What we must learn from the 2022 Marche floods

What we must learn from the 2022 Marche floods

Rights · ·

The case of the 2022 Marche floods is a mirror of the risk of environmental disasters caused by illegal building and neglect of the land.

"I could feel the waves of the sea," mimics signora Rosa. With her hand she traces the back of the river that swept away Pianello di Ostra: wherever it passed it clung to people's hair, to clothes scattered around, to the leaves of trees, tearing off branches with its violence. Then it devoured the fields, the harvests, surrounded the houses and poured inside. "It was a wall of mud," gesticulates Fabrizio, who watched it flow past his face, just a hand's breadth away, outside the window. The 2022 Marche floods swept away everything in their path, including the lives of 12 people: the previous flood, in 2014, claimed three lives, channelling through the same valley, that of the Misa.

alluvione delle Marche del 2022
Civil Protection workers assisting the population © Protezione civile

Disaster risk: what the 2022 Marche floods teach us

In the Marche, on the evening of Thursday 15 September, the rainfall intensity recorded at the Cantiano rain gauge proved to be the heaviest in the past ten years, according to the Research Institute for Geo-Hydrological Protection of the National Research Council (Cnr): more than 400 millimetres of water fell on the Apennines, a third of what normally falls in an entire year. In Senigallia, "the water came from behind, like a wave," explains Raffaella, a flood victim; it drained towards the sea up to a point and then stopped: the debris in the River Misa acted as a plug, and at that moment the city filled up with earth, debris and the remnants of the rain.

In the flood eight years ago, the river inundated the southern part of Senigallia, burying entire neighbourhoods under the weight of the valley's debris and the ruins of homes: eight years later, the affected area is more extensive, so much so that in the first days after the disaster rescue teams struggle to reach houses, and entire neighbourhoods and hamlets remain isolated and forgotten, because the damage cannot be quantified. On the night of 15 September, the Ponte Garibaldi collapsed — a bridge already marked by problems that had compromised its use by heavy vehicles, and which was due to be demolished and rebuilt. The Misa divides Senigallia into two equal halves: where the lights go out, the city is submerged in darkness, and for days, as evening falls, the only smell is that of mud rotting in the streets. Anger hisses through the people, because the mistakes are there for all to see.

In the wake of the flood, Massimo Olivetti, the mayor, declared that the last stretch of the river — the one that runs through the city and burst its banks — had not yet been cleaned: "It was scheduled." However, of the funds allocated by the then Ministry of Ecological Transition in 2021, amounting to over ten million euros for measures aimed at mitigating hydrogeological instability in the Marche region, nothing was earmarked for the Misa, long considered a fragile waterway. According to the latest Istat analysis on hydrogeological instability in the Marche, 9,791 people in Senigallia live in areas of medium hydraulic hazard, second only to Pesaro, which counts 12,224 people. "No alarm was raised," the municipalities complain, but that is not the point: why do we refuse to read the signs of climate change?

According to Eleonora Gioia, adjunct lecturer at the Disaster Risk Reduction Laboratory of the Department of Life and Environmental Sciences at the Università Politecnica delle Marche, a distinction must first be drawn between the concepts of hazard and risk. "While hazard is the probability that an event of any kind will occur, and encompasses the physical aspect of the territory, risk takes into account both the physical aspect and the territory in which that hazard materialises: here, vulnerability can be physical — for example, the type of house we build in an earthquake-prone area — or social, such as an area inhabited by elderly people." In the discipline of "Disaster Risk Reduction", which aims to reduce the impacts of disasters using a systemic approach, communication is a fundamental component. "When an emergency occurs, risk perception is higher, and a 'window of opportunity' opens — which is not only an economic opportunity because of the aid that arrives, but a chance to communicate. This is the moment when we can research and study, and work out how to open an effective dialogue between the parties involved in risk — that is, between institutions, citizens and scientists." The key is to adapt the type of information to the different scales of the community: "if I have to communicate with a group of young people, adults and elderly people, I have different methods, which may ultimately aim at the same principle." To tackle these events, it is necessary to bring people closer to an understanding of the place where they live, so they can grasp what they are potentially exposed to and, accordingly, what mechanisms to activate in different emergencies.

The problem of illegal building

The flood is the result of homo sapiens's irresponsibility towards its own territory, in the view of Fausto Marincioni, full professor at the Laboratory. "Something much bigger is happening at the level of the general environment. Climate is what reacts first — it is the most dynamic, because we are talking about the outer layer of the Earth's surface — but significant changes are also taking place underground, in terms of water and at a biological level. We find ourselves having to contend with a physical environment that is adjusting to new equilibrium conditions, to which we are struggling to adapt." The answer to the disaster lies in a photograph taken by rescuers during reconnaissance flights over the affected areas, showing the Misa's floodplain: "The river creates these spaces to park excess water when an event upstream, like the one we witnessed, occurs, and the very existence of this space means that floods have also happened here in the past." The problem is not the river overflowing its banks, Marincioni explains, but the human beings who built in those areas without thinking. "Senigallia was built on the delta of the Misa, which is the transitional zone between the sea and the river. Floodplains are beautiful and convenient to use, but they carry a cost: hydraulic hazard." The territory needs to be 'fixed' through retrofitting interventions — that is, adaptation measures — because the damage has been done, and all that can be achieved is a reduction in exposure to the risks of these areas. "People should be educated about this. We no longer know how to read nature because we have developed a lifestyle disconnected from its cycles. The problem is social, not scientific: if we base all our safety on technology, we are deluding ourselves, because technology is a human artefact and as such can fail — and disasters keep reminding us of that."

