Where does police reform in the United States stand

Where does police reform in the United States stand

Rights · ·

In 2023, US law enforcement has already killed 110 people, mostly African Americans. And civil society is once again calling for police reform.

On 1 February Anthony Lowe, 36, was killed by police in the suburbs of Los Angeles, in the United States. The man was on a pavement with a knife in his hand, but posed no danger whatsoever to the officers: with both legs amputated and his wheelchair beside him, Lowe was on the ground and, according to mobile phone footage, was in fact trying to escape by crawling. His family has demanded justice and cannot come to terms with what happened. A despair they share with many other American families. In just the first 40 days of 2023, 110 people have been killed in the United States at the hands of police. Often brutal killings that have brought people out onto the streets to protest, as happened following the murder of George Floyd and the mobilisation of Black Lives Matter. Protests driven by a common goal, the same as before: achieving a reform of the US police that already exists on paper, but cannot be definitively passed due to divisions in the Senate.

Violence by US police

It has now been 33 years since a Black taxi driver named Rodney King was first chased and then savagely beaten by three officers in Los Angeles. The scene was filmed and spread across the country, triggering a week of violent riots that left 64 people dead and thousands injured. A tragedy that nonetheless cast a spotlight on abuses of power by US police and also resulted in one of the first convictions — albeit minor — of officers for their conduct. It was thought it could mark the beginning of a small socio-cultural revolution, but that was not to be.

Black Lives Matter
A Black Lives Matter march calling for US police reform © Michael Nigro/Pacific Press/LightRocket via Getty Images

More than 30,000 people died as a result of police violence in the United States between 1980 and 2018, according to the journal The Lancet. In 2022 alone, 1,176 people were killed by American officers, an average of nearly 100 people per month: the highest figure since the statistic has been recorded. And 2023 began exactly as the previous year had ended.

President Biden called for action on police violence after the killing of #TyreNichols.

U.S. police have killed at least 115 people in 2023.

The GOP has repeatedly blocked a bill named for George Floyd that would ban police racial profiling, no-knock warrants and chokeholds.

When on 3 January Keenan Anderson died in police custody — a cousin of one of the founders of the Black Lives Matter movement — it was already the third such death in the Californian city in just three days. In 40 days, the death toll across the entire United States reached 110. And today, as in the time of Rodney King, the racial dimension continues to dominate. In 2022, African Americans accounted for 25 per cent of those killed at the hands of police, despite making up only 12 per cent of the population.

Protests following the death of George Floyd

At the end of January, body camera footage from the officers involved in the death of Tyre Nichols was released in the United States. The 29-year-old was kicked, punched and tasered in Memphis until he died, and the five officers involved were arrested and dismissed from the police force. The condemnation was unanimous; President Joe Biden described it as "another painful reminder of what Black Americans experience every single day."

Thousands of people in major American cities took to the streets to protest against the killing of Nichols, and it felt like a return to 2020. On 25 May of that year, officer Derek Chauvin killed African American George Floyd in Minneapolis, pressing his knee against his neck. It was the beginning of widespread protests — the largest in the US over institutionalised racist violence — which then spread across the world. The catalyst for the protests was the Black Lives Matter movement, founded in 2013 but which came into its own in 2020 as a well-established, if decentralised, force in denouncing abuses of power and systemic racism.

The protests continued for a long time, in many cases were suppressed with violence, and managed to mobilise millions of people and exert significant pressure on civil society and politics. The goal was always the same from the outset: to achieve a police reform that would curtail officers' power to kill and walk away legally unscathed. The same demand that has been voiced in marches and vigils over recent weeks following the death of Tyre Nichols.

Something did genuinely change, particularly in local legislation, following the murder of George Floyd: body cameras worn on officers' uniforms to monitor their conduct became widely accepted, and the recruitment of African American officers was increased in an attempt to curb the racism that typically goes hand in hand with abuses of power. The fact that the African American Tyre Nichols was killed by Black officers, however, has complicated matters.

