Can you choose between the energy crisis and the climate crisis? The spectre of fossil fuels returns

Can you choose between the energy crisis and the climate crisis? The spectre of fossil fuels returns

Energy · ·

Even the Executive Vice-President for the European Green Deal, Frans Timmermans, opens the door to fossil fuels, without losing sight of climate objectives.

The surge in energy prices that is battering the European Union will bring with it "very, very serious conflicts and wars". Returning to burning fossil fuels is the only way to avert a slide into civil unrest next winter, when there are fears that the taps on Moscow's gas may not be turned on to heat the homes of European citizens. The risk is palpable, given the ten-day (or possibly longer) maintenance shutdown of the Nord Stream 1 pipeline, which runs from Russia to western Europe through the Baltic Sea and Germany. Returning to coal will not, however, undermine the goal of limiting the rise in global temperature to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels, reaffirmed at the Cop26 climate summit in Glasgow last November.

Halting fossil fuels would increase tensions within the EU

It is hard not to bow one's head when even one of the most fervent advocates of the energy transition at a European level takes a step back. In an interview with the British daily The Guardian, Frans Timmermans, the Executive Vice-President for the European Green Deal and Vice-President of the European Commission, as well as the EU's second most senior official, is unequivocal: Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine will not halt the energy transition, but dealing with the consequences of the conflict takes precedence over containing the effects of the climate crisis. "If we were to say stop coal right now we would not be very convincing for some of our member states and we would contribute to further growing tensions within our society," Timmermans declares.

“The text is a huge strengthening of the situation. Never before on the global scene has there been a declaration that coal would be scaled down. I believe that is something to welcome.”

My remarks on the #COP26 outcome this afternoon ⬇️

"Think of home heating before global warming"

Is Putin more frightening than global warming? "If one of the world's main energy producers causes this disruption, as Russia is doing right now, obviously the rest of the world will be unsettled," and this will affect the "possibility of making further commitments on reducing our emissions."

"I have been in politics long enough, over 30 years, to understand that people worry mainly about the immediate crisis and not the long-term one," the European official stresses. Germany is the clearest example: on the eve of the invasion of Ukraine, the EU's strongest economy depended for 40 per cent of its total gas consumption on imports from Moscow, while today it has gone back to burning coal to increase electricity production. And the country's spokesperson, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, is pushing in the direction of a collective rethink on investments in gas-related projects.

Inflation and uncertainty in energy markets: fossil fuels make headway

It would be "hypocritical" to ask or force those who possess fossil fuels not to exploit them to meet the immediate challenge of finding alternatives to Russian gas, just as it would be to curb exploration in parts of Africa, he reiterated. High energy and fuel prices, ever more expensive food, inflation: the uncertainty will not stop — "Putin is using every means at his disposal to create conflicts within our societies, so we must prepare for a very difficult period." If civil unrest breaks out, "we will certainly not get where we need to get" and, on the contrary, we will be playing into Putin's hands.

At a European level there appear to be considerable room for manoeuvre: contrary to expectations, the European Parliament voted (at a second reading) to include gas and nuclear energy within the EU taxonomy for sustainable finance.

Acting strategically? Only by pushing renewable energy

Environmental organisations are firmly opposed: for months Greenpeace Italia, Legambiente and WWF Italia have continued to insist that (even more so) in the face of the war, rising raw material costs and supply problems, the response must be structural and not based on seemingly simple solutions that risk perpetuating the problems driven by pollution.

"The inadmissible solution is the reopening of coal-fired power plants: Italy is putting at stake not only its credibility, but also many of the greenhouse gas reductions it must implement in honouring its commitment to close all gas-fired power plants by 2025," they highlight in a joint press release.

Dall’inizio della guerra in Ucraina i Paesi dell’UE hanno speso più di 33 miliardi di euro per importare gas fossile, petrolio e carbone dalla Russia. È ora di investire nella pace, non nel petrolio!👇bit.ly/3OeOtKB #PeaceNotOil #StopFuellingWar

As well as being the easiest route, the fossil fuel path — gas in particular — is also the most burdensome, both in environmental and economic terms: "Expanding gas infrastructure would be a waste of resources," especially given that the "regasification terminals we have are paid for in our bills because they are underutilised," the organisations stress.

The brakes applied to Cop27

Keeping European citizens warm and ensuring that industry operates at full capacity is now the priority: Timmermans aims to announce the "all clear" by 1 November at the latest. And on the prospects for Cop27, the United Nations conference on climate change taking place next November in Sharm el-Sheikh, he is cautious: the nations that will sit at the negotiating table have not yet drawn up effective plans to contain the global temperature rise, and "there is not much appetite to increase NDCs" — the Nationally Determined Contributions that reflect the promise of more serious and stringent climate plans. There is also "a lot of frustration in developing countries over funds that were promised but are not yet fully available." Coal will have to be used. It is hard not to feel discouraged.