According to the ISS, the coronavirus was already present in Italy in December

According to the ISS, the coronavirus was already present in Italy in December

Well-being · ·

A new ISS study on wastewater has detected traces of the coronavirus in Milan and Turin as early as December 2019.

Traces of the novel coronavirus Sars-Cov-2 were already present in the wastewater of Milan and Turin in December 2019. This is what emerges from a new study by the Istituto superiore di sanità (ISS), carried out through the analysis of wastewater samples collected before Covid-19 manifested itself in Italy, whose first case was recorded on 21 February 2020 in Codogno, in the province of Lodi.

The analysis of Italian wastewater

Samples taken from treatment plants in urban centres in the north of the country were used as an "indicator" of the virus's circulation within the population. The study involved Giuseppina La Rosa, from the Water Quality and Health unit of the Environment and Health department of the Istituto superiore di sanità, Luca Lucentini, director of the Water Quality and Health unit, and Lucia Bonadonna, director of the Environment and Health department of the Istituto superiore di sanità, whom we spoke with to better understand the implications of these findings.

What is the study based on?
The analysis was based on the assumption that viruses are excreted by infected individuals through their faeces. They are therefore found in wastewater which, via the sewer network, reaches treatment plants, where the wastewater is treated, disinfected and returned to the environment. Treatment plants become important observation points for the circulation of viruses within a population, with the advantage of being able to monitor population groups of varying sizes, such as metropolitan areas, or to limit monitoring to specific city districts. This gives us the possibility of intercepting viruses circulating in a community whether they originate from symptomatic or even asymptomatic cases.

Il coronavirus visto attraverso un microscopio
The coronavirus seen through a microscope at the CDC, the American Centers for Disease Control and Prevention © Cdc/Getty Images

What samples did you start from?
Generally, the viruses subject to this type of surveillance are so-called enteric viruses, that is, those with faecal-oral transmission. These include enteroviruses such as hepatitis A, hepatitis E and other enteric viruses associated with gastroenteritis. The analyses are carried out routinely on wastewater samples taken from treatment plants in various Italian cities and regularly arrive at our department.

We had the opportunity to have preserved wastewater samples that could be useful for carrying out a retrospective study to verify whether the Sars-Cov-2 virus was present in wastewater prior to the first symptomatic cases. We analysed samples taken from treatment plants in Milan, Turin and Bologna during the pre-epidemic phase — that is, from October 2019 to February 2020 — and at the same time, wastewater samples stored at our laboratory, taken from the same treatment plants during a period that could hypothetically have predated the spread of the virus in Italy, namely from September 2018 to June 2019.

ospedale italiano coronavirus acque di scarico
The ISS study made it possible to detect the presence of the Sars-Cov-2 virus as early as December, at least in northern Italy © Antonio Masiello/Getty Images

What results did you obtain?
Our study made it possible to detect the presence of the Sars-Cov-2 virus as early as December, at least in northern Italy. We found signals of the presence of the virus — the RNA, the genome — on 18 December 2019 in the wastewater of Milan and Turin, and on 29 January 2020 in Bologna. In the samples we hypothesised might be free of the virus — that is, those from September 2018 through to June 2019 — the virus was indeed absent, thus confirming the absence of the infectious agent during that period.

So could there have been coronavirus cases as early as December?
During that period the presence of the virus had not yet been reported in the country, although some studies that are coming out have highlighted anomalous conditions among hospitalised patients presenting with pneumonia, which were probably attributed to the influenza virus given that it was circulating in Italy at the time. Numbers of pneumonia cases — Covid-like, we would say now — four times higher than those recorded in the same period of the previous year were reported, particularly by doctors, radiologists and pulmonologists.

Indeed, an increase in hospitalisations for pneumonia and flu-like symptoms was observed between October and December 2019, precisely in the areas of Milan and Lodi. This would lead one to hypothesise that the virus was present but was not recognised as a novel coronavirus. It is not for us virologists to say so but for epidemiologists, but the symptoms were probably being confused with those of influenza.

Medici in un ospedale italiano durante il coronavirus
An increase in hospitalisations for pneumonia and flu-like symptoms was observed between October and December 2019, precisely in the areas of Milan and Lodi © Antonio Masiello/Getty Images

How will the monitoring of the virus in water be taken forward? What benefits would it bring?
Following the results obtained, we received further confirmation of the importance of environmental surveillance as an early warning system. We therefore intend to continue monitoring wastewater for Sars-Cov-2 through a national-level study. It could represent a useful tool to complement epidemiological surveillance, thus completing active surveillance of the population thanks to an approach targeting communities rather than individuals.

This type of activity allows us to keep the circulation of the virus in the population under control, whether it is present asymptomatically or manifesting with the typical symptoms of Covid-19. Furthermore, it enables us to detect at an early stage any possible reappearance of the virus, making it possible to identify it quickly and more rapidly contain any potential new epidemic outbreaks.

We have therefore submitted to the Ministry of Health a proposed action based on environmental surveillance for the detection of Sars-Cov-2 in wastewater, structured in two phases. The first should begin in July itself and focuses on detecting the virus in wastewater, at treatment plants in priority sites such as, given the time of year, tourist locations. The second phase, to be activated in October/November 2020, envisages a more extensive national surveillance network involving territorial bodies such as the regional Arpa agencies, regional laboratories, local health authorities (Asl), universities and plant operators, all under the coordination and oversight of the Istituto superiore di sanità.