A new technology that will change our lives is on its way: it's called 5G. But before we are “flooded” with it, it's worth seriously understanding whether there may be risks to our health and that of the environment.
Telecommunications companies around the world are on the verge of deploying the fifth-generation wireless network (5G) within the next two years. This innovation is set to represent an unprecedented social change on a global scale. We will have "smart" homes, "smart" businesses, "smart" motorways, "smart" cities and self-driving "smart" cars. Practically everything we own or buy, from fridges to washing machines, from heating to air conditioning, from milk cartons to hairbrushes, from toys to nappies, will contain antennas and microchips and will be connected wirelessly to the internet. Every person on Earth will have immediate access to ultra-high-speed, low-latency wireless communications from anywhere on the planet, including in rainforests, in the middle of the ocean and in Antarctica. But do we citizens really need this technological revolution?
What is not sufficiently well known is the fact that the 5G innovation will also bring about unprecedented environmental changes on a global scale. At the present time it is impossible to predict what the density of installations required for millimetre-wave radiofrequency transmitters will be — with wavelengths similar to current ones but at higher frequencies that have so far never been studied. According to estimates, in addition to millions of new 5G base stations on planet Earth, 20,000 new satellites in space and 200 billion transmitting objects are expected to form part of the "internet of things" (IoT) by 2020, and a trillion objects of various kinds will be connected to the internet just a few years later.
In mid-2018, commercial 5G at lower frequencies and lower speeds was used in Qatar, Finland and Estonia. The rollout of 5G at extremely high frequencies (millimetre waves) was planned for the end of 2018. In Italy, five cities are testing 5G. The "5G pilot" cities are Milan, Prato, Bari, Matera and L'Aquila, and perhaps some people living in Rome or Turin will see experimental 5G-based services as early as 2020. Everyone else will have to wait for the launch of service from the operators that are currently winning frequency licences at auction. So, from 2020 onwards, and in full development from 2022 onwards, all of Italy will be covered by the service.
Despite widespread denialism, the evidence that radiofrequency radiation (RFR) is harmful to living organisms is clear. Clinical evidence has been gathered through epidemiological studies; recent experimental findings have demonstrated a correlation between RFR and certain rare types of tumour in nervous system cells in laboratory animals; damage to DNA, cells and organ systems has been identified in a wide variety of plants and animals; all of this data has been published in major peer-reviewed journals across more than 10,000 articles.
If the telecommunications industry's plans for 5G go ahead, no person, no animal, no bird, no insect and no plant on Earth will be able to avoid exposure, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, to levels of RFR radiation tens or hundreds of times greater than those existing today, with no possibility of escape anywhere on the planet. These plans for 5G threaten to cause serious and irreversible effects on human beings and permanent damage to all of Earth's ecosystems. And it will be almost impossible to turn back.
For all these reasons, interaction between scientists, the telecommunications industry and administrators — the so-called policy makers — is crucial, in order to jointly govern a planetary project that exposes billions of people and that could constitute an enormous public health problem.
We will be increasingly exposed involuntarily
Certainly one of the first problems to be addressed in terms of (physical, psychological and social) health is that of the correct use of mobile phones, which should always be kept away from the body, at least 5–10 centimetres. The consumer is the key player in demanding devices that adopt precautionary measures, and it is the consumer who decides how to use their phone and which model to buy. They can therefore, through their own preferences, steer manufacturers towards marketing phones equipped with measures that avoid dangerous exposure.
Many information campaigns, especially in schools, encourage more conscious use of mobile phones, highlighting all the bad habits that carry risks. For example, using a wired earpiece provides decisive protection for the user. But with 5G we face a different problem: that of radiation at frequencies that have been little studied so far (millimetre waves), but which are plausibly suspected of creating the same problems as the frequencies used today — and which are, moreover, entirely involuntary, with no possibility of escape even if one wanted to. This situation, which will concern the entire globe, calls into question the responsibility of governments that are facilitating the implementation of this new generation of telecommunications without any critical approach, either from a health or a social perspective, reducing the issue to a matter of frequency allocation by companies, with highly significant revenue for governments.
5G exposure on the ground
To transmit the enormous quantity of data required for the internet of things, 5G technology, when fully implemented, will use millimetre waves, which are transmitted with greater difficulty through solid material compared to current frequencies. This characteristic will require each operator to install base stations every 100 metres, in every urban area in the world and wherever there is a demand to activate the internet of things. Unlike previous generations of wireless technology, in which a single antenna covers a wide area, 5G base stations and 5G devices will have multiple antennas arranged in "phased arrays" that work together to emit focused, steerable beams.
Every 5G phone will contain tens of tiny antennas, all working together to track and aim a focused beam at the nearest tower. The United States Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has adopted rules allowing the effective power of such beams to be as high as 20 watts, ten times more powerful than the levels permitted for current phones. Each 5G base station will contain hundreds or thousands of antennas pointing multiple laser-like beams at all mobile phones and user devices in the service area. This technology is called Multiple input, multiple output, or MIMO. FCC rules allow the effective radiated power of beams from a 5G base station to be as high as 30,000 watts per 100 MHz of spectrum, equivalent to 300,000 watts per GHz of spectrum — tens to hundreds of times more powerful than the levels permitted for current base stations.
