Energy costs and electric cars: what is the real impact on charging costs? The debate over the consequences of soaring energy prices is heating up: a year ago
Beyond the serious hardships suffered by families and businesses over recent months, soaring energy costs could also have a heavy impact on the ecological transition of the mobility sector. Whereas, up until a year ago, charging an electric car cost between 50 and 70 per cent less than running a conventional vehicle, today filling up on electricity can end up costing even more. The figures emerge from an analysis carried out by Facile.it, which examined the consumption of several electric models and compared them with similar petrol- or diesel-powered vehicles. The thesis was quickly disputed by the association Motus-E, which spoke of "wrong calculations" and "misleading results", while not denying the difficulties of the current moment. But let us take things in order.
The research highlighting a 161 per cent impact from soaring energy costs
According to Facile.it, charging a battery-powered car today costs 161 per cent more than it did 12 months ago. For the analysis, the comparison platform examined three car models in their fully electric, diesel and petrol versions, taking into account the consumption figures declared by the manufacturers and the prices of energy and fuel. For electricity, the cost of a home charge was calculated using as a reference the prices in force on the regulated market in October 2021 and in the same month of this year, while for petrol and diesel the average pump prices recorded in September 2021 and in the last week of September of the current year were used.
In the first case – a segment B city car with an engine output of between 100 and 136 horsepower – to cover a distance of 1,000 kilometres the most cost-effective engine is the diesel at €71, followed by petrol (€83) and electric (€85). In the second case too – a segment C saloon with an output of between 130 and 150 horsepower – diesel comes out on top at €77: in second place is the electric car at €80, while the least cost-effective is the petrol model at €88. Only in the third simulation – a segment D saloon with an output of between 249 and 286 horsepower – does the electric model still prove to be the most cost-effective today: the cost is €99 to cover 1,000 kilometres, compared with €108 for diesel and €124 for petrol.
Motus-E's rebuttal: wrong data and misleading results
The figures were disputed by the association Motus-E, according to which the electricity cost on which Facile.it based its calculations refers exclusively to electricity purchased by a domestic customer at a variable price; in essence, no account is taken either of those who have signed a contract with a fixed tariff, or of those who, thanks to a photovoltaic system, eliminate or significantly reduce their energy costs: we are talking about over one million self-producers. In the study, moreover, the electric mobility stakeholder association points out that no mention is made of those who benefit from a flat-rate tariff for public charging; that is, a subscription-based plan under which the customer is offered a charging package in exchange for a fixed fee. With flat-rate subscriptions, in fact, tariffs remain between €0.31 and €0.35/kWh. Recalculating the segment B car simulation on the basis of these figures would yield a cost of €55 instead of €85, which is lower than both diesel and petrol.
In any case, Motus-E stresses that "the energy crisis and the related rise in commodity prices continue to cause us concern: the situation is unsustainable for many families and businesses, regardless of how they travel, and for this reason we trust that the Italian government and all European ministers will converge on a mitigation solution and a decoupling from gas prices as soon as possible." For the future of the electric car too, the game ultimately remains more open than ever.
Energy costs and electric cars: what is the real impact on charging costs?
Mobility — di Dario Zerbi
Energy costs and electric cars: what is the real impact on charging costs? The debate over the consequences of soaring energy prices is heating up: a year ago