What is carbon tax
Energy — di Lorenzo Brenna
We explain carbon tax, how it works, and the economic and environmental policy foundations it rests on. Summarising experiences and potential.

We explain carbon tax, how it works, and the economic and environmental policy foundations it rests on. Summarising experiences and potential.
In light of the recent resolution by CIPE, the possible use of fiscal instruments (green taxes) to preserve and guarantee environmental balance is once again topical.
Carbon tax is a tax on energy resources that emit carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. It is an eco-tax aimed at incorporating the intrinsic costs of the effects of greenhouse gases on the environment which, according to economists, should lead to automatic market regulation.
Since it is directed against a negative behaviour, it is classified as a Pigouvian tax (named after Arthur Cecil Pigou, who first proposed a solution to the problem of public costs).
The EU has discussed a carbon tax for its member states, in addition to carbon emissions trading, which began in 2005.
However, emissions trading systems differ from carbon tax because:
• payment for emissions is not collected by a government body
• the price per unit of emission is not fixed as in taxation systems, but rather as a market price that fluctuates.
In economic theory, pollution is considered a negative externality that represents part of the social cost of production not included in producers' private costs. As a result, companies would consider it less costly to pollute than to find other means of production because not all production costs have been "internalised". To resolve this problem, Pigou proposed a tax on goods whose production was the cause of negative externalities reflecting the costs of production on society, thereby internalising all costs linked to the production of goods. Carbon tax is an indirect tax as opposed to direct taxes, such as income tax. Externalities are the cause of market failure since they hinder the efficient use of public goods (environmental resources) by placing the environmental cost "generated" by the polluter onto society.
Environmental policy instruments are the mechanism aimed at ensuring that the polluting party complies with the requirements set by regulatory authorities. They are divided into 3 categories:
• Voluntary instruments (e.g. Emas, Iso 14000)
• Regulatory standards. These are generally divisible into 4 types: emission standards, process standards, quality standards and product standards. Although they regulate efficiency standards, the limitations are linked to the fact that they do not differentiate between different situations and do not constitute an incentive for the implementation of virtuous mechanisms
• Economic instruments. These represent the modification of the prices of goods and services through government actions that impact on production and consumption costs. Two types of instruments are distinguished: incentives/grants/subsidies and taxes, preferred by economists because they are more equitable and reduce barriers to entry by favouring demand elasticity. Carbon tax also belongs to this category. The purpose of a carbon tax is therefore both financial and environmental.
Special types of carbon taxes
include:
• Optimal carbon tax
• Value-at-risk carbon tax
Economic rationale
Assuming the negative externalities associated with the production of carbon dioxide, a global tax on carbon dioxide emissions would bring about improvements in economic efficiency in proportion to the non-wastage of revenues. Achieving the desired objectives with the introduction of a carbon tax requires that it be applied at a macro level and associated with other virtuous mechanisms such as emissions trading. For example, if the USA were to impose a carbon tax, many energy-intensive industries would simply migrate to nations without a carbon tax, and many of these would be developing countries that are dramatically less energy-efficient. This would simply cause substantial economic stagnation in the United States with no improvements in carbon dioxide emissions.
Many economists believe that a carbon tax imposed on a less than global basis would have at best a neutral impact on world pollutant emissions and would simply cause economic stagnation in the countries that imposed it.
International experiences
On 1 January 1991, Sweden imposed a carbon tax of 25 SEK/kg ($100 per tonne) on the use of oil, coal, natural gas and other polluting fuels. Industrial users pay half the rate, and some energy-intensive industries such as commercial horticulture, manufacturing and paper mills were entirely exempted from these new taxes. In 1997 the rate was increased to 365 SEK/kg ($150 per tonne) of CO2 emitted.
Finland, the Netherlands and Norway also introduced carbon taxes in the 1990s.
In 2005 New Zealand proposed a carbon tax, setting an emission price of NZ$15 per tonne of CO2 equivalent. It was due to come into force from April 2007 and was applied to the major economic sectors but granted an exemption for methane emissions from farmers and provided special exemptions for large coal consumers on condition that they adopted world's-best-practice emission standards. After the 2005 general elections, the minor parties supporting the government opposed the tax, which was abandoned in December 2005. The government argued that the tax would not have served to reduce emissions.
US President Bill Clinton proposed a BTU Tax that was never adopted. His Vice President, Al Gore, strongly advocated the imposition of a carbon tax in his book Earth in the Balance, a message not taken up by his Republican opponents.
Current situation in Italy and possible implementation dynamics
In Italy, carbon tax was introduced (but never applied) under article 8 of Law no. 448 of 23 December 1998, in accordance with the conclusions of the Kyoto Conference held from 1 to 11 December 1997. On 16 April 2012 the Council of Ministers approved the draft law on fiscal delegation, divided into 3 different areas, one of which is dedicated to reorganising environmental taxation with a view to promoting growth and the internalisation of environmental costs into production costs. The Ministry of the Environment's intention is to allocate the tax revenue resulting from the introduction of carbon tax to the financing system for renewable energy sources.
What is particularly interesting is not only the approach of redistributing the tax burden to promote renewable energy sources, but also the fact that this process will not entail an increase in the overall tax burden, as the delegation will be implemented on a revenue-neutral basis and will lead to a reorganisation of taxation in order to preserve and guarantee environmental balance.
Sectors already covered by the Emissions Trading Scheme will be excluded from carbon tax, while other sectors will be involved in the "polluter pays" logic. The proceeds from carbon tax will be allocated to supporting public and private investment in reducing the carbon intensity of the economy, including through the strengthening of the "Fondo Rotativo del Protocollo di Kyoto". This mechanism will represent a valid incentive for achieving the 20-20-20 Plan, representing the European objective for the post-Kyoto period.
The European roadmap is aimed at affirming the leading role of the Old Continent in the field of environmental economics and aims to exceed standard targets by raising the 2020 objective to a 25% reduction in CO2, 40% by 2030, 60% by 2040 and 80% by 2050 compared to 1990 levels.