alluvione delle Marche del 2022
Building struck by the flood in Senigallia © Archeoclub d'Italia

Once what could be salvaged had been saved, the rush began in the aftermath of the flood: time was short and the mud was treacherous — when it dries out it sets like concrete. The experience of 2014 taught one lesson: self-organised processes and immediate on-the-ground management of interventions are the most effective approach, because more serious measures follow the timetable of bureaucracy. Volunteers arrived in Senigallia from nearby villages, from towns not far away, and from organisations in neighbouring regions: children, young people, adults and the elderly worked heads down between one downpour and the next, and as the days passed the exhaustion began to bite. Spazio autogestito Arvùltura, the Brigate volontarie per l'emergenza delle Marche, together with the Brigate di solidarietà attiva, set up a base to coordinate aid and direct those arriving to where they were needed most. "With the means we have, which are not professional, we help people thanks also to our knowledge of the area and direct contact. That is the strength of solidarity."

At Caritas, clothing, bags, boots and soap were collected; at the Seminario cittadino, everything that could be of use to the displaced, or to those who simply had nothing left at home, was brought in. On "Vougghe Marche", a local entertainment page, people gathered to exchange information: where to go, who was available to help, where the need was greatest at any given moment — because in the age of social media, coordination happens online. The Ordine degli Psicologi of the Marche also mobilised to provide support and interventions for the population, because "the impact is catastrophic. The population lived through hours of terror both because of what happened during the first flood and because of what occurred in the hours that followed" — the hours in which warnings were being issued for the following Saturday, 17 September, when a second cloudburst was forecast. If trauma develops over time, explained Katia Marilungo, president of the regional Order, "the recurrence of the emergency does not make for peaceful sleep, especially when you are then hanging on weather forecasts, and therefore on situations that are hard to escape," she added. And three months after the flood, whenever it rains, Senigallia continues to fill with water: those who can afford to tremble behind the walls of their own homes.

operatori Anpas
Operators and volunteers provide support to the population © Anpas

In the psychology of disasters, Marincioni explains, a very clear condition is described: "It always happens to other people. After the tragedy comes the search for a scapegoat to blame so that everyone else is off the hook. Our job is to communicate things to people that they do not want to hear, to ask them to spend resources and time they may not want to invest, in order to prepare for something that we say is imminent but that they do not truly believe will happen, because disasters always happen to other people, never to us." And paradoxically, too much exposure to certain phenomena produces a kind of numbness: "we go from being completely unaware to the despair of there being nothing more that can be done." In the blame-shifting that politics performs onto technical experts, however, the core problem is that Senigallia was built in the wrong place and was not adequately protected. "It is not civil protection communication that would have changed its fate. Responsibility must be sought in our way of engaging with and living on the land, where everyone plays their part. It is fundamentally a cultural issue that cannot be resolved with technology, with an alarm or with the latest piece of equipment, because these things help but do not solve anything. We still have not worked out how to communicate risk more effectively," Marincioni continued. The crux of the problem is finding a way to "exchange knowledge" that also engages the emotions, because otherwise it is merely an exchange of information that adds nothing to what has already been said for decades.

Geomorphological fragility

As the emergency in the Marche faded from public interest, slipping into the oblivion of the press, Casamicciola Terme, a municipality on the island of Ischia, was struck by a flood that brought part of Monte Epomeo down with it, triggering a landslide that killed eleven people and displaced 290. Data from the catalogue managed by Cnr-Irpi show that landslides had already occurred in the area in 1910, 1987 and 2009; yet despite the fact that the maps of the Piani di assetto idrogeologico (Pai) record very high landslide hazard values for these areas, the conversation continues to revolve around illegal building, amnesties and neglect of the land. Despite the victims. For Fabio Luino, senior researcher at Cnr-Irpi and head of the Geo-hydrological Risk thematic area of Sigea, the Società italiana di Geologia ambientale, what happened on Ischia does nothing but highlight the extreme geomorphological fragility that characterises much of the Italian peninsula. "On a complex orographic terrain cut through by a dense hydrographic network, having built densely in areas that are poorly suited from a geo-hydrological standpoint has inevitably increased the risks for the population," Luino writes. The inhabitants of urban centres, he further notes, are unaware of the geo-hydrological processes present in their territory and should be prepared so that they are conscious of the risks they live alongside; to that end, a public exercise coordinated by the civil protection service would be necessary, exactly as happens for earthquakes. Awareness of geo-hydrological risk could be fostered from primary school onwards, rather than talking about relocation in the margins of disasters, because this "would be a definitive intervention, but one that is difficult to implement." For Gioia, the answer to these tragedies lies in prevention and in the lack of attention given to research: "Allowing more than one million people to live in areas of high landslide or flood hazard means considering the risk acceptable." Allowing people to live in areas where the risk is recognised, building new structures and regularising illegal buildings shows that we are comfortable with this way of using our land — "it may go on for ten or twenty years, but sooner or later it comes back to bite you."