Glyphosate has been authorised until 2022; now it is time to accelerate scientific research to prove how harmful it is to human health and the health of the planet. An interview with Fiorella Belpoggi of the Ramazzini Institute in Bologna.
Dr Fiorella Belpoggi of the Ramazzini Institute in Bologna
Before the vote of the Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed (Paff), Belpoggi decided to release the results of a pilot study ahead of the official publication of the research, because her conscience compelled her to do so. Because it was right that Italian Agriculture Minister Maurizio Martina should "know" the significance of the moment, given that an exposure of just three months to glyphosate is already "capable of altering certain significant biological parameters relating above all to markers associated with sexual development, genotoxicity and disruption of the intestinal bacterial flora." This is the view of a person who is not only well-informed, but also free from bias.
First of all, we would like to know what you think of the decision to renew the authorisation for the use of glyphosate for 5 years, compared with the 10 initially proposed by the Commission. Are you satisfied?
Satisfied is a strong word. Let's say that five years could be sufficient both to restrict the use of glyphosate and its formulations, in accordance with the precautionary principle, and to try to change the system that governs pesticide authorisations in Europe. Furthermore, our aim would be to produce, through new long-term scientific research, more robust and meaningful data that would allow a more certain assessment of the compound. In five years' time, we would not want to find ourselves back at square one — that is, in a state of uncertainty and unable to ban the compound due to a lack of adequate data.
Do you think five years are enough for a total phase-out? There is already talk of an additional two years to be factored in for the disposal of stockpiles in the event that glyphosate is actually banned in Europe in 2022…
Yes, I think that five years not only can be, but must be, sufficient to definitively characterise the risk associated with glyphosate, and also to revise the rules governing risk quantification in Europe, starting with the guidelines on endocrine disruptors. As well as providing for the possibility that studies intended to demonstrate the safety of a new product are not funded by industry, but coordinated and overseen by a third-party body, such as the European Food Safety Authority, which would entrust them to independent scientific institutions.
Why did you choose to release some results from the pilot study conducted by the Ramazzini Institute prior to the official publication of the research? In what way do you think this choice influenced Italy's vote?
I must be honest. Given that the dose studied was the one considered safe for citizens in the United States, I was surprised when I received our data, processed by the University of Bologna, which showed significant differences in certain specific parameters of the treated animals compared with the controls.
The "pilot" study, preparatory to the long-term study, was aimed at obtaining general information on the possible toxicity of glyphosate and the formulation Roundup (produced by Monsanto, ed.) at different stages of life: neonatal, childhood and adolescence. And above all at identifying possible biological exposure markers. As mentioned, both glyphosate and Roundup were tested at a single dose, corresponding to the acceptable daily intake of glyphosate currently permitted in the United States, equal to 1.75 mg/kg/bw.
In light of the results obtained, we can anticipate that glyphosate and Roundup, even at doses considered safe and over a relatively short period of exposure — corresponding roughly to a 90-day toxicity study, that is, in terms of equivalent human age, from embryonic life to 18 years of age — are capable of altering certain significant biological parameters relating above all to markers associated with sexual development, genotoxicity and disruption of the intestinal bacterial flora.
The study of other important parameters, such as transcriptomics for the mammary gland, kidney and liver, as well as the study of hormonal profiles in the blood and chromosomal alterations in sperm, is still ongoing. The "pilot" study, precisely because of its characteristics and aims, does not resolve the uncertainties regarding the carcinogenicity of glyphosate raised by the various agencies, but it certainly highlights equally serious health effects, which could also manifest as long-term oncological conditions and which, considering the global spread of this herbicide, could afflict an enormous number of people. For this reason we felt a responsibility to communicate our data (which have already been submitted for publication) both to our Agriculture Minister and to the media at various public conferences, as well as to citizens. I cannot say how much our data may have influenced the decision at European level; what is certain is that, given the credibility and social responsibility we have demonstrated over 40 years of activity, our data do not go unnoticed.
How will the global study be conducted, and what does it need in order to get started, for example in terms of funding and coordination with other international scientific partners? The integrated and global study on glyphosate needs, above all, funds that the Ramazzini Institute plans to raise through a worldwide crowdfunding campaign. In terms of collaborations, since we need to study many aspects of glyphosate toxicity (microbiome, endocrine disruption, neurotoxicity), we will have at our disposal a solid network of scientific collaborations, both national and international. Overall coordination will be entrusted to the Ramazzini Institute.
Do you think that the international campaign fighting to stop glyphosate could open up a war on multiple fronts against the cocktail of pesticides (and therefore in favour of sustainable agriculture) that very often has even more serious effects on public health, as documented in Argentina? The scientific awareness that it is necessary to study not only active ingredients but also, and above all, the commercial formulations of various compounds is now well established, and the issue is a priority. To arrive at an effective risk assessment, the only way is to study what is present in the general environment, namely cocktails of chemical compounds — often at low doses. I believe that our pilot study, as well as the crowdfunding campaign for the integrated study, can provide a solid basis for a better analysis of risk; it should be borne in mind, for example, that in our study, at the same dose, glyphosate had statistically significant effects above all in the Roundup mixture.
How much glyphosate is used in Italy? Does the fact that we do not grow GMO seeds protect us in some way from the worst effects?
It is one of the most widely used herbicides in the world. In the United States it is present in more than 750 products intended for intensive crops — in particular GMO crops that have had resistance to it incorporated into them — as well as for vegetable gardens and gardening. In 2013, global production of glyphosate reached around 700,000 tonnes, and the trend is unfortunately set to grow in the coming years; it is estimated that by 2020 demand will reach one million tonnes. In Italy, glyphosate is used in many (non-GMO) crops as a total, non-selective herbicide — phytotoxic, that is, to all plants.
It is worth remembering, however, that not all the seeds used in Italy for the production of commercial food come from Italian sources. A considerable share arrives from foreign markets that have different regulations and legal limits from our own. The 2016 report from the Institute for Environmental Protection and Research revealed that surface and groundwater are contaminated by aminomethylphosphonic acid — the main metabolite, which is very similar in chemical structure to glyphosate — thereby increasing the possible sources to which humans could be exposed.
What can a person do to protect themselves from exposure to glyphosate? Glyphosate is used everywhere in agriculture, but also in the general environment: in parks, in gardens, on railways. This is despite the fact that Italy is one of the first European countries to have regulated and restricted its use. Choosing products that have not been treated with pesticides can lower the risks, but cannot eliminate them entirely, given that rivers and irrigation water contain residues of glyphosate and many other pesticides.
Eliminating the risk of encountering glyphosate is impossible, and it will take decades to rid ourselves of it even if it were to be banned — precisely because glyphosate can be present in imported foods, such as those arriving from Canada that contain durum wheat heavily contaminated during the drying process, which is carried out artificially using glyphosate.
Fiorella Belpoggi: 5 years are enough to prove that glyphosate is carcinogenic
Environment — di Tommaso Perrone
Glyphosate has been authorised until 2022; now it is time to accelerate scientific research to prove how harmful it is to human health and the health of the planet. An interview with Fiorella Belpoggi of the Ramazzini Institute in Bologna.