Where things stand with Brexit

Where things stand with Brexit

Rights · ·

The British Parliament has asked Prime Minister Theresa May to renegotiate the Brexit deal. The European Union has, for now, rejected the proposal.

Time is running out but uncertainty over the fate of Brexit is growing ever greater. Following the rejection by British MPs of the draft agreement between the London government and the European Union, Prime Minister Theresa May obtained a fresh mandate from the House of Commons to reopen negotiations with Brussels.

British Labour calls for the Brexit date to be postponed

A way out to avoid a "no deal" – that is, the United Kingdom's departure without an agreement, which would entail major risks for all the countries involved – one that would have to be taken at the last minute. The Brexit deadline is, after all, set (for now) for 29 March. However, from the European Union's side the British proposal has for now been sent back: the document signed in November is "non-negotiable" according to EU leaders, as the presidency of the European Council made clear.

#May s'inchina ai falchi, 'Ue riapra accordo su #Brexit'. Scommessa su ricompattamento Tory entro 13 febbraio. Gelo a Bruxelles
#ANSA
ow.ly/yjQp30nvfGe

The situation is therefore one of complete deadlock. The "withdrawal treaty" was in fact rejected in a particularly decisive manner by British MPs — and only a few days ago: on 15 January. Theresa May therefore has no way of going against the will of her own Parliament. Nor can she go back before MPs with what would essentially be a carbon copy of the rejected text. It is no coincidence that the Prime Minister spoke of "an important and legally binding change to the agreement", adding that "negotiating such a change will not be easy, but I believe I can do it with the support of Parliament".

🔴 BREAKING - British MPs accept amendment to reopen negotiations with EU on Irish backstop f24.my/4LWJ.t

On 29 January Theresa May spoke with European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker, explaining that the main point requiring changes in order to be accepted by the House of Commons is the one concerning the so-called "backstop" — namely, the provision that prevents the return of a physical border between Ireland and Northern Ireland. In the past, both sides had stated their wish to avoid reintroducing customs controls so as not to reignite tensions in a territory that is finally enjoying a period of peace and prosperity after years of violence.


The British government also made clear to Brussels that it is "determined to leave the Union on 29 March". A Labour MP, Yvette Cooper, has however tabled an amendment calling for the date to be postponed. Should it be approved (the debate is scheduled for 5 February), the situation could change radically.

What a no-deal Brexit would entail

May responded to this prospect by arguing that, in her view, it would not solve the problems, and indeed stated that if a new agreement cannot be reached by 13 February, the following day the government would ask Parliament for a fresh vote — this time to approve the "no deal" option. For some, this would represent a catastrophe. European citizens living in the United Kingdom could in fact be forced to apply immediately for a residence permit. From a transport perspective, there are small airports in Europe that are not yet equipped to handle arrivals from "non-EU" countries.

Endless queues at Channel boarding points are also expected, caused by the reimposition of checks. Eurostar trains could be forced to stop. Fishermen would no longer be able to access British territorial waters. Not to mention the risk that academic qualifications obtained by European citizens in the United Kingdom would no longer be automatically recognised. As well as the difficulties linked to the halt to the free movement of goods and capital, which could even lead to the prospect of introducing tariffs.

theresa may
Theresa May, Conservative Party candidate © Christopher Furlong/Getty Images

In the face of such problems, it cannot be ruled out that attempts may be made to revive proposals such as an "ultra-soft" exit, along the lines of Norway's current situation. The Scandinavian country, despite not being a member of the Union, is part of the European single market. And to enjoy this privilege it pays a "bill" of 900 million euros a year. A proposal that May has deemed unacceptable, however, because it would betray the very meaning of the referendum of 23 June 2016 that enshrined the popular will to leave all European treaties.

A sovereignty limbo

An emergency way out could then be the "Backstop", which would guarantee that the Irish border remains open in any case, leaving the timing and means of reaching an agreement on everything else in abeyance. A kind of guarantee clause for the Dublin government and its economy.

beatles brexit liverpool
If the Beatles had been around… they might well have voted against Brexit. That is what the protesters who took to the streets on 23 September in Liverpool, the city where the Fab Four were born, imagined © Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images

If diplomacy were to fail, then, a result that, paradoxically, all the parties involved want would not be achieved, highlighting all the more clearly how opinion poll ratings and matters of principle are considered more important than finding a concrete solution to problems affecting millions of Europeans, today cast into what can only be described as a "sovereignty limbo".