Governments' climate commitments are still insufficient
Environment — di Andrea Barolini
5 years after the Paris Agreement was adopted, 80 nations gathered for a climate summit. But the commitments put forward are still not enough.

5 years after the Paris Agreement was adopted, 80 nations gathered for a climate summit. But the commitments put forward are still not enough.
A balance sheet that is, once again, a mixed picture. That is what emerged on Saturday 12 December from the summit organised to mark the fifth anniversary of the adoption of the Paris Agreement on climate. Only some of the 80 heads of state and government invited to the conference put forward new pledges on reducing greenhouse gas emissions. This was the case for the United Kingdom, China, Pakistan and, as a whole, the European Union. But they will not be enough to save the planet from climate catastrophe.
During the event, it was highlighted that – as things stand – the trajectory of global warming will lead to a rise in the global average temperature, across land and ocean surfaces, of 3.5–4 degrees Celsius by 2100, compared to pre-industrial levels. This, knowing that even exceeding "just" 2 degrees (the upper limit set by the Paris Agreement, which nonetheless calls for staying as close as possible to 1.5 degrees) would bring about epochal upheaval for the Earth.

The summit (held by video conference) was organised by the United Kingdom, which will host the next UN Climate Change Conference (Cop 26), France and the United Nations. They had already set conditions for participation: only nations that had indicated new concrete and ambitious commitments were invited to the event. As a result, requests from Australia, Brazil, Russia, Turkey, South Africa and Saudi Arabia were turned down.
Even so, too many nations, even during Saturday's meeting, showed too much caution. This was despite a heartfelt appeal from United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres, who explicitly called on governments to "stop waging war on the planet." Alok Sharma, president of Cop 26, commented on the outcome of the summit with these words: "Have we made real progress? Yes. Have we made enough to limit the rise in global average temperature to 1.5 degrees? No. While encouraging, these pledges are not enough."
Likewise, Laurence Tubiana – one of the architects of the Paris Agreement in 2015 – explained to the French daily Le Monde that "the summit marked some interesting progress, but short-term commitments, though indispensable, came only from the European Union and small nations. A great deal of pressure will be needed on G20 nations to adopt commitments between now and 2030 and not only by 2050." The non-governmental organisation Extinction Rebellion also voiced all its misgivings: commitments set so far in the future are "death sentences." Meanwhile, activist Greta Thunberg spoke of a "wrong direction."
Consider that a nation like China, the world's leading emitter of greenhouse gases, announced its intention to achieve carbon neutrality — that is, the elimination of net emissions of climate-altering gases — by 2060. During the 12 December summit, however, it announced its intention to reduce emissions relative to gross domestic product by "more than 65 per cent" by 2030, compared to 2005 levels. And to work towards renewable energy accounting for 25 per cent of national consumption within the next ten years, tripling installed wind and solar capacity.
Even here, though, these are targets that experts consider too modest. Manish Bapna, vice president of the American think tank World Resources Institute, explained that "these are steps in the right direction, but if China truly wants to achieve the carbon neutrality it has set for 2060, it must set itself more ambitious short-term targets from now."
For its part, the European Union committed to reducing emissions by "at least 55 per cent" by 2030, compared to 1990 levels. A concrete step forward from its previous commitment, which envisaged a 40 per cent reduction. But still insufficient, given that reaching 65 per cent would be needed for us to play our part in pursuit of the global objective of not exceeding 1.5 degrees.
Pakistan, by no means one of the world's wealthiest nations, surprised everyone by announcing its intention to abandon the construction of new coal-fired power stations. It presented a plan that would bring renewable sources to 60 per cent of the national energy mix and electric vehicles to 30 per cent of cars in circulation within the next ten years. New commitments also came from Canada (which allowed for a carbon tax of 170 Canadian dollars per tonne of CO2 emitted, but starting from 2030) and from Sweden, Iceland, Colombia and Barbados.

Unfortunately, many G20 nations were content to reconfirm their old pledges. This was the case for India, which, while indicating a desire to "go further," put forward no new formal commitment. The world is also waiting to see whether future United States president Joe Biden will be able to honour his electoral promises on climate. The coming months will therefore be decisive, as the world awaits Cop 26, to be held in November 2021 in Glasgow. Between now and then, the planet is playing for a large part of its chances of meeting the objectives of the Paris Agreement.