"The policing system and culture shape officers' minds, pushing them to act in a certain way, regardless of the colour of their skin," explained Jeanelle Austin, director of the George Floyd global memorial in Minnesota, who argues that to change things the focus must be on the institution rather than on individuals. A call for a sweeping federal reform of US policing that, in reality, already exists on paper, but has been lost in the drawers of parliament due to political conflict.

Federal police reform

US police reform has a very specific name: the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act. The federal legislation was drafted and brought before parliament just weeks after the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis. The main objective of the legislation is to change the modus operandi of US police forces, banning certain practices deemed particularly violent and expanding the scope of officer accountability in cases of code-of-conduct violations. After almost three years, however, the bill has yet to be passed.

George Floyd Justice in Policing Act
An event on US police reform, the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act ©
Alex Wong/Getty Images

What the American police reform entails — the main provisions of the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act:

One of the aspects the reform text places particular emphasis on is police funding. Compliance with the points listed above is repeatedly stated as a necessary condition for continued receipt of funding at both federal and local level, at a time when in recent years departments have already faced cuts. This is precisely what the Black Lives Matter movement has called for, through the slogan defund the police, which demands that a portion of resources allocated to the police be redirected to social services addressing marginalisation, also as a deterrent to violent interventions by officers in that sphere.

The political battle over reform

The George Floyd Justice in Policing Act was passed by the US House of Representatives for the first time in June 2020, then again in March 2021. To date, however, it has yet to clear the hurdle of the Senate, and so, two and a half years after a bill to reform US policing arrived in parliament, US policing has still not been reformed, at least at the federal level.

Un corteo di Black Lives Matter per la riforma della polizia Usa
A Black Lives Matter march calling for police reform in the US © Samuel Corum/Getty Images

The bill's easy passage through the House was due to the fact that at the time the majority was held by the Democratic Party. The situation in the Senate is different, and the political battle that broke out over certain provisions of the bill has so far made any further progress impossible. The section most contested by the Republican Party is that on qualified immunity, which would seek to remove part of the civil immunity enjoyed by police officers involved in problematic situations. For Republicans, this would constitute a profound limitation on the activities of law enforcement, with negative consequences for public safety. Democrats and Republicans negotiated at length over this point, the former led by lawmakers Karen Bass and Cory Booker, the latter by Senator Tim Scott, but in September 2021 all prospects of agreement collapsed and the reform was shelved.

Memphis's skateboarders pushing down Main Street in honor of Tyre Nichols, who was known for his skills at parks here and in Sacramento.

The skating scene here is more scattered than Sac's, skaters say, but they told me they still feel like they lost a part of their family.

Following the death of Tyre Nichols in January 2023, calls resumed for the urgent passage of the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act. Democratic congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee announced that the bill would return to the House and be expanded with a new provision requiring police officers to intervene when a colleague engages in problematic behaviour towards a suspect. In the meantime, however, the composition of the House has changed, with Republicans now holding the majority. It is therefore likely that the bill, unlike before, will no longer even clear the first parliamentary hurdle. This is why a federal reform of American policing today appears further away than ever.

State and local legislation

The demands raised by Black Lives Matter in the wake of George Floyd's death have not fallen on deaf ears. Although parliament has yet to pass federal police reform, at the state and local level measures modifying law enforcement codes of conduct have multiplied since June 2020.

A year after Floyd's murder, more than 30 US states had already passed around 140 measures. And this trend continued in the months that followed. The interventions frequently mirrored several of the provisions of the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act, such as the requirement for officers to carry body cameras and dashboard cameras, restrictions on their immunity and a narrowing of the circumstances in which force may be used. In Indiana, for example, a state law was passed in 2021 banning the knee-on-neck manoeuvre — made tragically notorious by Floyd's death — while a 2022 law made it mandatory for members of minority groups to be present in continuing education courses for police personnel. <