Cop26, the progress made and the issues still to be resolved in the first draft agreement
Environment — di Andrea Barolini
At dawn on Wednesday 10 November, after a night of negotiations, the first draft agreement at Cop26 in Glasgow was published.

At dawn on Wednesday 10 November, after a night of negotiations, the first draft agreement at Cop26 in Glasgow was published.
Shortly before six o'clock in the morning on Wednesday 10 November 2021, the first draft of the possible final declaration of Cop26 in Glasgow was published. The document will form the basis on which negotiators from nearly 200 nations present in Scotland will work between now and the end of the conference, building on a number of tentative steps forward and numerous issues still to be resolved.
As well as acknowledging the need to act, the "parties" state that they have "welcomed" the first part of the new Ipcc report, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, according to which many of the effects of global warming caused by human activities are now irreversible. It explicitly calls on heads of state and government to work towards stepping up action in key sectors in the fight against climate change, including by making concrete short-term commitments.
The draft indicates, in this regard, that it is necessary to "revisit and strengthen the 2030 targets within the framework of Nationally Determined Contributions". These are the NDCs, the pledges to reduce greenhouse gas emissions put forward by each government. Which, for now, according to a recent assessment by Unep, would put the growth in average global temperature at as much as 2.7 degrees Celsius by the end of the century compared to pre-industrial levels. Even taking into account the further announcements made by governments in recent days, the Climate Action Tracker indicates that the figure would not fall below 2.4 degrees: infinitely more than the most ambitious target of the Paris Agreement, which aims to remain as close as possible to 1.5 degrees.

With regard to adaptation to climate change, the document "emphasises the urgency of scaling up action and support to reduce vulnerability, in line with what the science indicates and with the priorities and needs of developing countries".
In this respect, it is stated in no uncertain terms that "it is noted with deep concern that current allocations are insufficient to respond to the worsening impacts of climate change" in the world's poorest nations. The reference, once again, is to the 100 billion dollars a year that were first promised at Cop15 in Copenhagen in 2009, and which have never been fully disbursed since.
The first draft circulated at Cop26, however, explicitly speaks of the need for "a just transition" towards the net-zero CO2 emissions worldwide. This indicates, at least in theory, a willingness to underscore the importance of ensuring equity within the process of transforming business, the economy and infrastructure that will need to be carried out.
In this sense, of particular importance is the fact that for the first time, at point 37 of the draft, the proposal to "accelerate the phase-out of coal" appears, and, above all, an end to subsidies granted to fossil fuels. "This is – explains Mauro Albrizio, director of Legambiente's European Office, one of the civil society observers at Cop26 in Glasgow – an important political step forward. But for now, neither when nor how this will need to be done has been concretely specified. There is therefore still a great deal of work to be done."

In this regard, it is worth recalling that, according to a report published by Bloomberg NEF and Bloomberg Philanthropies, the G20 nations alone, since the year the Paris Agreement was adopted, 2015, have granted coal, oil and gas something in the order of 3.3 trillion dollars. A figure described as "reckless" by the study's authors.
At point 28, moreover, governments state unequivocally that they have "decided" to "establish a work programme to increase ambition on mitigation" over the next crucial decade. "It is the most important achievement in the first draft – observes Albrizio –, since only in this way will it be possible in the coming years to remain on a trajectory that still gives some chance of hitting the 1.5-degree target."
Despite the tentative advances, however, there are numerous issues that still divide governments. Point 24, for example, seems to repeat the impasse reached at the end of the last G20 in Rome. Rather than indicating the need to achieve carbon neutrality by a specific date — 2050 — the far vaguer formula of "around the middle of the century" was preferred. This risks granting considerable leeway to nations that do not feel they wish to commit in a binding way.
And yet, the draft itself acknowledges, at point 26, that taking into account the latest updates to the NDCs as well, the quantity of greenhouse gases "is estimated to be, in 2030, 13.7 per cent higher than the 2010 level".
At Cop26, a further major point of contention is that linked to transparency. The objective is to agree on a common framework that can effectively (and unambiguously) monitor the progress of each nation in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Discussions on this point continued through the night from Tuesday to Wednesday, without any common ground being found.
The impression is that the British presidency, together with Denmark, is attempting to persuade the most reluctant nation, China, to accept that a form of oversight be imposed on Beijing too. The issue at stake is the possibility, requested by a number of nations, of being allowed to omit certain data from the common reporting. And according to sources, it cannot be ruled out that the point may be dropped entirely, owing to the impossibility of reaching an agreement.