5G exposure in space
Telephone companies are proposing to deliver 5G from space, using a total of 20,000 satellites in low and medium Earth orbit, which will cover the Earth's surface with powerful, focused and steerable beams. Each satellite will emit millimetre waves with an effective radiated power of up to 5 million watts from thousands of antennas arranged in a phased array. Although the energy reaching the ground from the satellites will be lower than that from ground-based antennas, it will irradiate areas of the Earth not reached by terrestrial transmitters and will be additional to 5G transmissions for the billions of IoT devices on the ground. Furthermore, the satellites will be located within the Earth's magnetosphere, which exerts a significant influence on the electrical properties of the atmosphere. Altering the Earth's electromagnetic environment may be an even greater threat to life than irradiation from ground-based antennas.
The danger to living beings and the environment is real
The World Health Organization's International Agency for Research on Cancer (Iarc) concluded in 2011 that Rfr radiation from 30 kHz to 300 GHz is a possible human carcinogen (Group 2B). From 2011 to the present, numerous epidemiological studies and in particular two large-scale studies on laboratory animals — rats and mice — have been carried out and their results recently published. It is also very important to highlight the fact that epidemiological studies (i.e. population studies) have found the same type of tumours of Schwann cells and the brain in heavy mobile phone users (more than three hours a day for at least ten years).
A recent study conducted by Philips et al. in the United Kingdom found an increase in glioblastoma multiforme, a malignant brain tumour, affecting above all the temporal and frontal regions. The author stated: "There is no reason to believe that improved diagnostic methods have affected (as some have commented, ed.) only one part of the brain and not another. After all, we know that the frontal and temporal lobes are the ones most exposed when the phone is held close to the ear." Further confirmation came from studies on rats carried out both by the Ramazzini Institute in Bologna and by the National Toxicology Program of the American Niehs, where the same types of tumour observed in humans were found — namely brain tumours and peripheral nerve tumours. In the latest report, published on 1 November last by the Ntp, increases in other types of tumour are also recorded. Both studies began more than ten years ago.
The Ramazzini Institute study is representative of exposures to radiofrequencies (Rfr) of 1.8 GHz, identical to those emitted by the many mobile telephone antennas found in Italy and Europe (far field). At the same time, the American National Toxicology Program (Ntp) laboratory also carried out a similar study in terms of the frequencies delivered and the type of rats used, but creating an environment similar to that of a "near field" — in other words, simulating the energy delivered and absorbed through mobile phone use.
The intensity of the emissions used for the Italian study is of the same order of magnitude as the most common environmental exposures in Italy. Indeed, the DPCM 8/07/03 sets the limits as follows: 1) exposure limits, differentiated for three frequency ranges; for example, for the frequencies of mobile telephony devices the exposure limits are equal to 20 V/m for the electric field; 2) an attention value of 6 V/m for the electric field, to be applied for exposures in places where people are present for more than 4 hours per day; 3) a quality objective of 6 V/m for the electric field, to be applied outdoors in heavily frequented areas and locations. These values are, however, measured as an average over 24 hours — that is, by averaging daytime and night-time readings — thus leading to an underestimate of actual exposures during the day, when telephone traffic is at its highest.
Despite the differences in field intensity, both studies therefore found statistically significant increases in the development of the same type of very rare malignant tumours of the heart and brain. The observation of the same experimental tumours cannot be due to chance, thousands of kilometres apart, in rats of the same strain, treated with radiofrequencies of different intensities. Although the evidence points to a low-potency carcinogenic agent, the number of people exposed is such (billions of people) as to represent an enormous public health problem: many thousands, if not millions, of people may be susceptible to biological harm from radiofrequencies. If we project these observations onto 5G, we realise that health will truly be placed in inescapable danger.
On the basis of experimental and epidemiological findings, we believe that the International Agency for Research on Cancer (Iarc) should revise the classification of radiofrequencies — hitherto regarded as possible carcinogens — to define them as "probable carcinogens" and bring about a controlled and limited progression of Rfr emissions.
The danger is real: caution must be exercised with 5G
The uncautious introduction of 5G, despite the warnings, appears to have taught governments nothing from the lessons of the past: we need only think of cigarette smoke and asbestos, to cite the most well-known examples. It took decades before people realised that the early warnings about smoking and asbestos were well-founded.
For our part, we can already take individual measures right away: everyone should use wired earphones (wireless ones offer no protection against waves) or a speakerphone; pregnant women should use their mobile phone only for urgent calls, and always keep them brief; children should not be allowed to use mobile phones before the age of 12; switch off your phone or put it in aeroplane mode at night (never leave it switched on under the pillow or on the bedside table); switch off the wifi router at night and when not in use; do not keep the phone in your trouser pocket or close to your chest. I could go on, but the broader message is: let us limit our exposure.
We recommend that the government modify the current monitoring system — that is, that measurements of exposure in homes no longer be taken on the basis of a 24-hour average, as per the recent regulation, but that they be carried out, as was once the case, on a point-in-time basis, so that the limit of 6 volts per metre is never exceeded at any point during the entire day, even marginally. At night there is no telephone traffic, and this means that the average does not correspond to the actual exposures to which people have been involuntarily subjected during the day. As regards 5G, governments should take their time and await thorough assessments of the risks posed by this innovative technology. Citizens need to understand whether or not institutions are on their side — that is, on the side of the most vulnerable.
What are the costs and benefits of 5G technology
Well-being — di Fiorella Belpoggi
A new technology that will change our lives is on its way: it's called 5G. But before we are “flooded” with it, it's worth seriously understanding whether there may be risks to our health and that of the environment.