Uniformed abuse in Milan is not an isolated case

Uniformed abuse in Milan is not an isolated case

Rights · ·

The video of a trans woman being beaten by the local police in Milan has brought the issue of uniformed abuse in Italy back to the fore.

There is a person lying on the ground on the asphalt, barefoot and with their hands raised. They are surrounded by three local police officers who kick them, spray pepper spray in their face and strike them on the sides and head with a baton. The violence goes on for nearly a minute, ending only when the uniformed men manage to handcuff the victim.

Contrary to what the description might suggest, this scene did not take place in the United States but in Milan on 24 May 2023, in front of the library of Luigi Bocconi University. We know about it for one reason only: a resident filmed everything from their home, and the video went viral, in part because of its brutality.

Reactions were swift. Mayor Giuseppe Sala described it as a "truly serious matter", while senator Ilaria Cucchi announced she would table a parliamentary question and that she intends to "get to the bottom of this affair".

Fratelli d'Italia MP Stefano Maullu instead expressed "full solidarity with the officers who did their duty". Silvia Sardone, the Lega commissioner for the province of Milan, accused the left of already having "the [guilty] verdict in their pocket".

Beyond the political controversy, that brief clip has brought the issue of uniformed abuse back to the fore — an issue that in Italy is never discussed enough, or is only discussed when it concerns other countries.

How the Milan local police beating came about

But how did that scene come about? According to initial reconstructions, the local police intervention is said to have begun at around eight in the morning near Parco Trotter in Via Giacosa. Some passers-by, according to sources from the Sindacato unitario lavoratori Polizia locale (Sulpl), had reportedly reported the presence of a transgender woman of Brazilian origin who was "shouting incoherent phrases" and "undressing in the middle of the street" (a circumstance subsequently denied by investigators).

The woman was then said to have been loaded "with difficulty" into a patrol car and to have feigned illness in order to escape. At that point a chase allegedly ensued — during which one officer reportedly even got a "flying lift from a citizen on a scooter" — culminating in the beating. Still according to information that has emerged so far, the woman was not held in custody but reported while remaining free on charges of resisting a public official.

The Sulpl's account, however, has not been confirmed by the city council or the judiciary. The councillor for security, Marco Granelli, announced that "the officers involved have been reassigned to internal duties". The prosecutor's office, for its part, has opened an investigation file for grievous bodily harm aggravated by abuse of public office.

Un fatto grave quello di stamattina accaduto nei confronti di una persona da parte di alcuni agenti della Polizia…

Posted by Marco Granelli on Wednesday, May 24, 2023

Racial and sexual profiling by Italian law enforcement

While investigations will run their course, the content of the video is unambiguous: there is no protocol that provides for an intervention of this kind. Or at least: none exists officially. Cases such as this one do, however, appear to point to the existence of an unofficial protocol based on racial and sexual profiling.

The expression, according to the definition of the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance (Ecri), refers to a "persistent practice" carried out by law enforcement without "any objective and reasonable justification" when conducting control or surveillance operations, driven primarily by "prejudices based on race, skin colour, language, nationality or national or ethnic origin".

In Italy the term is little known, and runs up against the perception that it is a phenomenon confined to the United States. This is far from the case: according to the "Being Black in the EU" report by the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, 70 percent of the Italian sample surveyed believed they had been subjected to racial profiling.

In UK, le persone nere hanno nove volte più probabilità di essere fermate rispetto a quelle bianche.

Nel rapporto "Esseri neri nell’UE", condotto in 12 paesi diversi, il 70 percento del campione intervistato in Italia diceva di essere stato vittima di profilazione razziale.

Unlike other countries, above all the United Kingdom, no specific data exist. One must therefore rely on news reports, or on accounts posted on social networks by those who experience stops motivated by racial prejudice.

The same applies to transgender people, who face a double stigma at the social and policing level. For foreign transgender sex workers the situation is even more critical, as Pia Covre, founder of the Comitato per i diritti civili delle prostitute, has explained: "they are continually identified, stopped and moved on, sometimes several times a day", yet they rarely report incidents for fear of making an already extremely precarious situation worse.

In this regard, the testimony of a transgender woman who was sexually blackmailed and threatened by carabinieri at the Levante station in Piacenza, which was shut down in July 2020, is telling. "If you don't cooperate [with us]," the station commander had told her, "one way or another I'll get you and send you back to Brazil".

Previous cases of uniformed abuse

In short: the Milan case is not an isolated one, nor is it the first to involve local police officers.

In September 2008, in Parma, 22-year-old Emmanuel Bonsu had been mistaken for a drug dealer and illegally arrested by a patrol of plainclothes officers in an evident state of overexcitement and agitation. At the police station the young man was beaten and subjected to racist abuse. The officers — subsequently convicted on various charges — even took a "souvenir photo" with Bonsu, making him hold a bag bearing the words "Emmanuel ne*ro".

In August 2015, in Turin, Andrea Soldi died during a compulsory health treatment (Tso) that was "invasive" and "violent", as the judiciary established. Three officers were definitively convicted of manslaughter: they had performed the restraint manoeuvre incorrectly, suffocating the man.

More recently, in February of this year, four local police officers from Sassuolo were investigated for the crime of torture against a man of Moroccan origin. The events date back to October 2021 and are quite extraordinary: the officers, convinced the man was a drug dealer, had beaten him on the chest and head while he was being treated in the emergency department for a hypoglycaemic episode. The complaint was filed by the hospital.

These are three well-known cases involving just one police force. Were the other forces to be taken into account as well, the list would grow enormously. But there is no need to do so, because every case of uniformed abuse in Italy follows the same script: aggression against vulnerable or defenceless people; conflicting initial accounts; cover-ups; entrenched institutional loyalty; and finally the downplaying, when not outright suppression, of events.

In this way, you start from scratch every time, without ever structurally addressing the problem of uniformed violence. Which, for a certain political class, is not even a problem to begin with. On the contrary: the problem is the laws that try to punish that violence.

Recently, some members of parliament from Fratelli d'Italia tabled a bill to repeal the crime of torture – introduced in 2017 with a delay of almost thirty years from the signing of the UN Convention. The abolition of the offence, as stated in the explanatory report, would serve to "adequately protect the honour and image of the police forces". Evidently, as emerges from certain statements by figures from the current majority, the behaviour of the Milan municipal police is something to be proud of.