President Ilham Aliyev's party retains its majority of seats, but international observers describe the vote as undemocratic.
In the snap parliamentary elections held in Azerbaijan on 1 September 2024 — the first since the country last year regained control of the Nagorno-Karabakh territory disputed with Armenia — the ruling party of President Ilham Aliyev retained its majority, securing 68 out of 125 seats. These are at least the partial results released after the counting of 91 per cent of ballots (the final results will be announced by 22 September). In substance, however, little changes: the ruling New Azerbaijan party confirms the number of seats it already held in parliament, in an electoral round marked by a rather low turnout (37.27 per cent, the lowest figure recorded in parliamentary elections since the country gained independence from the USSR in 1991), and by "a restrictive political and legislative framework that does not allow for genuine pluralism", as the OSCE, the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe, has denounced.
The Azerbaijani political scene is indeed dominated by President Aliyev's New Azerbaijan party which, in addition to occupyingalmost 60 per cent of seats, can also count on a group of political alignments loyal to the government line. Add to this the control of information, enshrined in the media law adopted in 2022, the repression of civil liberties and critical voices, the general impoverishment of public debate and the weakening of political opposition recorded in recent years, and the portrait that emerges is of a country that Freedom House defines as "not free".
#Azerbaijan’s #elections devoid of real competition amid diminishing respect for fundamental freedoms, but efficiently prepared: international observers buff.ly/3TghgTg
In these latest elections, which were due to be held in November but were brought forward because of Cop29, the United Nations Conference on Climate Change taking place during that very period in the capital Baku, many opposition parties chose to boycott the vote, as did the Popular Front of Azerbaijan, which did not stand in the elections, citing a complete absence of transparency. The other major opposition party, Musavat, instead decided to change tactics and for the first time in fifteen years fielded its own candidates, without however winning a single seat. The remaining seats will therefore be allocated to formally independent candidates and minor parties, which in practice nonetheless support the government.
Despite the presence of 279 observers from 34 countries, there was no shortage of reports of fraud and violations, and according to Musavat leader Arif Hajili, the voting "did not take place in a democratic environment".
"The authoritarian regime in Azerbaijan has been consolidating over many years and it would be anachronistic to observe the ongoing political process through the lens of democratic transition — Laurence Broers, one of the foremost experts on Caucasus politics, director of the 'Caucasus' programme at the independent peacebuilding organisation Conciliation Resources and co-founder of Caucasus Survey, the first academic journal dedicated to this region, commented to LifeGate —. We should instead analyse Azerbaijan's politics by drawing comparisons with other authoritarian regimes, and therefore asking ourselves what type of authoritarianism we are dealing with, how it functions, how it legitimises itself, what role democratic institutions play in helping to consolidate this regime. In the country, for example, opposition parties exist, but they are to all intents and purposes excluded from the political arena."
In office since 2003 and re-elected for a fifth consecutive term in February 2024 with 92 per cent of the vote, Ilham Aliyev is the undisputed protagonist of the Azerbaijani political scene. It is in his hands that the power inherited from his father, Heydar Aliyev, now rests — a KGB man who led the country under Soviet rule and was installed as president following a military coup in 1993, in the wake of the collapse of the Eastern bloc.
Over these twenty years in power, in addition to driving the country's modernisation process — whose economy rests on hydrocarbons (gas and oil account for 90 per cent of Azerbaijani exports and together make up 60 per cent of the public budget) — the current president Ilham Aliyev has entrenched his position by extending the presidential term from 5 to 7 years and removing the limit on presidential re-election beyond two terms.
The military victory over the Armenian separatists of Nagorno-Karabakh in September 2023, with which Aliyev today boasts the credit of having "reunified" the country, then secured him an important domestic political consecration: a card that appeals to a large part of the population, which has always viewed Armenians as historic adversaries.
"When Ilham Aliyev was appointed president in 2003, there were mass protests and his presidency began with a lack of legitimacy — Laurence Broers explained —. Since then, Aliyev has always sought to legitimise his position, first and foremost through a process of socio-economic development of the country which, with the inauguration of the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline in 2006, led to an oil boom. The profits were enormous and this made it possible to introduce public and social programmes benefiting broad sectors of the population. All of this, combined with a political strategy aimed at preventing and disarming the opposition, allowed Ilham Aliyev to broaden his support base."
Azerbaijan and foreign policy
Today, with the formation of the multipolar world so widely discussed, Azerbaijan is pursuing a foreign policy aimed at maintaining the best possible relations with various states, from Russia under Vladimir Putin — who visited Baku just a few weeks ago — to Turkey under Recep Erdoğan, with whom a sense of Turkic-Azerbaijani brotherhood has been rekindled, through to the European Union, which is seeking a strategic partnership to bypass Russian gas.
"We must not, however, make the mistake of identifying only two possible tracks: pro-Russia or pro-West — Laurence Broers explained —. In Azerbaijan's case the situation is far more complex: the country has above all very close ties with Turkey, which in turn has geopolitical relations with the West as a Nato member, but its interests do not always coincide with Western ones; secondly, Baku also has a very close relationship with Iran: let us not forget that Azerbaijan is a majority-Muslim country, albeit a secular one. For this reason the 'Russia/West' opposition is inadequate if we genuinely want to understand all the nuances of the Azerbaijani positions."
On the domestic front, meanwhile, after the gradual consolidation of authoritarianism recorded over the past two decades through repressive crackdowns and ad hoc legislation, the authorities have recently sought to safeguard themselves by implementing a fresh tightening that has led to the arrest of pacifists, researchers, students and journalists, persecuted in the general indifference of the international community on the very eve of Cop29. An indifference that compounds the hypocrisy, denounced by many, of hosting the world's most important climate event in a country whose economy is based almost exclusively on fossil fuels.
The latest crackdown in recent weeks is merely the tail end of a broader wave of repression that began in 2014–2015 and flared up again in the summer of 2023, which also led to the arrest of Gubad Ibadoghlu, a prominent economist and activist, associate of the London School of Economics, and a particularly outspoken critic of the fossil fuel industry. Shortly before his arrest, Ibadoghlu — who is currently under house arrest — had published an article criticising Azerbaijan's oil and gas policies.
In September of last year, the European Parliament adopted an "urgent resolution" calling for the immediate and unconditional release of Ibadoghlu, stating that the finalisation of a future EU–Azerbaijan partnership agreement should be made conditional on the release of all political prisoners. According to the Turan news agency, there are at least 300 political prisoners in Azerbaijani jails.
Yet, despite the glaring human rights and civil rights violations (Amnesty International speaks of "vindictive acts of reprisal, intimidation and threats against the families" of political prisoners as well), the West is turning a blind eye to Baku in order to do business and circumvent Russian gas. In the summer of 2022, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen had signed an agree
Azerbaijan's ruling party wins parliamentary elections, but there is no democracy in the Cop29 host country
Rights — di Lucia Bellinello
President Ilham Aliyev's party retains its majority of seats, but international observers describe the vote as undemocratic.