Energy geopolitics is shifting, but fossil fuels remain

Energy geopolitics is shifting, but fossil fuels remain

Energy · ·

The relationships between states and continents over energy supply are changing, but the type of source is not: we are still talking about fossil fuels.

Following the 40 per cent cut in gas supplies to Germany, the energy war between Russia and Europe has now entered full swing. The Kremlin is tightening its grip on fossil fuel supplies and costs are rising: the price of methane on the Amsterdam exchange jumped by 43 per cent in one week, rising from €82.50 to €117.74, with peaks of €134 per MWh.

Meanwhile, Russia has become China's top crude oil supplier, displacing Saudi Arabia from that role. Moscow's oil now accounts for 55 per cent of the oil imported by Beijing. India, too, is taking advantage of Russian oil, which is cheaper than that from the rest of the world.

United States President Joe Biden will travel to Saudi Arabia, where he will meet Prince Mohammed bin Salman — and has been criticised for doing so — in an attempt to convince the Middle Eastern country to increase oil production. In short, compared to the start of the invasion of Ukraine, global energy geopolitics has shifted once again. But the main players are always the same: fossil fuels.

gasdotto-finlandia-combustibili fossili
A gas pipeline in Finland © Sean Gallup/Getty Images

Is Italy running out of gas?

In Italy too, the Ministry of Ecological Transition is evaluating whether to raise the crisis level of the national gas system, moving it from early warning to alert. If the cuts were to continue for an extended period, the storage mechanism could be put at further risk — a scenario that has already prompted Germany to restart its coal-fired power plants.

The Italian government has already discussed this possibility, and it is precisely on the issue of reserves that the technical emergency and natural gas monitoring committee, set up at the ministry, is focused. In the meantime, Italian gas is coming increasingly from Algeria and less and less from Russia (while domestic production has almost entirely disappeared). Data released by the Mite show an increase of 289 per cent in gas imported from the North African country, against a veritable collapse in purchases from Moscow, which have fallen by around 48 per cent.

Draghi, Macron Scholz
Macron, Draghi and Scholz on a visit to Ukraine © Jesco Denzel/Bundesregierung via Getty Images

Eni will produce emissions until 2050

Speaking of imports, energy giant Eni recently joined the North Field East consortium, the world's largest liquefied natural gas (LNG) project, as a new international partner of QatarEnergy and TotalEnergies. This partnership, hailed by numerous Italian media outlets as a major milestone, represents a "carbon bomb" in terms of emissions: a "climate bomb" refers to a fossil fuel extraction project capable of releasing at least 1 billion tonnes of CO2 into the atmosphere over its lifetime.

gnl lituania
A vessel transporting liquefied natural gas at the port of Klaipeda, Lithuania © Paulius Peleckis/Getty Images

It is estimated that North Field East may hold 10 per cent of the world's LNG reserves. It is "a competitive process that began in 2019" and "has a duration of 27 years", the company's website states. That is to say, it ends in 2050 — the very year by which, on the contrary, we should be achieving net zero emissions (and in the meantime Eni states that these investments represent a significant milestone in the company's diversification strategy, "which broadens its portfolio of cleaner, more reliable energy sources").

We Italians are placing a great deal of faith in LNG (as indeed is all of Europe, which has signed an agreement with the United States) — a choice that will stay with us for many years to come. Draghi has in fact appointed special commissioners for the construction of two floating regasification terminals (each with a capacity of 5 billion cubic metres), one at Ravenna and the other at Piombino.

von der leyen repowereu
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen © Getty Images for Greentech Festival

Europe says full steam ahead with fossil fuels

At the European level, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has warned member states not to backtrack on reducing the use of fossil fuels in response to the reduction in Russian supplies. In addition, a new Commission regulation requires that gas storage facilities must be filled to at least 80 per cent by 1 November 2022, to protect European citizens from potential supply shocks.

And, at the same time, the European Union is working to strengthen its energy cooperation with other countries. High on the list is Israel, which Italian Prime Minister Mario Draghi recently visited. The European Union has signed a memorandum of understanding with Israel and Egypt: "With this agreement we will work on the stable supply of natural gas to the EU from the Eastern Mediterranean region," von der Leyen said from Cairo.

But there is little to celebrate. The geopolitics of energy sources once again revolves around securing fossil fuels. And meanwhile renewables — which remain truly the only way to break free from the dictatorship of fossil fuels — are left waiting in the background. While emissions continue to rise.