Why Vicenza could no longer be a Unesco World Heritage site

Why Vicenza could no longer be a Unesco World Heritage site

Culture & lifestyle · ·

It will shortly be assessed whether Vicenza should be removed from Unesco's World Heritage List. The reason: building abuse has disfigured the Palladian landscape.

If Italy continues to pay no attention to its Unesco sites, it could one day lose its top ranking among World Heritage locations. Were Vicenza to be expelled from the World Heritage List, we could soon find ourselves back at 50 sites, level with China, which is also "growing" thanks to the 2016 nominations.

The reason for the Italian "demotion" threat is straightforward: the city of Palladio, which joined the World Heritage List in 1994 precisely thanks to the works of the sixteenth-century architect, is not properly safeguarding its heritage, which has been damaged by building abuse.

Borgo Berga.
The Vicenza landscape disfigured by Borgo Berga. © Borgo Berga

Borgo Berga, Vicenza's eyesore

The source of the scandal — and the blot on the landscape — is the eyesore of Borgo Berga: a residential complex not yet completed, which was intended to include homes, shops and offices, and which stands on the site of a former cotton mill, at the confluence of the Bacchiglione and Retrone rivers, a short distance from the famous Rotonda by Andrea Palladio. The buildings, which surround the new courthouse, are situated at a point in the landscape that the sixteenth-century architect considered fundamental, and which was for that reason protected by Unesco.

The building abuse, in no way obstructed by the successive municipal administrations over the years, was reported to the international organisation as early as 2013 to 2015 by several associations and civic committees, which sent documents and appeals directly to Unesco.

In addition to the building abuse at Borgo Berga, the committees also reported to the international organisation the US Del Din base, highlighting its environmental and landscape impact, and the Tav project presented by the Municipality together with the Chamber of Commerce and the Veneto Region in 2014, with the aim of building two new stations in the city (at the Fiera and at Borgo Berga).

Rotonda del Palladio
The building abuse is not far from the famous Rotonda del Palladio. © Getty Images

Unesco's response

Having taken on board the concerns raised by Vicenza's citizens, Unesco responded in June 2016 through its "operational arm", Icomos, the International Council on Monuments and Sites, with a statement that, in summary, amounted to: "Stop the completion of Borgo Berga."

The developer, however, has no intention of demolishing the eyesore. On the contrary, the Municipality decided to commission Heritage Impact Assessment to carry out an expert appraisal at the expense of Vicenza's citizens, a study costing 63,000 euros.

As Maurizio Di Stefano, president of Icomos Italia, pointed out, "After the inspection, which has a collaborative purpose, the ministries will have to demonstrate that they have taken on board Icomos's concerns and recommendations. If they have not done so, more severe measures will follow."

Villa Adriana a Tivoli
In 2014, Villa Adriana at Tivoli also risked being placed on the list of endangered heritage sites due to a case of illegal construction.

Illegal construction: the blight of Italy's Unesco sites

Italy's singular passion for mistreating World Heritage sites is sadly well known. In 2014, indeed, Villa Adriana at Tivoli risked being added to the list of endangered heritage sites, for two reasons: a proposal to build a landfill near the archaeological area, and the so-called Nathan lottizzazione, a one-million-cubic-metre development by the firm Impreme in an area very close to the villa. Following a request for clarification from Unesco and a study by a team of experts, the Mibact came out definitively against the development, while the construction firm was forced to consider relocating the project.

Another site notorious for illegal construction is the Valle dei Templi at Agrigento: in 2015 Ignazio Fonzo, deputy prosecutor of Agrigento, issued an ultimatum to the Municipality, the Soprintendenza and the Ente Parco, threatening to press charges if they failed to address the demolition of more than 650 illegal buildings.