The climate crisis is putting skiing in crisis. The case of the Lecco Prealps

The climate crisis is putting skiing in crisis. The case of the Lecco Prealps

Environment · ·

The climate crisis is hitting mid-altitude ski resorts that have been watching their lifts close for years. As is happening at the Piani d'Erna.

The last pylon of the ski lifts at Piani d'Erna, in the province of Lecco, was also removed in mid-June. Hundreds of people from Lecco, Brianza and Lombardy learned to ski on those slopes. At least a couple of generations. Chignolo, Roccia, Teggia and Bocca 2 are the names of the ski lifts that made so many descents possible between the 1970s and 1990s at this ski resort, a stone's throw from the city of Lecco and in the shadow of the celebrated Manzonian peak of the Resegone. What is happening at Erna's 1,375 metres is a fate shared across the entire Lombard and Italian Alpine arc, now scattered with the carcasses of abandoned cable cars and ski lifts. Rusted skeletons, pylons that stand as testament to a war lost by mankind in pursuit of an impossible dream: skiing at a thousand metres above sea level in the age of climate change.

piani d'erna impanto scii smantellato
The old ski facility at Piani d'Erna, in the province of Lecco, was definitively dismantled on 18 June 2020 © Itb

Decommissioning of ski lifts and "renaturalisation"

"The Bocca 2 ski lift at Piani d'Erna last operated in 2005 and is one of many facilities between 1,200 and 1,800 metres that have been decommissioned for years due to the rising snowline," explains Alberto Pirovano, president of the Club Alpino Italiano (Cai) in Lecco. Lombardy leads the Italian list of abandoned mountain resorts, but the lifts share a common fate across the entire Alpine arc: to bear witness to a climatic era that no longer exists.

📢 January #temperature highlights from #Copernicus #C3S:

🌡️In Europe, last month was the warmest January in our record, at 3.1°C warmer than the 1981-2010 average
🌡️Temperatures were even higher in some areas, up to 6°C above average

More detail➡️bit.ly/2RZSXtD

In Italy, a study by the Eurac research centre in Bolzano illustrates that with a 4-degree Celsius rise in global temperatures, only 21 of 87 ski stations in the Alps would remain operational, while with a 2-degree rise, 59 would survive. If the temperature increase were contained to 1.5 degrees, nearly 70 winter sports stations would be saved (though all of them above 1,500 metres). What should be done with these resorts now? "With the removal of the old ski facilities that have been decommissioned for years due to the climate crisis, a decisive "renaturalisation" of Piani d'Erna is taking shape," explains Alessio Dossi, environment councillor for the municipality of Lecco. And this is what is happening at many former mid-altitude facilities that are trying to reimagine their life without snow and without winter sports.

Gennaio 2020. Le temperature anomale registrate
January 2020. The anomalous temperatures recorded by satellites © ECMWF

The cause of closed ski lifts: 2°C more

The ski facility at Piani d'Erna is one of many located between 1,200 and 1,800 metres that have been affected by climate change, Dossi adds. A change that can also be felt "in the increased hydrogeological instability caused by variations in lake cycles and by mountains with no more ice due to warm winters," the Cai president in Lecco emphasises.

Since the 1980s, Italy has indeed been recording increasingly warm winters, as confirmed by a report from the Ecmwf (European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts). This is because at altitude the greenhouse effect is twice as strong as in the valleys. As a result, over the past century temperatures in the Alps have risen by two degrees, with the consequence that the ski season has been shortened by 38 days in just fifty years. According to the Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research in Davos, at this rate, by the end of the century there risks being no snow at all below 1,200 metres, and very little even below 1,800 metres.

🔴🌡️ Past winter (12/2019 to 02/2020) was the warmest on record in #Europe, almost 1.4 °C warmer than 2015/2016.

February 2020 was the second hottest on record globally, cooler by only 0.1 °C compared to 2016, as reported by our #ClimateChange Service.

👉bit.ly/3armdQ8

Climate crisis, snow and winter sports

Mid-altitude ski resorts are therefore increasingly forced to come to terms with the climate. And not only because this year winter was essentially absent. In the Alps, the winter sports season 2019–2020 was saved only thanks to the unusually abundant and early snowfall in November and the use of artificial snow.

As far back as 2007, the OECD explained that "the Alps are particularly sensitive to climate change and are critical from both an economic and ecological standpoint." According to Eurac, moreover, areas with snow cover on the ground could decrease by 62 to 84 per cent, leading to the closure of an ever-growing number of ski lifts and accommodation facilities operating solely for the winter season.

Piani d'Erna Lecco con neve anni 2000
A photograph of snow-covered Piani d'Erna from the early 2000s © Marco Locatelli

What future for mid-altitude resorts? Adapt, mitigate and rethink

There is therefore a risk of "therapeutic obstinacy" based on artificial snow. But the latter, according to a WWF study, reduces soil permeability, keeps it frozen for longer and hinders the absorption of rainwater at the end of the season.

Even more impactful are other methods, such as transporting snow by lorry from the valley floor up to altitude, when thermal inversions keep snow lower down than on the peaks, or even by helicopter (as has already happened at certain resorts in France). "Faced with these scenarios, there is discussion of reconverting the sector, diversifying the tourism offering, and pursuing alternative activities to skiing," Pirovano notes. But there can be no adaptation to the new environmental situation without mitigation measures — both for the climate and for the land. The imperative, therefore, in order to save not only tourism but above all the beauty and accessibility of the mountains in winter, is to implement drastic reductions in greenhouse gas emissions.

piani d'erna funivia nuova
The Piani d'Erna cable car, which connects Lecco to Piani d'Erna as a public transport service © Itb

The removal of disused facilities to restore the landscape

The dismantling of ski infrastructure is therefore not just the end of a chapter in high-altitude sporting history, but a first step towards a new life. As at the Piani d'Erna in Lecco. A landscape made more beautiful without the skeletons of old ski lifts. "It was a duty to intervene with a removal that allows the landscape to be restored, so that the Piani d'Erna can grow as a tourist destination and natural attraction," emphasises the environment councillor of the municipality of Lecco.

Now the page turns. New projects are needed with a view to a different, sustainable form of tourism. According to Pirovano, "we need to rethink the vocation of these areas: not just hit-and-run tourism, but also places for training camps dedicated to young people learning how to go into the mountains." To bring the mountains closer to everyone, the Cai is pursuing a process of digitalising trails, which will need to be made accessible in a sustainable way. To that end, "until 27 September 2020, every Sunday and public holiday, it will be possible to reach, free of charge, by shuttle bus, the starting point of the trails leading to the Piani d'Erna," concludes Dossi. Because the climate crisis demands a revolution, but also represents an opportunity.