The outcome of Cop28 is certainly better than what had seemed likely. Once again, however, every country thinks of itself rather than of a global accord.
It was at Cop2, held in Geneva in 1996, that I first became interested in the climate crisis. I was living in Lausanne, an hour's drive away, and as a curious researcher I ended up there almost by chance. Then at LifeGate we carried on — we have been covering the climate since 2000, sending part of our editorial team each time to follow the proceedings. Even in the last week we have friends and colleagues from LifeGate in Dubai. I, with the detachment afforded to me by following the proceedings from Italy, allow myself to share a few immediate reflections. The flavour of this Cop28 is bittersweet too. For the umpteenth time. The twenty-eighth.
To put it very briefly, once again the agreement reached among all the participants is better than the disaster foreshadowed during the preparatory work, but still inadequate given the scale and urgency of the ongoing climate crisis.
There is talk of abandoning fossil fuels, but with an "orderly, just and equitable transition also for producer countries" — transitioning away: the concept is mentioned, but the text is softened to avoid speaking plainly of a "definitive exit from fossil sources" — a phase out — since producer countries could not be entirely alienated (Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates above all; let us not forget that Cop28 was held in Dubai itself). Countries are invited to "accelerate the gradual reduction of coal" without enshrining a true guillotine or even a clear timetable for phasing out the most dangerous fossil fuel for global warming — coal, precisely. Because otherwise India and China would have brought their fists down on the table.
And so on: plenty of "accelerate" and "reduce" that point in the right direction but without bold or sufficiently binding commitments.
In light of all this, I would like to revisit and update a basic observation I had already put forward at Cop9, the last one I attended as a speaker. That was back in 2003, but unfortunately it still seems very relevant today.
There is a fundamental problem, an issue inherent in the model itself: an urgent crisis cannot be resolved effectively with an instrument that seeks to bring roughly two hundred governments from around the world into agreement, with entirely different agendas that are by definition in conflict with one another. However much one may trust in democratic processes, I believe it is essential to assess their limits as well. What has happened over the past few decades unfortunately confirms the doubts: despite tens of thousands of people meeting annually in different parts of the world to find shared solutions, the main outcome has in reality been profound disappointment for those with a genuine interest in solving the problem.
And this happens precisely because such a process, managed by so many actors so different from one another, can only ever play to the lowest common denominator, since there will always be someone determined to spoil the party and undermine the best ambitions with some term deftly inserted into the folds of the texts. And indeed all the agreements produced by the Cops have always avoided binding rules in terms of outcomes and any penalties for those who step out of line.
At #COP27, Prime Minister of Barbados @miaamormottley urged leaders to deliver on past promises to make a “definable difference in the lives of the people, we have an obligation to serve.”
If this was my position in 2003, today I am even more convinced that — without abandoning this path — different routes must also be sought: the geopolitical landscape has changed considerably over these twenty years, and unfortunately in the wrong direction. Tensions between the world's states have exploded in number and intensity. As a result, even the understanding that could once be glimpsed between the major driving powers has vanished in the face of issues perceived as more pressing, such as armed conflicts, and contingent circumstances, such as national budgets to be balanced in the months ahead or economic situations in which the logic of "my country first" prevails. In such a scenario — more akin to a free-for-all than a cohesive parliament — seeking shared consensus appears not merely difficult but entirely utopian.
The greater the tensions and open fronts between the participating countries, the smaller the chances of building bold and visionary actions together.
It is wholly right and essential to try to involve everyone, given that the problem is global. And all the more so, it is right to seek to involve petrostates such as the United Arab Emirates or the wider world of finance. Everyone must be involved because enormous resources need to be mobilised, but we cannot every time remain held hostage by cross-vetoes whose only effect is to defer every real decision to the next round.
In the best-case scenario, Cops should be stages created to give global visibility to the best projects, the most courageous and ambitious governments, and the most virtuous alliances.
A stage for those who have thrown their hearts over the bar and can share that solution, extending it to a wider audience through strategic agreements between various states. In the dystopian reality we are living in, however, the opposite often occurs.
As in the opening days of the Cop, when the appointed president himself, Al Jaber, chief executive of Adnoc, a state oil giant, played down the findings of the scientists he was supposed to defend and appeared to place his own country's interests above those of the international institution he was supposed to represent. The mess was subsequently resolved with a clarification, but two problems were laid bare: not only have we chosen a model in which we seek to reach a compromise that is extraordinarily difficult to find, but we also decided on a host city such as Dubai.
Dr. Sultan Al Jaber, COP28 President, stated that "we have the potential to deliver a paradigm shift that can define global economies of our future, and put the most vulnerable at the center of climate action." #COP28#UniteActDeliver
It could only have been a good idea if a watertight agreement had been in place with the Emirates to make a landmark announcement.
That was not the case, and so the opposite effect was created. 2,500 fossil fuel lobbyists in attendance and any potential dissent nipped in the bud whenever it was deemed too inconvenient. Such as revoking the entry badge of a twelve-year-old girl considered too vocal in reminding everyone that she will be living in that future, and is worried about it.
In the end, the result just reached, as anticipated, is better than expected, but it is certainly not possible to speak of a "historic turning point". Because what is needed now, more than statements of intent, are clear and swift actions.
I have absolutely no wish to downplay some of the results that were nonetheless achieved and that will demonstrate their true significance in the months ahead.
But I cannot share the enthusiasm of president Al Jaber, who spoke of a "historic agreement", or of John Kerry, who spoke of an "extraordinary outcome". For me the truly "historic" result of this Cop28, which emerged with force, is the repositioning operation of the Gulf countries on the international geopolitical chessboard.
At a moment of general confusion in which the traditional balance established by the historic superpowers (the US, China, Russia) appears to have collapsed, it is precisely these countries that want to reshuffle the cards and be seen as active and decisive on the international stage across multiple fronts: sport, wars, the next World Expo, and also the climate crisis.
So what? While governmental solutions at the international level remain, for now, a lukewarm palliative, we can look, paradoxically, to the private sector. Widespread environmental awareness among citizen-consumers demands ever more virtuous behaviour from companies, and these, one hopes, could surpass their own governments in courage and speed of action.
Cop28, getting two hundred countries from around the world to agree is unthinkable
Environment — di Simone Molteni
The outcome of Cop28 is certainly better than what had seemed likely. Once again, however, every country thinks of itself rather than of a global accord.