receive their usual treatment due to the overcrowding of hospital facilities.

The situation is now very different. One of the weekly reports from the Istituto superiore di sanità (Iss) states clearly that, despite an increase in hospital admissions in some regions, "no cases of overload of health services have been reported". At the same time, the numbers of coronavirus deaths, intensive care places and hospital admissions have equally decreased. According to data from the Gimbe foundation dated 27 August, 67 people are currently admitted to intensive care units across the country and 1,131 are hospitalised with symptoms.

Coronavirus remains the greatest challenge for the healthcare system

These considerations should not, however, lead anyone to think that now is the time to lower one's guard and squander the efforts that — through commitment, sacrifice and hard work on everyone's part — have contributed to an improvement in the situation.

On the contrary, as Matteo Villa also emphasises, a fatality rate of 1 per cent carries two major consequences: "A fatality rate of around 1 per cent of those infected represents perhaps the greatest challenge for healthcare systems worldwide. Had the fatality rate been much higher, as with the Sars infections of 2002–2004, the spread of the virus would have been self-limiting, because its hosts would have fallen seriously ill much more quickly, becoming bedridden — at home or in hospital — and therefore far less capable of infecting other people. If, on the other hand, the fatality rate had been much lower, we could have worried less about the new coronavirus and treated it simply as another form of influenza, more serious only because we do not yet have a vaccine. Unfortunately, that is not the case."

Moreover, the number of inhabitants who have contracted the virus is still very low — a factor that makes the achievement of herd immunity impossible, which is reached when 70–80 per cent of the population has been infected.

Now is not yet the time to lower one's guard

This analysis aims to contextualise the data currently available, because the emergency is not yet over. The World Health Organisation has highlighted how the pandemic is beginning to spread to younger segments of the population, who were not particularly affected in the initial phase. According to some scientists quoted by the British newspaper the Guardian, this could translate into a rise in cases but a fall in hospitalisations, as the risk of complications would be lower.

However, there are conflicting views on this hypothesis, since the United States — the country worst hit by the epidemic, with nearly six million cases and 180,000 deaths — recorded a peak in infections among young people, followed by a consequent peak in cases among the elderly, possibly infected by the former. Some suggest that a similar situation could repeat itself in Europe.

paziente italia coronavirus decessi nuovi contagi
The Covid ward of an Italian hospital © Antonio Masiello/Getty Images

It is therefore important to remain vigilant and do everything in our power to continue slowing the advance of the coronavirus: wear a mask, wash and sanitise your hands frequently, maintain social distancing, and cover your nose and mouth when coughing or sneezing. Simple precautions that have so far yielded significant results.