Brazil, no respite for indigenous peoples: Senate backs marco temporal
Rights — di Maurizio Bongioanni
In Brazil, the Senate approves the bill on marco temporal, the same anti-indigenous ruling rejected by the Supreme Court just one week earlier.

In Brazil, the Senate approves the bill on marco temporal, the same anti-indigenous ruling rejected by the Supreme Court just one week earlier.
Indigenous peoples in Brazil cannot even enjoy a week's peace. In less than 7 days, in fact, from the ruling of the Federal Supreme Court of Brazil that rejected the marco temporal (under which indigenous peoples would only have rights to lands already occupied before the entry into force of the federal Constitution, on 5 October 1988), the Brazilian Senate ignored the Court's ruling and approved the bill known as PL490 – when it was being debated in the Chamber – which then became PL2903 once it reached the Senate.
A law that many movements committed to defending indigenous rights consider "genocidal" towards native peoples, as it would pave the way for the reduction or cancellation of any indigenous territory in Brazil, which could thus be replaced by mines, oil wells or other industrial projects.

On 27 September, in a single day, the bill — considered unconstitutional by many — was first approved by the Senate's "Committee on Constitution, Justice and Citizenship" and subsequently the President of the Senate, Rodrigo Pacheco, accepted the request for an urgent vote in plenary, which led to its approval with 43 votes in favour and 21 against.
A lightning-fast procedure that cannot help but bring to mind the interests of the agribusiness lobby, which has always been very active in championing the usefulness of the marco temporal so as to gain access to lands hitherto protected by the Constitution, and which wields considerable influence over Brazilian politics. For his part, however, the President of the Senate, Rodrigo Pacheco, was keen to stress that the recent vote does not represent an "affront" to the Court, and described the Congress's approval of the draft as "very natural". According to Pacheco, this type of issue should always be addressed by parliament.
Members of parliament still need to decide on the key points of the text and any amendments, after which the document will be sent to President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva for approval. It is expected, however, that he will veto the bill.
Lula has always declared himself opposed to the marco temporal, and his electoral campaign devoted considerable attention to the causes of indigenous peoples. The veto could temporarily halt the bill's progress, which would in that case need to be debated again. The waters of Brazilian politics risk becoming decidedly choppy in the near future.